You know I’d keep em all right? From a talent perspective I saw nothing that says run a dude off. The new staff will prioritize skills and construction to suit their preferences so yeah turnover will happen.
The Weiner took Cortez from a mid 7 ERA, 2 + WHIP, a K/BB of less than 1 guy to what we saw this year. He also took Stewart from a near 7 ERA and 2 WHIP to valued CWS bullpen guy. Those were multi year guys so it’s not like we’re talking true frosh numbers. I’ve previously highlighted Kent versus Kennedy. There’s also some lucky shit. Imagine if Prager, coming off an injury season, misses this year. And that Witt, coming off an injury, has a big year.
I don’t trash Pierce like others, but I think you need to view our returning guys in the context of better plate discipline and a well qualified pitching coach.
You bet your ass I’d be happy keeping these guys: Borba, Kennedy, Galvan, Belyeu, J. Duplantier, Gasparino, Schuessler. Then you have guys that you don’t know much about that you can’t say cut them loose: Farmer, Cummings, Service, Sanders.
On the pitching side, I’d for sure be fine with Ace, Grubbs, Tumis, O’Hara, Lummus, Shaw and Harrison. Not sure on Hamilton and Servig. Based on profiles, I’d take Santos and Mercer too.
With a roster of 35-40 guys, some of them will be role players that includes dudes that never play or play limited roles in blowouts. You are talking about 20 guys or so that produce the lions share of the work.
Obviously, I can’t see work ethic, attitude, player goals, etc.
There is plenty of talent and production to choose from here. Assess what you have with incoming freshmen.