The above is correct. Lots of appreciation in Badger-land for Chryst and some shock when he was let go, but not shocking to many closer to the athletic department. Chryst was a good fit for a while as an alumnus, one who's coaching philosophy matched the existing blueprint, and the fact that he looks like every dad in the state of WI with his sweatshirt and cap on. The problem was, as identified above, lack of emphasis on recruiting and the writing on the wall that we may get crushed going into the new world of NIL and transfer portal continuing down that path. And who knows where conference realignment goes in the coming years - athletic departments cannot afford to become an also-ran these days or they risk some form of to-be-conceived-of relegation.
Prior to the Fickell buzz, even into last night, I think most of WI saw Jim Leonard as the likely successor at 85% and the field at 15%. Fickell's name came up along with the other 6 or so usual suspects that always get mentioned and you never think are serious candidates.
I don't follow coaches nearly as closely as many here on Surly, but I've been impressed with Fickell and hoped he'd end up at Texas after the Herman firing or, probably a better fit, at Wisconsin.
Another thing to note is our AD is 1.5 yrs in, so while this appears to be a very good hire, there's also likely a dash of a new AD wanting to put his own imprint on the program and not doing what everyone expected (hiring Leonard). Kudos to him for getting it done. UW flies under the radar a bit, but it has a surprisingly large (top 15ish) athletic budget and they're looking for results.
My two remaining questions:
- Most suspect tOSU is Fickell's dream job. How long does UW keep him if he pans out? If he gets snagged by tOSU in the future, presumably that means UW has been doing very well, in which case I wouldn't be too upset.
- What happens with Leonard? He demonstrated considerable loyalty over the years to the UW program and was seemingly walking into his dream job. Now that's not the case. There will be a lot of questions about when and how he was made aware. Wisconsinites love Jim Leonard. CFB has become a cold business - we all get that, but some of us in or from WI still yearn for the good ol' days where we think things like loyalty, integrity, etc existed in college athletics.
Bringing this discussion back to UT... From a UW board asking why they were caught off guard on this hire and reports that Mrs. Fickell took a flight or two to Madison:
Post: Who the hell was supposed to be tracking flights?
Reply: Honestly we’re not very good at this coaching change thing. Auburn, Tennessee, Texas, those guys are pros at this.