Rank these players

[shadow_operative 15932]

•Oscar Robertson

•Magic Johnson

•John Stockton

•Isiah Thomas 

•Chris Paul

•Steph Curry

•Jason Kidd 

•Steve Nash

[shadow_operative 15932]

•Hakeem

•Shaq

•Wilt

•Russell

•Kareem

[VinyVango 694]

Kidd would probably be last on that list.

[shadow_operative 15932]

as college freshmen:

•Bill Walton

•Lew Alcindor 

•Kevin Durant

•Carmelo Anthony

•Anthony Davis 

•Chris Jackson 

[HookEm 2467]

•Oscar Robertson
•Magic Johnson
•John Stockton
•Isiah Thomas 
•Chris Paul
•Steph Curry
•Jason Kidd 
•Steve Nash

Magic
Curry
CP3
Isiah
Nash
Stockton
Kidd

Oscar Robertson (never saw him play)

[ztejas 43475]

49 minutes ago, shadow_operative said:

•Oscar Robertson

•Magic Johnson

•John Stockton

•Isiah Thomas 

•Chris Paul

•Steph Curry

•Jason Kidd 

•Steve Nash

Ill go career here and not peak or prime:

Magic

Steph

ORob/CP3 (tough one here)

Stockton

IT

Nash

Kidd

50 minutes ago, shadow_operative said:

•Hakeem

•Shaq

•Wilt

•Russell

•Kareem

I have a hard time rating guys that played in totally different eras. But I guess I'll try.

Kareem

After that you could put the next 4 in any order I honestly believe. I might go:

Wilt

Shaq

Hakeem

Russell 

But that's all razor-thin and I don't really know how to compare guys like Russell with guys like Hakeem.

 

[Mole 4333]

1 hour ago, shadow_operative said:

as college freshmen:

•Bill Walton

•Lew Alcindor 

•Kevin Durant

•Carmelo Anthony

•Anthony Davis 

•Chris Jackson 

The pedant in me says, since these two players weren't eligible to play as college freshmen, I'm ranking them last in some order.

With that, I'll go:

Carmelo, on the strength of his tournament play

KD

Davis

Chris Jackson

[shadow_operative 15932]

On 5/18/2021 at 9:56 PM, shadow_operative said:

•Oscar Robertson

•Magic Johnson

•John Stockton

•Isiah Thomas 

•Chris Paul

•Steph Curry

•Jason Kidd 

•Steve Nash

i'll go:

Magic

Steph

Oscar

Stockton

Paul

Thomas 

Nash

Kidd

[UTDD 362]

Really tougher than I thought at first glance -- I have a few really close together with 3-5.

Magic, Steph, Oscar, CP3, Stockton, Thomas, Nash, Kidd.  

[conVINCEd 21469]

Kidd was a better player than Nash.  The MVPs for Nash would tempt you into ranking Nash ahead of him, but those were somewhat fool’s gold.  If I have to win a playoff game tomorrow, I would take prime Kidd over prime Nash.

[hobbes2702 13045]

On 5/18/2021 at 9:56 PM, shadow_operative said:

•Oscar Robertson

•Magic Johnson

•John Stockton

•Isiah Thomas 

•Chris Paul

•Steph Curry

•Jason Kidd 

•Steve Nash

Magic

Steph

Oscar

CP3

IT

Stockton

Nash 

Kidd

[hobbes2702 13045]

On 5/18/2021 at 9:57 PM, shadow_operative said:

•Hakeem

•Shaq

•Wilt

•Russell

•Kareem

KAJ

Russell

Wilt

Hakeem

Shaq

[realgreggym 835]

On 5/18/2021 at 10:10 PM, shadow_operative said:

as college freshmen:

•Bill Walton

•Lew Alcindor 

•Kevin Durant

•Carmelo Anthony

•Anthony Davis 

•Chris Jackson 

Walton and Alcindor were not eligible to play varsity their freshman years.