I've been curious about this general topic for a while but have been reluctant to bring it up out of a sense that the more it's discussed among the group, the more "homogenaity of process" might eventually emerge, and I didn't want to suggest that anyone had been doing anything "wrong" or "meaningfully different from the group" or whatever, mainly because I don't think there's any one superior approach, but also because I didn't want anyone to feel retroactively guilty about following a different practice. Hopefully nobody would, but as we all know by now, Rep is Serious Business.
But I think that the group of us that continues to regularly play some or all of these types of daily games has gotten to the point where we're probably all pretty much set in our ways, and so there's hopefully little risk of me upsetting the apple cart.
Which all brings me to my broader inquiry - what are the "guidelines" that you all tend to follow when determining what, if any, rep reaction?
Mine feel pretty simple, but given that I'm the only non-rageface reaction to @Craftywidget's score above, I figured that this was a reasonable enough time to broach the topic with the rest of the group.
I will always default to the most positive/favorable possible reaction when there's any possibility of ambiguity or "mixed results" across games.
I give a Homer Drool for a 1 or a 2 at Wordle or a 6 or less at Quordle.
I give the Devil Horns (I'm not a UT alum, so to avoid the appearance of any cultural appropriation, I prefer to Hail Satan instead) for a Wordle 3 or a Quordle 7/8. I don't feel like a Wordle 4 deserves positive recognition but I acknowledge that this is a pretty harsh criterion, so I make up for it by being a bit more liberal with my Quordle standards.
I only award a Rage Face for a failure at either Wordle or Quordle and if there isn't a separate basis for a Drool or a Hail Satan. Absent unusually/obviously frustrating hieroglyphics, I don't Rage Face for any completed puzzles, only failures.
Connections has never factored into my criteria because of course it shouldn't, and I also ignore the geography games and whatever other games people share here because I don't know what's good, average, or bad.