Mostly 3 stars, with some 4 and like 2/3 5*. Flood, much like Herman and Strong regimes, are either coaching the talent out of them, or they're lazy recruiters who go for the lowest hanging fruit with the occasional "hit" with a 3* (Goosby, Williams, kind of, Kibble will be, Cruz, possibly). Don't get me wrong, every team has misses, but an entire o-line (besides Goosby, and Baker for now) is not some aberration, it's a pattern.
Since 2022
Hutson - 3* (zero stars for me)
Campbell - 5*
Banks - 5*
Cam Williams - 3*
Goosby - 3*
Cruz - 3/4*
Robertson - 3*
Baker - 5*
Chatman - 4*
Kirkland - 4*
Stroh - 3* (zero stars afar as I'm concerned)
Cojoe - 3*
Neto - 4*
Agbo - 4*
Kibble - 3* (will be a stud. IDGAF)
Brooks - 4*
J. Coleman - 3*
J. Christian - 3*
D. Coleman - 3*
Yeah, Flood isn't just terrible at evaluating, the higher ranked recruits he had help with. It's a massive red flag of a pattern. It's no wonder our o-line is the Barbara Streisand of CFB.