I'm disappointed just like everyone else, but the logic in choosing Bama right now is solid. Tommy likely had a committable offer with Bama until signing day. I'm not convinced it would be the same for James. Conversely, it would seem both would have committable offers here through signing day and would also appear they'd be welcomed should they elect to transfer down the line. Bird in hand with an elite program while your safety net almost assuredly remains in tact long enough to figure out if Bama is the right fit.
As for Herman and Co., they need to play this the same way Helton did Bru. Don't disparage or burn any bridges. It's poor form and doesn't provide any benefit. Play the long game and see what happens. Meanwhile, coach up the guys on campus, start winning consistently at a high level and put more guys in the NFL. And sure wouldn't hurt if the powers that be took a long look at our membership in the B12...