Sorry, was distracted by other things and frankly tired and frustrated by this argument so left it alone for a day.
Ok, first you show a graph that is comparing pneumonia as a percentage of total deaths. That's faulty for this instance because official covid19 deaths have pushed the total deaths way higher than normal as well as the covid deaths classified as pneumonia. So the overall percentage of total deaths wouldn't rise as dramatically as the raw numbers show. You say the data I got from the CDC is faulty but you haven't shown why or given any data that refutes it. You need to bring the exact raw data for total pneumonia deaths for 2020 and the total deaths from the last 5 or so years. Find those numbers that differ from the CDC numbers I used and we'll go from there.
And again, I'm not saying the state or localities are intentionally under-reporting covid deaths as pneumonia. I 100 percent think it's a function of the suppressing of tests especially in the first months of the pandemic. We still are in a situation where we don't have enough tests to test the living that need it and the deceased that died outside the hospital and never received tests. As far as I know no dead bodies brought to the morgue are being tested in Texas or anywhere else. That's where I believe the total covid deaths are being hidden. Without tests for positive confirmation the MEs are classifying as pneumonia because that's what the symptoms are. Therefore you have a situation where people either too poor or underinsured to go to the hospital are dying of covid and not being counted.
Now, the CDC numbers I found I documented earlier and as of May 29th Texas was 1,777 pneumonia deaths over their average for the previous 5 total years. Those years had an annual low of approx 2700 and a high of approx 3500. Texas is at approx 5000 as of May 29.
Now the question is what is the typical pace of pneumonia deaths in Texas in a normal year? We know in no year has Texas had anywhere near 5000 for the entire year much less by May 29, but what's the range Texas usually has by the end of May? 50 percent of total? 60? 35? That information would give us an idea of just how many deaths from covid are being misclassified as pneumonia.
For example, If you assume in a normal year Texas hits 50 percent of it's pneumonia deaths in a year by the end of May then the normal range should be about 1350 to 1750 pneumonia deaths. According to the CDC Texas is at 5000 in 2020. That would be approximately 3250 to 3650 covid19 deaths misclassified as pneumonia. Given Texas has reported about 1600 official covid deaths so far that's potentially a very large amount to be wrong by. So not 4-5 times the amount like the reddit article said but realistically 2-3 times.