2023 FA Class
Aaron Judge- awesome so far- way too many years on it.
Trae Turner- $27M a year for a lot of years- 2.3 WAR in year 1, that won't age well
Carlos Correa- Signed a 1 year 30M deal or whatever after 2022 and was hot garbage in 23. Bounced back this year but that doesn't count b/c he opted out after being shitty in 23
Xander Bogaerts- 25M per for like 10 or 12 years. 4.4 War last year- 0.8 War this year- would you want to be on the hook for the next 200+ M of that contract?
Dansby Sawanson- 40M so far- 5.8 War- this one might work out- was only a 7/175 as I recall
Brandon Nimmo- 8/162- 6.5 War so far- trending to 8 for first two years- they might get value out of this one- depending on if you believe it is $8M per War or 10M per war
Jose Abreu- Nope
Carlos Rodon- Ha. Haha, Hahaha
Chris Bassitt- 3 for 63. So far he's at 3.2 WAR- half way through- not a disaster
Degrom- 5/185. I think he's pitched 17 innings so far in the first 2 years of the deal
Wilson Contreras- I like this deal. The Cardinals pitchers had a mutiny last year and refused to pitch to him. Things seem to be on track this year? 5/87. I was pounding the table to sign him. Figured LF//1B/DH and back up catcher with Yainer. Probably make value
Clayton Kershaw- Nope- hurt- more playoff suck
Justin Turner- 1 year contract- he outperformed it
Nathan Evoldi- 2/34 with a 25 vesting option. Fucking Rangers with the best signing of the offseason
JUstin Verlander- Nope
Michael Brantley- Nope
Max Scerzer- nope
Wade Miley- Nope
Kevin Kiermaier- good deal
Jsoh Bell- Cut
Brandon belt- really good 1 year signing
Greinke- Nope
Bellinger- good deal on 1 year
Nobody did as poorly as us. Not even close. It wasn't quite as bad as I remembered- but there are only a couple deals that are going to pencil out and some of the ones that were 8, 10, 12 years that look fine now are going to suck on the backend and be pretty underwater overall.