Jump to content

Thread of Statue Removals


Hugo Stiglitz

Recommended Posts

I'm honestly surprised that there aren't self-organized "Town Square Militias" in the Deep South that stay up all night, armed, to protect confederate statues in the downtown/courthouse areas.  I'm being completely serious, I was genuinely expecting it.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 1:36 PM, Lobo said:

I'm honestly surprised that there aren't self-organized "Town Square Militias" in the Deep South that stay up all night, armed, to protect confederate statues in the downtown/courthouse areas.  I'm being completely serious, I was genuinely expecting it.  

Expand  

Yeah, same. I'm wondering either they don't want to be called racist (they probably don't care) or they don't care.

I was super sad yesterday about the George Washington statue, and I had no idea that it was gonna be taken down. I wished I was there to cut the ropes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

StassneyHorn-I'm willing to cut you in for 30% of my new video game series, but you gotta find a programmer/designer as well. 

CALL OF DUTY:  CONFEDERATE STATUE EDITION.  

You basically get geared up in your camo and tac gear, get your semi-automatics and your arsenal, take two weeks unpaid vacation from the plant, and you travel from southern town to southern town in a ridiculously oversized F-250 protecting statues from antifa and BLM.  Sometimes you even go undercover and infiltrate their ranks so you can save statues beforehand.  Other times, you gotta fistfight, small arms, large-scale platoon size battles, etc.  Some towns have cops that'll help you, some have cops that'll try to stop you.  In some towns, you're vilified, in others you're a hero.  So there's a heavy mental element to it besides all the shooting.  And you dial in your friends and they are rival mercenaries also trying to get contracts to safeguard statues in other southern towns and y'all have to build up a resume and compete for contracts, and sometimes even have to fight each other if you end up at the same site.  And the final mission is to of course to save the Final Trinity, the three officer statues in each of the 3 Confederate capitals-Danville, Montgomery, and Richmond. 

I promise we would sell 250,000 copies in the first year to gamers in the Deep South and Ohio.  However, it would destroy the rest of their brand, so they'll probably not allow to use the name and platform.  Shit.  Anybody got any workarounds?  I don't know how the splits work on video games, but is at least a $10mm idea.  

Edited by Lobo
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's all based on personal opinion but some are taking the statue removals too far. But that is also a consequence of many tone deaf leaders of the past. When a group feels that an injustice has been systematic, their swinging pendulum is going to swing too far. This always happens. A few George Washington or Thomas Jefferson statues may pay the price of that.

If many of these confederate statues had been removed when we all knew they should be removed then the Washington or Grant statues would have not been targeted.

  • Like 6
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 2:10 PM, Lobo said:
StassneyHorn-I'm willing to cut you in for 30% of my new video game series, but you gotta find a programmer/designer as well. 
CALL OF DUTY:  CONFEDERATE STATUE EDITION.  
You basically get geared up in your camo and tac gear, get your semi-automatics and your arsenal, take two weeks unpaid vacation from the plant, and you travel from southern town to southern town in a ridiculously oversized F-250 protecting statues from antifa and BLM.  Sometimes you even go undercover and infiltrate their ranks so you can save statues beforehand.  Other times, you gotta fistfight, small arms, large-scale platoon size battles, etc.  Some towns have cops that'll help you, some have cops that'll try to stop you.  In some towns, you're vilified, in others you're a hero.  So there's a heavy mental element to it besides all the shooting.  And you dial in your friends and they are rival mercenaries also trying to get contracts to safeguard statues in other southern towns and y'all have to build up a resume and compete for contracts, and sometimes even have to fight each other if you end up at the same site.  And the final mission is to of course to save the Final Trinity, the three officer statues in each of the 3 Confederate capitals-Danville, Montgomery, and Richmond. 
I promise we would sell 250,000 copies in the first year to gamers in the Deep South and Ohio.  However, it would destroy the rest of their brand, so they'll probably not allow to use the name and platform.  Shit.  Anybody got any workarounds?  I don't know how the splits work on video games, but is at least a $10mm idea.  
Just so long as there's an accurate driving sim between each town and the F-250 is out of alignment
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 3:02 PM, Nice Guy Eddie said:

It's all based on personal opinion but some are taking the statue removals too far. But that is also a consequence of many tone deaf leaders of the past. When a group feels that an injustice has been systematic, their swinging pendulum is going to swing too far. This always happens. A few George Washington or Thomas Jefferson statues may pay the price of that.

If many of these confederate statues had been removed when we all knew they should be removed then the Washington or Grant statues would have not been targeted.

Expand  

That misses a salient point -- to remove Confederates and Confederates only makes the sin of the memorialized treason and treason only. 

The protests today are not about whether or not it was constitutional for the southern states to secede. They are now about slavery and racism.  DId the Confederacy and the Confederacy alone contain all of American racism and slavery?

Obviously, no, no it did not. Still, of all those whose statues have been pulled down, his is the most extreme in that he was pretty woke for his era. However he was responsible for attempting to expel every Jew from the Southern territory he had reconquered early in the war:

  Quote

Grant's decree was “the most sweeping anti-Jewish regulation in all of American history,” historian and rabbi Bertram W. Korn noted in his book American Jewry and the Civil War.

Though the 1862 orders were aimed at cotton speculators, they gave all Jews—speculators or no—just 24 hours to leave their homes, businesses and lives behind. It was the culmination of a wave of anti-Semitism that swept through the United States in the year before the Civil War… and a decision that would haunt Grant for the rest of his life.

Expand  

Lincoln squashed Grant's order but not until many were expelled from their homes and businesses.

I kinda doubt that was why his statue came down but you could chalk it up to karma, I guess.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you're mad about statues being pulled down 1k miles from where you live, you need to think about why that makes you mad. It probably doesn't reflect well.

It's funny how people of certain ideologies demand more consistency and coherence from a protest movement than they do from the elected officials who created the situations that led to the protests.

Deep-seated authoritarianism.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 5:14 PM, bad_teammate said:

If you're mad about statues being pulled down 1k miles from where you live, you need to think about why that makes you mad. It probably doesn't reflect well.

It's funny how people of certain ideologies demand more consistency and coherence from a protest movement than they do from the elected officials who created the situations that led to the protests.

Deep-seated authoritarianism.

Expand  

I don't know who you're talking to, but neither of these were 1000 miles away.

Do you think it should be okay to tear down statues of Malcom X, or MLK?I'd hope not, I'd also hope it would make you a bit angry.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 6:33 PM, workswithseed said:

I don't know who you're talking to, but neither of these were 1000 miles away.

Expand  

Texas -> California

Someone in Texas mad about Grant being taken down in SF is 1000+ miles away.

  Quote

Do you think it should be okay to tear down statues of Malcom X, or MLK?I'd hope not, I'd also hope it would make you a bit angry.

Expand  

The following questions are not rhetorical:
- Why would people tear down a statue of Francis Scott Key and Ulysses S. Grant?
- Why would people someone tear down a statue of Malcolm X or MLK?

The intentions and message are the problem. I'm 100% cool with anti-slavery intentions, even if they play out in a temporarily overexuberant way. I'm not cool with racist intentions, regardless of how they play out.

This shit isn't complicated.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 2:15 PM, Message Board User said:
Expand  

This is stupidity.  Grant married into a family who owned slaves, was given one and later freed him with no conditions despite being almost destitute because he hated the practice so much.  The rest of his resume' on slavery is well known.  Now if you want to criticize his policies on American Indians..... then I can't complain but it's stupidity to lump him in with Confederate personalities.  

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 7:22 PM, bad_teammate said:

Such a strange thing to be mad about people 1500 miles away taking down a statue of Ulysses S. Grant.

Find better shit to get mad about.

Expand  

Also the distance thing is weird. Does taking down a Hitler statue all the way in Germany not make you happy since it's so far away?

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 7:24 PM, Xian said:

What does distance have to do with it?  

Expand  

Because it's not your city or public space. Why do you care what the people of San Francisco do with their public spaces?

What is it that makes you angry? Think about that and see if you can tell me.

What is it about people taking down a statue of Ulysses S. Grant in SF that angers you?

  On 6/20/2020 at 7:25 PM, workswithseed said:

Also the distance thing is weird. Does taking down a Hitler statue all the way in Germany not make you happy since it's so far away?

Expand  

This is an idiotic comparison. It's Ulysses S. Grant; he's not relevant to anything going on right now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 7:34 PM, bad_teammate said:

Because it's not your city or public space. Why do you care what the people of San Francisco do with their public spaces?

What is it that makes you angry? Think about that and see if you can tell me.

What is it about people taking down a statue of Ulysses S. Grant in SF that angers you?

This is an idiotic comparison. It's Ulysses S. Grant; he's not relevant to anything going on right now.

Expand  

Then why take him down when he's not relevant?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If someone takes down a statue of Hitler, I like that because their intentions are anti-Nazi. Cool & good.

If someone takes down a statue of MLK, I hate that because their intentions are racist. Lame & bad.

If someone takes down a statue of Ulysses S. Grant while taking down other slaveowners next to it... what? It seems like their WORST crime is historical ignorance and overexubuerance.

Are you guys worried that it's indicative of a desire to commit white genocide? Are you just mad because they aren't stellar at history?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 7:39 PM, bad_teammate said:

Don't know and don't care. They don't need to justify it to me. It's their park in their city and their intentions seem fine to me.

You (and others) are avoiding the question: Why does this make you mad?

Expand  

Cause, they memorialize an idea. George Washington memorialize that you can be humble to rule a land, and not having to rule with an iron fist. Grant's is that you use force to free a populace that's under the boot.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 7:34 PM, bad_teammate said:

Because it's not your city or public space. Why do you care what the people of San Francisco do with their public spaces?

What is it that makes you angry? Think about that and see if you can tell me.

What is it about people taking down a statue of Ulysses S. Grant in SF that angers you?

This is an idiotic comparison. It's Ulysses S. Grant; he's not relevant to anything going on right now.

Expand  

In that case why get mad they are up in the first place?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 7:47 PM, workswithseed said:

Cause, they memorialize an idea. George Washington memorialize that you can be humble to rule a land, and not having to rule with an iron fist. Grant's is that you use force to free a populace that's under the boot.

Expand  

Those are your ideas of George Washington and Ulysses S. Grant. It's clearly not theirs.

Do you think the people who took down these statues want an iron-fisted ruler? Do you think they oppose the use of force to attain freedom?

  On 6/20/2020 at 7:53 PM, Michael Knight said:

In that case why get mad they are up in the first place?

Expand  

Because they are mad about people rejecting the common white supremacist interpretation of American history. And I oppose them for having an emotional allegiance to the white supremacist interpretation of American history.

I don't like it when white Southern men decide they are the noble keepers of America's history, because blood follows.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 7:58 PM, bad_teammate said:

Those are your ideas of George Washington and Ulysses S. Grant. It's clearly not theirs.

Do you think the people who took down these statues want an iron-fisted ruler? Do you think they oppose the use of force to attain freedom?

 

Expand  

why is weird that I'm mad when I project those ideas off those statues?

Maybe on both of your questions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 7:58 PM, bad_teammate said:

Those are your ideas of George Washington and Ulysses S. Grant. It's clearly not theirs.

Do you think the people who took down these statues want an iron-fisted ruler? Do you think they oppose the use of force to attain freedom?

Because they are mad about people rejecting the common white supremacist interpretation of American history. And I oppose them for having an emotional allegiance to the white supremacist interpretation of American history.

I don't like it when white Southern men decide they are the noble keepers of America's history, because blood follows.

Expand  

It's 1000s of miles away, why do you care. That's your own stupid fucking argument btw

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 8:02 PM, formermav43 said:

Because if anyone is upset at removing a statue of US Grant, it’s obviously white Southern men. 

Expand  

Are you reading this thread?

  On 6/20/2020 at 8:03 PM, workswithseed said:

why is weird that I'm mad when I project those ideas off those statues?

Expand  

It's weird for you to think that they are tearing them down because they hate freedom. That you even think that's a possibility is strange as hell.

  On 6/20/2020 at 8:04 PM, Michael Knight said:

It's 1000s of miles away, why do you care.

Expand  

What is the "it" here?

I am arguing with people right here in front of me (Internet-wise), that's who I am arguing with.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 7:11 PM, Xian said:

The grant statute legit pisses me off 

Expand  

That actually pisses you off? I see red when seeing cops murder someone on the street not some statue that doesn’t matter.

besides Ulysses isn’t even the best Grant.  Cary, Bud and Lou have him beat.

Edited by Nice Guy Eddie
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 6/20/2020 at 10:03 PM, Axiom of Choice said:

These are american citizens taking down a symbol against slavery on American soil, not by vote or popular consensus, but by mob rule representing a minority opinion.  I'm an American citizen who lives on american soil.  I don't like vandalism of monuments against slavery by mobs caught up in a mindless frenzy anywhere in the US.  If conservatives took down the exact same statue, there would be massive public outrage.  Since it is your fellow leftists, you wonder why anyone should care - just look the other way as their motives were pure, even if they don't know history.  

Expand  

Do you think that the people who took down the statue viewed it as "a symbol against slavery"?

Answer honestly.

  Quote

Yes, historical ignorance and "overexuberance" of mindless mobs is the crime.  People do not like mindless shit for brains imbeciles vandalizing what they do not understand.  

Expand  

Are you OK with all of the statue removals that involved slaveholders?

It really seems like there's been a lot of resentful silence just waiting for an excuse to explode and the Grant statue is the permission people need to express their anger. The level of invective you obviously feel towards the individuals involved is a lot deeper than just the Grant statue.

A triggered snowflake, if you will.

Link to comment
Share on other sites



×
×
  • Create New...