I missed the 2nd quarter with kids soccer so watched that this morning. I watched that play 4 or 5 times. Unless Cook somehow played tremendous defense, I'm pretty sure that ball was picked regardless. What Sark said about Malik is exactly right. He tries to make plays when there is absolutely no play to be made. Nobody was open on that play. He throws it away we are at 3rd and 2 in FG range and likely get points on the drive. He throws the ball on the 4th quarter pic away instead of making probably the most boneheaded play I've seen a Texas QB make (with stiff competition from his throw against BYU last week) we punt it and it likely never gets that close.
I don't think anyone is "giving up on MM" as is the narrative by some on this thread. But we're playing for a conference championship and playoff spot right now. If this was an 8-4 or 7-5 season fine, let him make mistakes and figure it out, but we aren't in a position for him to work through this right now. A better D probably picks off 4 passes yesterday. Assuming Ewers can't go, I think we have to get Arch in for a series early next week so that if it's a tight game and MM is melting down, Arch isn't in a position to have to save us on his first ever series. Arch will never be "dual threat" but he can actually scramble if open unlike MM and move the chains. And he may very well make mistakes and throw picks not reading coverage, but if nothing else, I would think his pedigree would keep him from just pure WTF throws right at a defender we've seen the past 2 weeks.
More importantly we need QE back. We're playing with fire as long as he is out.