I think the technical legal dispute is whether it's an enforceable contract given that it is conditioned on the house settlement which hasn't happened. Don't think anyone can really weigh in without seeing the contract terms. But that aside, to the extent we assume it is an enforceable contract, I'm team Wisconsin here. If these players want to essentially be treated essentially like professional athletes (and despite what NIL is intended to be, it's obvious that is what their goal is) then they need to understand contracts mean something and are a 2 way street. And if you sign a 2 year deal, another team can't just come over the top and allow you to tear up the paper. If you want an out, negotiate for it (i.e., termination/buyout provisions). And I think we all appreciate there is some level of tampering from lots of schools via agents but if Miami is doing it at an egregious level with blatant disregard for pre-existing contractual relationships, then fuck Miami and I'm glad they are getting called out. It's probably inevitable we get to some kind of CBA eventually and disputes like this will only accelerate that.