The positive i took away is that the defense looked coached up and on pace to be ready for game 1. I saw multiple fronts including plenty of four man. I saw plenty of gap control and limited over pursuing. They keep their eye on the ball, had several tips and for scrimmage one there was sufficient swarming. I'd grade the defense overall a B.
My overall grade for the offense was a D-. That is mainly due to QB and WR play. I will skip RB play. It is true the TEs looked better but they are still not getting enough looks. OLine played ok for scrimmage one, especially against flashes of a stout dline.
I suppose with Sark being an offensive guy I simply expected the O took look farther along than it did. We gave too many reps to the scrub QB's imo. Aside from RB plays it often looked frustrated and at times disjointed. Also, with Casey being this far in the program i expected more veteran decisions. His int's weren't that far apart in timing and the one to Brock should have never been thrown. It was one of those that looked like it was intended for the guy who caught it. Casey was facing the north end zone on or near the left hash and threw into a crowd on the right hash. In brief, Casey didn't deliver today. He played as if he was unfocused, mechanical, and slow to read progressions. I know it was a hot day but that is no excuse as the first game will be at 330pm. When you pair that with mediocre WR separation it just was not a good day for the O. Maybe coach K and his defense are really good and simply didn't give the new QB's learning a new O much to work with, maybe, time will tell.
You're not wrong. We talkin about practice? Practice?
I'll admit that I had Casey as my QB1 going into today. He still is but Card definitely gained some major ground today. Let's see how Casey handles the bad day and if Card does more to build his case further.