Hocutt deserves ample criticism for the KK hire. He rolled the dice on someone that everyone was pot banging to be hired because he was the OC for Johnny F'n Football. It was a risk to hire KK, but at the time he was trending up.
No one then realized that KK just wasn't ready to run an entire program, recruiting and all. Hocutt probably knew better than to roll the dice on KK that early, but if he hadn't and KK had gone on to success at another school, he would have been run out of Lubbock on a rail. The Tech fan base, myself included, kind of painted Hocutt into a corner on that hire because Tuberville was such a polarizing failure of a hire (not Hocutt's hire).
KK was a roll of the dice, and unfortunately we crapped out on that roll. So I give Hocutt a pass on that hire for all the reasons I state above.
I think it's too early to make a summary judgement on Wells & his staff. Yes, there were some head scratching moments this season, but I wasn't at the practices, in the film room, or on the sidelines during the game. And the defense, that was already pretty thin depth-wise, was decimated by injuries. So I am going to give him and his staff the benefit of the doubt for this season. But he needs to show real improvement next year before we decide Hocutt has gone 0-2 on football head coaching hires at Tech.
Now, Beard was a no-brainer. Even the worst AD in America would have known to go after Beard as soon as Tubbs left for Memphis, regardless if Beard just signed a big contract at another school two weeks prior. The credit I give to Hocutt for the Beard hire was to not be resigned to the fact he was just hired by UNLV and to go after him anyway. But I don't give him credit for the Beard hire in as far as he could see talent there that no one else could. Hell, we all knew Beard was the guy to get. I wanted him before Tubbs left and UNLV hired him...so did many others. It was the no-brainer hire of all no-brainer hires.