My wife ordered about $1,000 worth of clothes from an online retailer. For whatever reason, the checkout process switched the shipping address to a house we lived in 6 years ago. No clue why because she orders from them semi regularly and it always arrives at our current address which is saved on her account. The FedEx tracking shows it was delivered on 3/28 with a picture of it on the doorstep of our former house. One of the items shipped separately and also arrived on 4/1. I still had a phone number in the closing documents for the person who bought the house, so I texted her to ask if she still lived there and if we could send a friend by to retrieve the packages. She still owns the house but it is now Airbnb and she lives in another town. She said the tenants had messaged her that 2 packages were received and they set them inside the house. The owner gave me the number of her local property manager (letās call her Karen) and said to contact Karen to arrange for our friend to pick them up. I called Karen who was out of town but said she would get them to our friend when she returned in a few days. It seemed simple enough but then Karen became slow to respond to my texts and calls and it took from 4/4 until 4/13 when she finally said she left it on the front porch for our friend to get. Our friend went and there was only one package, which was the second smaller package. The first one, which has $900 worth of dresses in it, was not there. I messaged Karen and tried calling her to ask about the other package. She was slow to respond but now says there was only one package. She says the other package was something else that got delivered to the wrong house and she took it to them already. I called the owner of the house who was super friendly and helpful and reviewed her Ring camera footage from the day of delivery, which shows our package being delivered at the house, and later shows Karen taking the exact same package to her car. She sent me screenshots. At this point Iām starting to suspect Karen is lying so I searched Facebook marketplace for some of the items and I found a person in their city selling them. Same dresses, same sizes, new with tags. I messaged the seller last night and offered to buy them. I was friendly towards her and offered to pay for shipping. She said she was selling them for a friend but they are no longer for sale because her friend wanted them back. I asked the friendās name and she confirmed it was Karen. Busted. When I explained the situation she said she actually worked for Karen but that Karen owed her money and they arenāt on good terms. She suggested I talk to Karen. I texted Karen about it, told her I have a pretty good idea of what happened and I just wanted the stuff back. I would pay her a finderās fee plus shipping if she would simply locate the items and return it to us. Then we could put the whole thing behind us. Karen said sheās on a flight home and she would contact me today once she figures out whatās going. My question is, if she refuses to give it back, do I have any recourse against her? I have video of her putting the package in her car, screenshots of the merchandise for sale on Facebook, and screenshots of the conversation with the seller in which she says Karen gave her the merchandise. Should I file a police report to report it stolen, in hopes that it would motivate her to play ball? Is this a small claims court situation? TLDR: 1. Wifeās online order ($900 of clothes) delivered to wrong address 2. Delivery address is an Airbnb 3. Airbnb property manager took the package and gave it to an acquaintance to sell 4. I would like to know if there is a way to get it back