Comparisons with a little wish casting to 05
QB- edge 05. VY was aGod and the best college QB I’ve ever seen. Quinn Ewers is likely to be in NY for the Heisman ceremony and Arfh Manning might be an improvement on him in 25, so it’s not like this years team is hurting there.
RB- Big edge 05.
WR- Big edge 24. Biggest advantage 24 has.
TE- 05- David Thomas was awesome. We have 2 NFL guys in 24 so we aren’t hurting.
OL- edge 24? I think we have two first round tackles and I expect every guy on the line to be drafted eventually, but that 05 unit was good and cohesive. It didn’t have anyone as good as Banks, and the NFL prospects are much better for 24. If they play well and up to their talent as a unit this is an advantage, but who knows.
DL- edge 05 but I think we might have 5 draft picks on this DL. If Collins has a great year this unit will be as good as that one and potentially better.
Lb- edge 24. That was the weakest part of 05. Ant Hill is special and I think Gbenda would start ok that team as well.
Secondary- edge 05. That was a truly special special group. This secondary should be pretty good I think- but that might be the best defensive backfield I’ve ever seen.
specialists- edge 24-
headsets- edge 24.
Depth- edge 24.
I would never pick against that 05 team against anyone because of VY. That said- this team is really really good I think.
Will be interesting to do this again at the end of the year.