Jump to content

Fud

Legacy Members
  • Posts

    9724
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Fud

  1. In the first 100 or so picks, I think you have to draft best player available within reason. You should be trying to land cornerstones more than plugging holes. Ideally you do both at the same time, but if it comes down to drafting the better prospect or filing the better need, you should go with the better player (assuming he's not overly redundant with the current roster to where he doesn't develop properly)
  2. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    Perhaps you should put out a 1.1 mock with a correction and an apology
  3. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    I mean, you can be sold or not sold on Drake and think they should have a different strategy, but it's what they're going to do. They're going to draft either Drake or Daniels, with an outside chance of Caleb if Chicago passes on him. If you want to have a somewhat realistic mock draft, it should included Washington drafting a QB In the very remote chance that Washington doesn't draft a QB, they'll trade back for a massive pick haul. Your mock includes trades, so someone should be trading up with Washington to then draft a QB if you have Washington not drafting one
  4. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    They're drafting a QB
  5. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    Well this went off the rails quickly
  6. I disagree on Slowik going forward. This year might have been a year too early, but he's got enough experience and next year would make sense for him to get a HC job in a natural progression, assuming the offense is good again. He was let go from the Commanders... along with Shanahan, McVay, McDaniel, and Lefleur. So what? Kyle rehired him for a reason after Collinsworth brought him on (along with other NFL guys) to help revamp PFF's grading system after Collinsworth bought into the company Jerrod will probably benefit next year as now being a "Shanahan tree" guy. One of the most popular OC hires every year is the passing game coordinator/QB coach for a Shanahan (or McVay, by extension) offense. Should Houston just promote him to OC if Slowik gets hired away? I prefer they also interview the PGC/QBC of the Rams/49ers/Dolphins/Packers etc first
  7. Houston had a historically bad run of OL injuries last year. Sure they should sign/draft guys if they make sense in terms of value or draft rating, but sirens aren't going off at the position
  8. Schultz is better than a jag
  9. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    DJ's list is usually the closest to a league consensus, if that exists https://www.nfl.com/news/daniel-jeremiah-s-top-50-2024-nfl-draft-prospect-rankings-1-0
  10. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    I think you can bump him up to a lock to get drafted
  11. So what’s really going on there?
  12. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

  13. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    Undrafted is hyperbole. Yes the medicals are an issue I'd guess 2nd-3rd, but you can't rule out a team taking him in the first
  14. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    Teams value players based on their talent, not on their team's accomplishments
  15. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    Again, you're taking a $130 million dollar dead cap hit in 2024 by trading him. You're having to serious cap maneuvering (cutting a ton of players, extending everyone who you don't cut) just to make that work Also, you'd be the only personnel guy in the NFL who doesn't have Herbert comfortably in the top ten QBs in the league
  16. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    Herbert would net something like 4 firsts, 3 seconds, and 3 thirds
  17. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    He's at-worst a top ten QB in the league for the next 10 years. He's arguably a top five QB for the next 10 years. Some teams wander through the wilderness for a decade looking for that level of QB. Also, the dead money from trading him means you're lighting next season on fire (his cap hit alone takes up over half of the salary cap space). You'd get an all-time draft haul for him, but Harbaugh doesn't strike me as the type who'd looking for a complete rebuild, I think he's hoping to win games right away
  18. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    The issue isn't getting someone to take Herbert's contract. Teams would give LAC 3+ first round picks for that privilege. The issue is the dead cap hit on LAC isn't feasible to deal with (about $130 million in dead cap money)
  19. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    It's Mel Kiper, but Newton to Houston is a weird match. He's not similar to interior DL in New England over the past two decades, he's not similar to anyone Caserio has prioritized in the draft or free agency, and he's not similar to the DTs that San Francisco had while DeMeco was there
  20. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

  21. https://www.tankathon.com/nfl
  22. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    He was extremely productive this year, and the weakness of the draft on defense should push the top guys up higher than they would typically go
  23. Jerrod getting hired away to an OC position would net Houston a comp pick
  24. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    Nix is much more likely than Penix Penix has medical concerns, isn't nearly as athletic as Nix is, and has a windup
  25. Fud

    2024 NFL DRAFT

    Penix not in the first is reasonable
×
×
  • Create New...