No, he said "His recovery history from alcoholism is his biggest problem. He’s too lenient and forgiving when it comes to second chances because of how he got his second chance.." and you latched onto that phrasing ("problem"), I'm guessing, because of some emotional reaction. You've repeated "questioning someone's/Sark's sobriety" multiple times, so that's clearly your anchor.
I said I didn't read/take it that way. I think your "questioning Sark's sobriety" is a straw man that you've latched onto.
"The problem with/my biggest problem..." is pretty commonly used phrasing that doesn't actually mean the subject is a problem (in the negative sense).
"The problem with spending the holidays with family is that I eat way too much." "My biggest problem with the holidays is I spend it with family and eat way too much." Does that mean that spending time with family is a problem? Is it a critique of family Thanksgiving/Christmas? Of course not.
You overcommitted to what I think is a straw man, then you doubled down by acting like a douche, and now you can't gracefully back out of it. I offered a polite "agree to disagree" and you couldn't even take that; you had to come back with a snarky comment.
You're a lightweight and that's what lightweights do.
I was polite, you didn't take the olive branch, so now I'm not going to be polite anymore. I've got a flight to catch, but if you want me to slap you around a little bit more, I've got a few minutes.