Astros currently have the 5th best projected roster in the league. 6th best offense, 9th best pitching staff. They are favored to win their division by 3 games. Their team is still very good. I think the vast majority of fans way underestimate how much impact the pitching injuries had. They had 7 SP on the IL at one point and still won their division. They also had the most negative impact player in the league in their lineup most days for a third of the season (Abreu).
The 2017 team won the goddam World Series with Mike fuckin Fiers leading the team in innings, Brad Peacock the #4 SP, and the corpse of Carlos Beltran getting 500 plate appearances. The roster doesn’t have to be 2019-level to be a contender.
A total rebuild like what was done in 2011-2014 is not possible these days because of rules changes and how other teams are run. Theres a draft lottery that makes it nigh impossible for a team to get 3 straight #1 picks. Almost every team manipulates their draft pool to try to get overslot signings in later rounds (the Astros were the first to really do it in 2012).
Houstons best bet is to try to win as much as they can while Altuve and Alvarez are still productive. They are going to have to rely on Dana Brown to draft/scout/develop their way to contention after 2025. But this offseason they are in a good spot. Shopping Tucker and Framber is them following the market. If they can trade away a 4 win player (with 1 year left) and release a 0.5 win player to add a 3 win player (with 4 years left), a 3 win player (with 2 years left), and an elite prospect, that’s a good move for both 2025 and beyond. And that’s the kind of package the Astros should be demanding. If Houston ends up trading Tucker for a middling package like Gil and Rice alone, that’s not a good move. But if they get something like Suzuki, Paredes, and Shaw, that’s a home run move.