I'm not terribly picky, as long as it isn't Dickel. That multivitamin aftertaste is disgusting. And that is especially sad for me, because I drive within 2 miles of their distillery a couple of times a month and could pop in for special releases, etc. My wife came back from Colorado last year with something from Breckenridge Distillery, I was all excited until I tasted it. Obvious Dickel juice.
I'm usually searching for the value/bang for the buck picks. Rarely buy a bottle over $60, and will regularly pay half that for quality stuff (OGC 114, EW BIB, etc.). Recently made a run up into KY to buy some KY only releases, and was very impressed with Old Bardstown BIB, unique flavor considering I had never tried a Willett product before. Apparently I'm a fan. Anything out of the Buffalo Trace lines is my wheelhouse that most new ones are judged up against. The hunt for something hard to come by without breaking the bank is almost as fun as the pour. Almost.
Oh, and as for shipping? Negative, Ghost Rider.