"Where does Jesus say I should love a random person off the streets?"
I mean....in literally the first fucking book of the New Testament?
I mean, it's not even a vague concept like "love" -- it's a literal and direct call to action. And does Jesus mean everyone, even your enemies, fall under that group?
In BOTH sections, the greek word is "agape," which is an action word, not a feeling word.
It's all one of the more maddening things about MAGA Christians: how on the one hand, they wave the banner of "I'M A CHRISTIAN!" more aggressively than anyone else, while running away, as fast as they can, from THE ACTUAL FUCKING SCRIPTURES THAT ARE THE DEFINING TEXTS ON BEING A CHRISTIAN.
There's no lawyering around the commands, FROM JESUS, in Matthew. The word used is agape, and it has meaning. It's one they don't like. But tough fucking shit, y'all keep telling us the Bible is inerrant, right?