Was just looking at that. After Charles Woodson in 1997, it's been pretty rough. Number of Pro Bowls in parentheses.
Maybe???: Newton (3 + 1 MVP)
Good-but-not-quite-Hall-worthy: Ricky (1), Palmer (3), Ingram (3)
Meh: Dayne, VY (2), Bradford, RGIII (1), Winston (1), Mariota, Mayfield
Terrible: Weinke, Leinart, Troy Smith, Tebow, Manziel
Non-existent: Crouch, White
Jury's still out: Henry (4), Jackson (3 + 1 MVP), Murray (2), Burrow (1), DeVonta Smith
Cam's on the outside looking in, but I guess it's theoretically possible. Current trajectory looks promising for Henry and Jackson. Henry's likely done as part of the "best RB in the NFL" conversation, but if he squeaks out a couple more 1,000 yard seasons it's probably a done deal. Jackson's gotta stay healthy and a Super Bowl win wouldn't hurt. Interestingly, Henry and Jackson were drafted 45th and 32nd overall. A lot of the rest of these guys were high first rounders.
To be fair, there was a big string of crap before Woodson as well. Heisman winners being bonafide NFL stars pretty much ended with the 80s.