Like many of you, I don't understand why Chas is not our regular CF. I get wanting to test Meyers because he is/was considered to have a higher ceiling. At what point to you make that decision? Never? Given last season, that decision should have already been made. Now we're seeing what we have in Julks too. My guess is that Chas is the postseason starter unless he just gets flat beat out during the season, where these other guys are going to get some PT.
Many people on this board only seem to appreciate offense for position players. Maldonado is not a good offensive player. This is known. His defense is just okay. Where he excels, and obviously what the organization and the pitching staff values, is his ability to call a game and handle pitchers. We won the fucking World Series last year, had a Cy Young winner and the best bullpen in the league with him as the primary catcher. He had something to do with all that.
I also don't understand how some people can be so certain that Brantley is washed. He was doing well before he got injured last year. I realize the decline due to age can happen fast, but what are y'all looking at to see such a decline?
I don't like the 3-4 start, at home, to the White Sox and fucking Tigers. But, it's only seven games and we're currently without our most important player. We're a different team with Altuve and Brantley.
Offseason. Our roster has some holes; every roster in MLB does. We could have used a LF, C and SP. We signed Brantley to split LF and DH with Yordan. I'm okay with it. If he is what he has been then it was a great move. If he has seriously declined then I think it was a gamble worth taking. I'm okay with rolling with Maldy at C. Yes, he sucks offensively. But with our lineup (assuming our regulars are healthy) we can bear a hole in the 9 spot. I think he brings a lot of value to the team with what he does well. We came into the season with six legit starters. One being a fairly unproven rookie, but still. LMJ goes down and we're down to 5. So now we're looking a little thin. Should the FO have gone out and signed a SP instead? In my opinion, no. We've got some money left to spend this year. I expect the plan is to wait and see how the season shakes out. See what our record is at the deadline and who is doing well and who is not and plug the holes accordingly. I'd be good with that.