Is a fake slide an acceptable move ?

[hobbes2702 13034]

15 hours ago, Cairn Horn88 said:

So, sliding is like calling a fair catch?  But, they can hit him before he slides or faking a slide, since the slide has not commenced?

 

Once you begin the motion of a slide you are down from that spot. So when he fakes he is beginning the motion of the slide and should be ruled down at the spot. Refs missed it

[Deej 76797]

18 hours ago, 4th&Five said:

I wouldn’t expect refs to catch something like that in real time if they’d never seen it before. 

Unless a Texas QB pulled that move. Then they'd have caught it immediately.

[Pig Bellmont 8719]

12 minutes ago, Deej said:

Unless a Texas QB pulled that move. Then they'd have caught it immediately.

The UT QB would have legit just stumbled and the refs would review the play, call it back, and then give a penalty 

[JimmyJames 12271]

Just now, Pig Bellmont said:

The UT QB would have legit just stumbled and the refs would review the play, call it back, and then give a penalty 

Yep. You can bet your ass if that was a longhorn QB in a big 12 game the touchdown would have been called back after review. 

[Tex Long 4400]

Is it only a QB who is protected by this rule, or is any player wearing a skirt?

[Js1 85346]

1 hour ago, Pig Bellmont said:

The UT QB would have legit just stumbled and the refs would review the play, call it back, and then give a penalty 

[satyanash 14499]

Apparently the NCAA Rules Committee clarified that the 'fake slide' the QB did was illegal and should have been blown dead on the spot.

 

 

[Pig Bellmont 8719]

1 hour ago, satyanash said:

Apparently the NCAA Rules Committee clarified that the 'fake slide' the QB did was illegal and should have been blown dead on the spot.

 

 

Yes and now maybe our resident contrarians can settle down 

[Js1 85346]

He’s a good sport 

 

[Jkwellborn 6702]

Unless a Texas QB pulled that move. Then they'd have caught it immediately.

Nah, he’d have gotten destroyed by the defense and it would have been ok.

[Guest]

17 hours ago, Tex Long said:

Is it only a QB who is protected by this rule, or is any player wearing a skirt?

any player can give up on the play/ slide.  Most common time for non-QBs is defensive players making an INT to end the game or Offensive player trying to stay in bounds to keep clock running.

[The Dude 1244]

I’d be for just getting rid of the slide rule.  Possession receivers over the middle have figured out how to lay down after a catch without getting decapitated. The slide rule allows for taking advantage of the defense. If you want to be a ball carrier, take the hit, or fall down and don’t try to squeeze that extra half yard out of your run

[PittsburghTiger 6187]

https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/ncaa-bans-fake-slide-play-made-famous-by-kenny-picketts-touchdown-run-in-acc-title-game/

 

 

gonna be a lot written about this 

Edited December 10, 2021 by PittsburghTiger

[Onboard 2.0 9083]

11 hours ago, Pig Bellmont said:

Yes and now maybe our resident contrarians can settle down 

Nah the rules committee is a bunch of pussies trying to destroy a once proud game, and turn it into flag football.
 

D’uuuuuh

Edited December 10, 2021 by Onboard 2.0

[utee94 15824]

1 hour ago, The Dude said:

I’d be for just getting rid of the slide rule.  Possession receivers over the middle have figured out how to lay down after a catch without getting decapitated. The slide rule allows for taking advantage of the defense. If you want to be a ball carrier, take the hit, or fall down and don’t try to squeeze that extra half yard out of your run

Exactly.  The rule itself is stupid and redundant.  Its sole purpose is to allow a ballcarrier in the open field to squeak out an extra half-yard without taking a hit.  Why?  If the ballcarrier doesn't want to get hit, the ballcarrier can go to the ground well before the defenders arrive.  If the ballcarrier wants that extra yardage, then the consequence, is getting hit.

But as long as the rule exists, then this is the way it must be called.  Faking a slide, is beginning a slide, is a dead ball.  

[Tex Long 4400]

2 hours ago, The Dude said:

I’d be for just getting rid of the slide rule.  

Fuck that shit. They can have my K&E Log Log Decitrig Duplex when they pry it out of my cold, dead hands.

Edited December 10, 2021 by Tex Long

[Onboard 2.0 9083]

31 minutes ago, Tex Long said:

Fuck that shit. They can have my K&E Log Log Decitrig Duplex when they pry it out of my cold, dead hands.

Ohhhhhhhh that's baaaaaaaad, and that I know what it is may be worse....

[Eskimohorn 5635]

I’d be for just getting rid of the slide rule.  Possession receivers over the middle have figured out how to lay down after a catch without getting decapitated. The slide rule allows for taking advantage of the defense. If you want to be a ball carrier, take the hit, or fall down and don’t try to squeeze that extra half yard out of your run

At the college level, they really need to simplify the rules. At all levels, really when you can. Less subjectivity.

At college, they should eliminate this rule and revamp/point of emphasis on preventing defenders from punishing runners already down.

[RPM 26321]

5 hours ago, utee94 said:

Exactly.  The rule itself is stupid and redundant.  Its sole purpose is to allow a ballcarrier in the open field to squeak out an extra half-yard without taking a hit.  Why?  If the ballcarrier doesn't want to get hit, the ballcarrier can go to the ground well before the defenders arrive.  If the ballcarrier wants that extra yardage, then the consequence, is getting hit.

But as long as the rule exists, then this is the way it must be called.  Faking a slide, is beginning a slide, is a dead ball.  

This. The first time somebody tries that move and it backfires there's going to be a massive shitstorm when he gets slept. Should be the same as a fair catch.