There are 3 very good teams at the top of the conference: Alabama, LSU and Georgia. There is one good team below that group – Auburn. The jury is still very much out on Florida. Sure they are highly ranked and undefeated but they’ve played no one of consequence. Their best win was over Miami. Based on the ‘canes other games, Gata is a lot better than Bethune-Cookman and comparable to UNC (in football anyway).
The situation with aggy has some parallels to Florida. Loss to Clemson says they’re nowhere near the top tier. Wins over Texas State and Lamar indicate they are well above rock bottom. Unlike UF, aggy has played a good team (Auburn) and lost in rather humiliating fashion. They shouldn’t be ranked and probably won’t be once the polls are in for this week. Historically aggy is the definition of mediocre and there is reason to believe this year will be more of the same.
What sits (mostly) below aggy is just dog crap. 4 of those teams have shown themselves to be on the level of FCS / G5 by losing to teams of that description. And only Mizzou @ Wyoming could be classified as a true road game. Tennessee losing to Georgia State and Arkansas to San Jose State, the worst team in the Mountain West are both going to leave a mark.
After those dregs, there are 3 other SEC teams that already have losses to lower-tier teams from other P5 conferences. Not only did Vandy lose to Purdue, they handed the Boilermakers their only win this season. South Carolina of course suffered defeat at the hands of Mack Brown and the Orange Slice Boogaloo. That is looking even less impressive now since the ‘cocks couldn’t match the obvious institutional advantages of Wake and Appalachian State.
Those who watched KSU beat Mississippi State saw the Wildcats seriously outplay their opponent but kept them in the game with butterfingers. While Ole Miss was already part of the non-P5 loss crowd, we need to add the Cal loss to the ledger. While Kentucky hasn’t added to the list of embarrassing non-conference losses yet, don’t give up on them. They close their season with Louisville so they still have a shot to contribute.
At least half the teams in the SEC would be near the bottom of any P5 conference and have proven it on the field. 4 of those 7 teams have gone down to G5-FCS level opponents – multiple times in the case of Tennessee. Kentucky also looks really bad but their schedule was weak enough that they were able to pull out wins over Eastern Michigan and Toledo.
They SEC is not a strong conference. They have a few strong teams sitting on top of a huge, steaming pile of manure that composes the majority of the conference. No one with a brain will argue against the strength of the top 3 in conference this year. But the image of the conference being strong is highly misleading and mostly false.
Even a mediocre aggy team is virtually guaranteed a bowl every year with 3 pathetic non-conference scrubs, Arkansas, Ole Miss, South Carolina and MSU on the schedule every year. The top of the SEC is formidable but to make the case for the conference as a whole, ESPN and others have to hide a whole bunch of weak to horribad teams. From the front it looks really scary. The rest of it, not so much.