Correct. And if you don't pay your premiums on time, that goes into the sauce as well. Guess the carriers share that info, just like claims.
It's still my experience that USAA's rates are still pretty good in most instances that we run up against them. It's still a better place to be than Allstate, Farmers, State Farm, etc.
Chubb is one of a handful of companies in the high net worth/luxury insurance space. They're not typical insurance companies. They write big checks and ask questions later. They usually cost more up front but are worth their weight in gold in that they'll pay more on claims and will look for coverage for clients as opposed to looking for ways to NOT pay claims, like so many of the other companies.
The problem is that not everybody qualifies for them. Chubb just recently increased their minimum primary home value from $500K to $2M in Texas. This is a seismic change in appetite for them. Not sure if this is a permanent change or if they'll lower that once things stabilize -- if they stabilize. Maybe they drop back to $1M but I doubt they go all the way back to $500K.
I've heard that about Goosehead that they charge like $50 or something just to look around for you. What you should do is look for boutique local independent agents in your town or city or you can go the big broker route like us (HUB International/HUB Private Client), Willis or Marsh. None of those will cost you anything as we get paid by the carrier IF we write policies for you. Higginbotham is a large Texas-only broker that handles all kinds of insurance. Stay away from anybody that is going to charge you for ANYTHING to shop rates/carriers for you because you don't have to.
If you're in a $2M or more home you can go to the HNW carriers' websites and do their "Find an Agent" thing by your Zip Code. Be adviseed companies currently writing HNW business are Chubb, Cincinnati, Berkley One and PURE. Chubb and Cincinnati's mins in Texas are $2M (Cincinnati has an Executive product that is very good that starts at $1M), PURE is now $3M and Berkley is $5M.
Our main non-HNW markets now are Travelers and Safeco. I think you can also find independent agents by doing the same thing on their carrier websites.