Jump to content

JBJ

Legacy Members
  • Posts

    4827
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by JBJ

  1. Higher bar to clear, but a worse status. It's more like TPS, immigration proceedings can continue, but the hold prevents certain orders from being actionable. It's literally immigration limbo and is a bad system.
  2. I actually am as multiple discussions are going on simultaneously. He was in El Salvador already when the case was filed and it actually is habeas. This is more like the Quintero Chacon case.
  3. I've answered this several times. It's not okay. It's on purpose, too. You guys want me to be something that I'm not.
  4. This was kind of the point of my original post. This specific case is actually stupid all around. Democrats want it to look outrageous, Trump wants Democrats to look crazy. Both have been successful depending on what echo chamber you step into.
  5. Someome show me where his lawyers alleged there was no notice. I've seen this said multiple times. His lawyers certainly knew to file this case while he was being moved.
  6. I agree. I believe deporting someone under the A/S Act would actually take immigration courts out of the picture, but I'm not sure it should apply to current orders. That's ultimately what this actual case is about, right?
  7. I believe it was on purpose. They likely couldn't proceed with this case because the habeas case would happen first. If Abrego wasn't aware of this, his lawyers should be the ones in the Salvadorian prison.
  8. Forget it. I was meaning to leave anyway. I'm feeling sick at work, but this clearly isn't the place to discuss this topic.
  9. They also are used to contest movements of prisoners in general, not just deportations.
  10. Pretty sure Subliminal admitted he mistated that in his original post.
  11. I'm aware of all this. I'm not the one here spreading misinfo about habeas whack-a-mole and his deportation status. Since people are logging alts to neg me, I'll leave this "shithole" again. I'd love if y'all considered these two things: 1) This is actually the dumbest possible potential constitutional crisis. Mostly due to politics on both sides being more important than legal procedure. 2) There was an actual solution to this. Abrego could very easily not be deported right now and he could actually be having the trial everyone thinks he should be having (and that's due to Trump and not really due to the judge either - not his responsibility but he definitely should have told the lawyers to also file for habeas, it was clear in their original filing that they intended to).
  12. You cannot move someone across state lines without prior notice and cannot move them at all once habeus is filed.
  13. Yes. He was being held in Texas, I believe. They even amended their initial filing before he was deported, so they had time to file a separate case.
  14. I'm not disagreeing. His lawyers should have filed habeas and they could actually argue that and halt his deportation at the same time. Why do you suppose they chose not to? Incompetence?
  15. I thought his deportation was held due to a rival gang in El Salvador harassing his family? If I don't have all the facts, maybe I am wrong.
  16. I trust the judge's determination that there was sufficient evidence. I trust that his lawyers decision to not to further adjudicate it was for good reason. I'm not really into conspiracy theories. If a time comes to, sure, but this is not the hill to die on.
  17. Who ended up being right on that case?
  18. I've already admitted Trump is wrong. Now y'all admit this judge is also ignoring the lawful process.
  19. Judge literally determined he was a gang member.
  20. Not being an MS13 member and alleged child trafficker would help.
  21. This specifics of this case are a dumb hill to die on. Please read my original post. There's no actual remedy that's going to take place amd the guy himself is not a sympathetic figure.
  22. Yeah. Manufacturing cases happens all the time, and I don't have any issue with doing it. All I'm sayung is that if his lawyers wanted him here to adjudicate whether he was being wrongfully deported, they could have kept him here.
  23. No, because this is still a dumb hill to die on.
  24. I'm not okay with it. That's why I said this is the dumbest thing to have a constitutional crisis over. Even if the whole thing was manufactured by his lawyers to create this situation or something like it (which I do think the odds of are north of 0%), this isn't the right guy for it. I am a stickler for the process. I'm just applying it to both sides here. This judge should have originally told the lawyers to fuck off and file for habeus and we wouldn't be here at all.
  25. Above, he literally did and his lawyers decided to do something else.
Ă—
Ă—
  • Create New...