I'm gong to go ahead and disagree. I like the bar being set at National Player of the Year. It is fairly unambiguous and identifies a true superstar player during their time at UT. There is a LITTLE wiggle room since there are several awards that qualify, but overall it is pretty cut and dry and I like that. Maybe I would make an exception if a player led us to a National title
In basketball, we have only had seven 1st team All-Americans:
Clyde Littlefield - 1915 - 1st Team AA + world record in hurdles + All-SWC football
Abb Curtis - 1923 - 1st Team AA + Undefeated SWC champs
Jack Gray - 1935 - 1st team AA + Coached 1947 Final Four
Chris Mihm - 2000 - 1st Team AA, top-10 Wooden, #7 NBA draft pick
TJ Ford - 2003 - Consensus NPoY, 1st Team AA, Final Four, #8 NBA draft (retired jersey)
Kevin Durant - 2007 - Consensus NPoY, 1st Team AA, #2 NBA draft (retired jersey)
DJ Augustin - 2008 - 1st Team AA & Academic AA (only 16 in history), Top-5 Wooden, Cousy Award winner, #9 NBA draft, Elite 8
We've had three additional 2nd team All-Americans:
John Hargis - 1947 - 2nd Team AA, 2x All-SWC, 1943 Final Four, 1947 Final Four
PJ Tucker - 2006 - 2nd Team AA, Big 12 PoY, Elite 8, Israeli League MVP, NBA Champion
Jordan Hamilton - 2011 - 2nd Team AA, All Big-12
If you extend to conference Players of the Year you get: Kevin Durant (2007), PJ Tucker (2006), BJ Tyler (1994), Travis Mays (1989, 1990), John Brownlee (1986), Ron Baxter (1980), Larry Robinson (1972, 1974), Billy Arnold (1968)
Aldridge had a nice resume at UT and has had a great NBA career, but if you didn't earn All-American or conference PoY honors for your time on the 40, then I don't support retiring your jersey. I would retire half the players above before Aldridge, starting with DJ Augustin (Cousy winner) and then PJ Tucker (One of only 2 Big-12 PoY winners).