I would agree his recruiting has actually been pretty good, but I have to disagree on a few issues: 1) The way we ended 2019, there is no way we belonged in the tourney, I think we were completely and fairly slotted in the right spot. If we had gotten hot near the end, maybe one can argue it's a different story/closer case but we did the opposite. 2) I think the most obvious thing from many years with his coaching is that Shaka simply isn't an innovative or even average offensive coach. I don't need to regurgitate stat after stat, virtually anyone with the eye test alone probably can agree with that statement. You also have some players that are not elite at something doing that too often offensively, while players elite at something else are not being used that way enough.
But for me, the real issue is that the players brought to campus are not developed well enough, and that translates to results never seeming to match the talent level. I could understand a middling record if our talent was subpar, but I just don't believe that has been the case.
He's coached Texas recently to 8-10 (6th), 8-10 (6th), 9-9 (Tied for third I think), and right now 9-6 (5th). Granted, this is a very tough conference, but this a 34-35 conference record recently, and anyone can see the recent recruiting Big 12 ranks (2nd, 3rd, 10th because Greg Brown was the only signee, but I'd still say that's solid, and 2nd). So for me, the real question is if we can find another coach that can maintain, improve, or not go down too much with recruiting talent, but actually coach them to a higher level of performance. I'd love to hear who that coach might be, because I admit I am sometimes thinking about this more often than I should (when I am supposed to be focused on other things). Really...love to hear it, lol.
We all know we are a football school, but I still think the basketball program can reasonably fight for the Big 12 title a lot of years and be a perennial tourney participant...with occasional deep runs with the right combination of luck and talent, etc. I don't reasonably expect a routine Final Four contender (but it would be nice to end up with a nice Baylor run or in a dream world have two decades of Kansas...) whereas in football I would have higher expectations.