I prefer Moonlight overall as well, but both are great. Since they made F street a pedestrian zone (I hope permanently), Amicas has the better view, but I prefer the brews at Moonlight (I like Soulcraft, but their contract brews for Amicas aren't quite as good).
And don't sleep on the new NY style Pizza Rio above and run by the Boathouse owners. Also great.
I'm a shitty and not super serious fly fisherman but I love getting up and fishing the whitewater park before everyone shows up, then hanging/drinking beer by the river while my boys play all day, then getting in a little more casual fishing before walking to dinner and more beer at any of the above.
This is why I'm fat and why I love Salida.
( @wd40, if you ever feel like sharing info on hikeable places in the area, feel free. I promise I won't catch anything).