Thought this was an interesting exchange.
FTR, our special teams are not VERY good. Not at all. I do really like our punter, which after Chris Jones for 5 years and his pussy leg, feels nice. Good name too. I also think our coverage units and particularly our punt return rush unit is pretty decent, but the biggest part of your ST is the kicker and he's..... not good.
Additionally, our punt return portion of that team is fucking terrible. We rank 30th in punt return average. Our longest punt return is 21 yards. Our kickoff return team is better but almost all of that is based on 1 return which went for a TD and because of injury, that returner can't return for us anymore. Without that one play, we drop from 5th to 20th in the league. We also are 30th in the league in special teams penalty so when it feels like all we get are penalties in our return game, there's a reason. 27th in penalty yardage on ST. We're 27th in kickoff coverage letting up 26 yards per return. That's bad.
So, it would seem as a whole, we have a good punting game, we rush the punter fairly well and cover punts well (6th in the league). This is the best part of our special teams. After that, we're pretty much bad. We have a kicker with the yips and leads the league in missed XPs and is 24th in field goal accuracy, we can't cover kickoffs, we're really mediocre or below at returning kicks and we are one of the most penalized teams overall on ST. Not sure how Ickes looks at special teams, but it really poor analysis.