When I say "pay up" I don't mean spend money stupidly. I mean actually bring his checkbook to the table and get the heck out of the way. Plenty of teams get FAs and succeed, see Bryce Harper, Turner (after somehow they cheered him), Freeman, etc., really a lot of the bigger signings. Maybe they aren't going to work out for 10 years, but you don't F your window because you don't want to MAYBE F up a future window. You have to weight all the factors. Guys can get bought out. Guys can be traded with money attached. Use your money wisely that you've earned, but you can't just hoard it.
Also, baseball owners are making money hand over fist. They always have. There is way, way more money out there. The team economics for top half of teams could probably support $300MM payrolls pretty easily.
It can't simply be "we don't sign long term contracts" that will not work out much longer. Unless we want more 37+ guys on the roster. That's the cost of doing business in today's baseball. And Crane got very lucky with Luhnow and getting setup to succeed without it. That's not happening again.
I don't hate the idea of Chapman with our pitching coaches. And if he's that cheap that's a no brainer. Guy is volatile, but you can't teach 105. You can teach some control and mechanic changes.
Montero was worth his contract this year. Early issues notwithstanding, I still think that deal is going to end up looking very reasonable.