I've been thinking about this for a while so I now present my longest post ever:
smokebomb's Austin Homeless Solution
First - I think it is important to divide the homeless up into 4 distinct groups:
People who are homeless due to circumstance and are trying to get out of it. This is the population that most people are the most sympathetic.
People who are homeless due to mental illness. I would argue that this segment has the a lot of sympathy from the population as well.
People who are drug addicts. This population has some sympathy but is lower down the chain.
People who do not want to conform to societal norms or who just don't give a fuck. This is the segment no one cares for and who give homelessness a bad name. Rightfully so.
This is important because we need to create a solution that focuses not on group 4 but groups 1-3. Fuck Group 4. We can help them but we don't have to cater to their lazy asses.
My solution (and it has been mentioned by many others): Use the Home Depot at I-35 & St John's the city purchased over a decade ago. We don't even need the building - just the parking lot.
With the Home Depot lot:
Allow anyone to camp out in the parking lot - draw out 12x12 boxes and let people put up their tents. Even offer free tents to those who need them.
Provide port-a-potties. Have them emptied daily. Maybe provide some outdoor showers.
Provide police patrols and implement quiet hours. Arrest anyone dealing drugs as well as buying in the parking lot. Kick out anyone who is involved in a fight or who is disturbing the peace. Make it safe but don't focus on making it a place for PIs & pot busts.
Provide dumpsters & create a trustee system to pay people to keep the area cleaned.
Have doctors come weekly & provide checkups.
Have social workers onsite daily to help with those that need it.
Eventually use the Austin City Library and provide training
The above ideas could be implemented in a week (except maybe the showers). Even if it took a few weeks/months, it would be a start.
Once certain people have shown they can live in the lot and contribute (maybe through the trustee system?), put them on the list for the hotels / city-assisted living. Give those that are actively trying to better situation a much needed boost.
With the social workers, maybe they can identify those that really need mental help and convince/guide them to the correct facilities.
With drug addicts, maybe the social workers can help them achieve sobriety. Even it is just one, it is a win.
For others, they will take advantage of the system. Some of these people will not follow the rules. That is fine - deal with them accordingly. Kick them out if they cause problems but let them stay in the parking lot if they don't. Some of these folks will not want to change their situation but if we offer them a place where they can live safely and not disturb other residents, everyone in Austin benefits.
However, this alone will not solve the homeless issue because a one-size-fits all solution will not work. Some people will use the above assistance while others won't. It simply provides a first step but a first step that the city council so far as failed to even attempt.
Now my Adler/City Council Rant:
Telling people to just camp where they want to and ignoring the situation was not a solution. It was criminal for the mayor and the city council to think so and then not do anything in the last two years to address the issue. The fact that Adler tried to make it a Democrats vs Republican right before the election was almost as disgusting as the city's inaction. However, it was even sadder that voters fell for it.
The best part of last weekend's election wasn't just Yes on Prob B, it was No on a strong mayor. This showed Adler that the city is tired of his schtick. Hopefully people come out in the primary and vote his grifting ass out of office or he will continue to push his bullshit, real-estate agenda.