I know this doesn't really fall into this thread topic, but it also doesn't fit into the 'doesn't warrant' thread, so I thought I would get the best response here.
I'm taking a vacation in November to Carmel, CA with my wife and want to rent a nice convertible. Before kids, I had a 2002 BMW M Roadster that I loved (still kicking myself for selling that), and since kids won't be with us, I want to rent something better than a mustang or camaro while we're there. I've looked through Turo, and found a BMW 428i convertible, and a Porsche Boxter S for reasonable daily rates ($106 and $140, respectively). Both, sadly, are automatic, but that is probably a good thing, since my wife may be driving at some point on the trip, and she can't row her own. I haven't driven either of these cars, before, but am looking for insight as to which we will enjoy more. Driving highway 1, and other scenic excursions are on the agenda. Thoughts/experiences with either, or better yet, someone that has driven both?