I don’t think it’s anything about RT the person. I have found him to be super personable, upbeat and generally nice to be around. I think the players and their families generally like him and I would never worry about him embarrassing the University (horns down not withstanding).
I can just speak for myself and say that the lack of a real coaching search to test just who you might have been able to land before making a purely PR decision to hire a guy that had not had a lot of head coaching success, burned my ass.
I have this belief (I’m sure several of you will point out how unrealistic this is) that the University of Texas should not have a head coach who has not demonstrated consistent head coaching success prior to coming. Look at Coach Vic as an example. He is a really good head coach as shown by where he has the program and what he did with Mississippi State prior to coming.
It is true that my logic would have excluded Sark for example who, fingers crossed, seems to have what it takes. But, hiring any coach is a crap shoot and playing the probabilities is my preferred way of minimizing risk.
RT could very well become an elite coach. He’s not that right now hence my opinion that the University of Texas should have a head coach who is in effect learning on the job what it takes to be consistently successful. It’s a skill set and it’s different from being an assistant. There is a learning curve which I just don’t have the patience for.