2024 Transfer Thread - The Pedantic Circlejerk

[Huckleberry 32848]

6 minutes ago, BurntOrange&White said:

I don't think you quite understand how much better the SEC is in the trenches top to bottom vs just a few teams from big 12. 

 

From just 2024 recruiting class alone 13/16 teams rank in the top 25 and all 16 are in the top 50. 

Now do how good they are on the actual field. Using recruiting ratings to rebut the premise that a recruiting guy overrates something is an interesting move. 

Massey ratings because they're easy to parse: SEC has 6 of 14 teams in Top 25, Big 12 has 6 of 14. SEC has 12 of 14 in the Top 50, Big 12 has 10. So this big difference is that Mississippi State was slightly better than BYU. If they flipped it would be 11 each in the top 50.

So yeah, the handwringing is a bit overboard.

[Red Five 40844]

4 minutes ago, Mr. Drummond said:

And to be clear, im not saying the lines aren't better in the SEC, they clearly are.    But there is no reason to be a bitch about it.

There is a zero percent chance that any of us at any time next year will be saying "Damn if only we hadn't lost Trill Carter!". 

[Longhornlove 4809]

5 minutes ago, BERT said:

Found Bobby's surly handle

Might be true true if Bobby was bitter and spiteful. Hell Fat Ketch quotes himself(twitter) in here all the time.

[cafe society 2860]

Everybody has their panties in a wad about uber-developer Bo Davis potentially leaving, yet these same everybodies don't seem to consider how far our young DL will have come next fall.  Calm the fuck down, Debbies.

[Pato del Muerto 52485]

10 minutes ago, BurntOrange&White said:

We will be playing teams far talented that put out far more NFL players than our current conference. There is a huge difference in having to play 1-3 teams like that a year vs most of your conference schedule being like that. 

We still only have to play one team at a time and one a week, right?

[Stunns38 3460]

I thought it was pretty funny - Did we even sign a "handful" of OL in 2023.

Yeah, I didn’t think we signed but 1 or 2 last cycle.

[Red Five 40844]

We signed five OL in 2023.

[6th Street 6390]

Hope Kirkland, Goolsby, and Chatman stick around. Cojoe and Stroh might be further down the IOL depth chart 

[DixonHur 11293]

10 minutes ago, cafe society said:

Everybody has their panties in a wad about uber-developer Bo Davis potentially leaving, yet these same everybodies don't seem to consider how far our young DL will have come next fall.  Calm the fuck down, Debbies.

Davis and Choice might be the 2 best position coaches on this staff...we need to do everything we can to retain them.

[Ricky Butler 2683]

16 minutes ago, Red Five said:

There is a zero percent chance that any of us at any time next year will be saying "Damn if only we hadn't lost Trill Carter!". 

To be fair, I also heard Burton literally say, “If they get Caldwell, it’s not a huge loss.” Adds some meaningful context to the handwringing. 

[Hiphopopotamos 20869]

FWIW - I saw last night that Brandon Harris and JM Jones (Asst Dir of Player Personnel) were following Liberty WR and recent portal entrant CJ Daniels.  Just this morning Taylor Searels (Dir of Recruiting Operations) started following him.  Maybe a visit is in the works?

https://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/players/cj-daniels-1.html

 

 

[bwub60 147]

2 hours ago, Hookem2147 said:

Give me Gbenda. Blackwell is still a tweener despite the physical gifts.

Hasn’t it been mentioned that Trey Moore could profile some to the Strong side LB spot that Blackwell currently has?

Moore is a Buck

[Bevo 13566]

16 minutes ago, 6th Street said:

Hope Kirkland, Goolsby, and Chatman stick around. Cojoe and Stroh might be further down the IOL depth chart 

Well, he said a handful so I’m pretty sure that he meant they were all gone. It is pretty sad really. I had such high hopes.

[BachelorTrek 2966]

39 minutes ago, BurntOrange&White said:

We will be playing teams far talented that put out far more NFL players than our current conference. There is a huge difference in having to play 1-3 teams like that a year vs most of your conference schedule being like that. 

But also it's a huge difference not having to play chicken-littles that play jihad-games against you, where you have nothing to win and everything to lose, complete with the cheapshots and intentional injuries like froggie did to JB.

[Ricky Butler 2683]

4 minutes ago, Bevo said:

Well, he said a handful so I’m pretty sure that he meant they were all gone. It is pretty sad really. I had such high hopes.

He said a handful, so it implies that only a portion of one of them is gone. 

[Vertigo 20276]

2 hours ago, Atticus said:

I love me some Mo Blackwell, but he's probably best as a core special teamer on this team. Too bad he couldn't put on more weight.

Gbenda is nice if the lightbulb continues to come on for him. He could even be draftable next year if he makes a similar leap from last year.

Gbenda is still limited athletically, and while he has been vastly improved under Choate, I believe the starting linebackers coming out of spring even if Gbenda stays will be Anthony Hill and Liona Lefau. The staff is super high on Lefau. Gbenda's best move would be to follow Choate. He will get exposed in the SEC pretty easily. 

 

 

1 hour ago, DZX158 said:

Burton reported Jelani McDonald moved to Safety. 

A starting tandem of Watts (if he stays) and Williams, with Filsaime, McDonald and Rubell as the primary backups, plus Taafe as the glue guy to pair with the younger guys represents an enormous makeover of that room into a suddenly hyper athletic and scary unit. 

28 minutes ago, 6th Street said:

Hope Kirkland, Goolsby, and Chatman stick around. Cojoe and Stroh might be further down the IOL depth chart 

I doubt Goosby goes anywhere, he is the heir apparent to the LT spot unless Baker takes it from him. Kirkland is doubtful to leave because of the knee injury, but if he does I can't say it would be impactful at this point. Chatman may be a flight risk along with Cojoe, but Stroh is likely going to be a program guy that maximizes at some point and maybe finds a starting job a couple of years down the line. I can't say that losing either Chatman or Cojoe would be felt. 

[BurntOrange&White 39930]

2 minutes ago, Vertigo said:

Gbenda is still limited athletically, and while he has been vastly improved under Choate, I believe the starting linebackers coming out of spring even if Gbenda stays will be Anthony Hill and Liona Lefau. The staff is super high on Lefau. Gbenda's best move would be to follow Choate. He will get exposed in the SEC pretty easily. 

 

 

A starting tandem of Watts (if he stays) and Williams, with Filsaime, McDonald and Rubell as the primary backups, plus Taafe as the glue guy to pair with the younger guys represents an enormous makeover of that room into a suddenly hyper athletic and scary unit. 

I doubt Goosby goes anywhere, he is the heir apparent to the LT spot unless Baker takes it from him. Kirkland is doubtful to leave because of the knee injury, but if he does I can't say it would be impactful at this point. Chatman may be a flight risk along with Cojoe, but Stroh is likely going to be a program guy that maximizes at some point and maybe finds a starting job a couple of years down the line. I can't say that losing either Chatman or Cojoe would be felt. 

Rubbell will be nickel/star

I wonder if they'll kind of use Mukuba like they did with Jahdae but instead of putting him at corner he slides to safety in certain defensive looks. 

[HenryJames 66038]

29 minutes ago, Bevo said:

Well, he said a handful so I’m pretty sure that he meant they were all gone. It is pretty sad really. I had such high hopes.

Wtf1

[Vertigo 20276]

Just now, BurntOrange&White said:

Rubbell will be nickel/star

I wonder if they'll kind of use Mukuba like they did with Jahdae but instead of putting him at corner he slides to safety in certain defensive looks. 

I could see that, although Watts at the safety position shouldn't be a liability that is exploited like Thompson and Taafe.

[Frank Drebin 5659]

10 minutes ago, Vertigo said:

Gbenda is still limited athletically, and while he has been vastly improved under Choate, I believe the starting linebackers coming out of spring even if Gbenda stays will be Anthony Hill and Liona Lefau. The staff is super high on Lefau. Gbenda's best move would be to follow Choate. He will get exposed in the SEC pretty easily. 

 

No one on our defense is getting exposed in the SEC.  Playing defense in the Big 12 is a hell of a lot harder than playing defense in the SEC.

[BurntOrange&White 39930]

I keep forgetting Smaje Burrell is on the roster. He was obviously redshirting this year.

 

[cafe society 2860]

Seems as though Surly is overlooking Warren Roberson.  He's got a lot of dawg in him, I can see him moving up the depth chart this spring.

[Tree Fidy 1176]

1 hour ago, BurntOrange&White said:

We will be playing teams far talented that put out far more NFL players than our current conference. There is a huge difference in having to play 1-3 teams like that a year vs most of your conference schedule being like that. 

Yo Chin Pubes, what's up?   I never understood (until now) why you are repeatedly called out for being a dumbass.   That, sir, is no longer a mystery.

[Hiphopopotamos 20869]

Bobby 9.95'n as hard as he ever has.

I'm saying Caldwell and Daniels.

[Hookem2147 21194]

Bobby said he thinks the staff is willing to go into the spring with the WR room they currently have if they don’t love what is out there. Then look again during the May portal window.

edit: well interesting timing with that tweet

Edited January 5 by Hookem2147

[CaseMcCoyTruther 106]

I'm new here. Any rumor of Fat Ketch transferring back to Planned Parenthood for that abortion to go through?

[Mason Ramsey 3373]

4 minutes ago, Hiphopopotamos said:

Bobby 9.95'n as hard as he ever has.

I'm saying Caldwell and Daniels.

Yeah he confirmed on the livestream that we're bringing in Caldwell and CJ Daniels for visits. Looks like he could be a solid AD replacement.

https://www.espn.com/college-football/player/gamelog/_/id/4605951/cj-daniels

[Not a Sock 2311]

56 minutes ago, Frank Drebin said:

No one on our defense is getting exposed in the SEC.  Playing defense in the Big 12 is a hell of a lot harder than playing defense in the SEC.

This is an out of date take, the Big 12 doesn’t have the same caliber of offenses it did a decade ago, if anything the SEC is more an offense league now than the Big 12. 

[BornAndRaised 12281]

1 hour ago, Hiphopopotamos said:

FWIW - I saw last night that Brandon Harris and JM Jones (Asst Dir of Player Personnel) were following Liberty WR and recent portal entrant CJ Daniels.  Just this morning Taylor Searels (Dir of Recruiting Operations) started following him.  Maybe a visit is in the works?

https://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/players/cj-daniels-1.html

 

 

 

12 minutes ago, Mason Ramsey said:

Yeah he confirmed on the livestream that we're bringing in Caldwell and CJ Daniels for visits. Looks like he could be a solid AD replacement.

https://www.espn.com/college-football/player/gamelog/_/id/4605951/cj-daniels

@Hiphopopotamosgood detective work boss.

[HtownHorn 14663]

6 minutes ago, Not a Sock said:

This is an out of date take, the Big 12 doesn’t have the same caliber of offenses it did a decade ago, if anything the SEC is more an offense league now than the Big 12. 

Not really.

OFEI

2 LSU

3 Georgia

8 Oklahoma

9 Kansas

10 Kansas State

15 Ole Miss

17 Texas

18 Missouri

20 Alabama

21 TCU

22 Texas A&M

23 Tennessee

25 UCF

26 West Virginia

27 Iowa State

 

Looks pretty even.

[Dbeasy 15042]

I think there was originally a WR they thought would enter the portal in December that didn’t, but could in the spring. 

[Hookem2147 21194]

Daniels seems like the perfect fit for what we are looking for at WR

[Elmer_Fudd 22202]

Just now, HtownHorn said:

Not really.

OFEI

2 LSU

3 Georgia

8 Oklahoma

9 Kansas

10 Kansas State

15 Ole Miss

17 Texas

18 Missouri

20 Alabama

21 TCU

22 Texas A&M

23 Tennessee

25 UCF

26 West Virginia

27 Iowa State

 

Looks pretty even.

Yep.  Looking at the schedule next year, the offenses of Vandy, Kentucky, Miss. State, and Arky shouldn't scare anybody.  Florida is a dumpster fire all around.  Georgia will be good with Beck returning.  Aggy will be on its 3rd QB if Klein runs the QB battering ram offense.  

 

[Red Five 40844]

2 minutes ago, Hookem2147 said:

Daniels seems like the perfect fit for what we are looking for at WR

Lots of potential versatility with a rotation of Cook, Golden, Daniels, and Wingo.

[Hookem2147 21194]

Bobby also said he heard today that Mo Blackwell signed a lease for a new apartment and is staying 

[BurntOrange&White 39930]

"Texas has continued to recruit him(Caldwell) so I think that hurdle has been cleared and not really that concerned about it any further" - Bobby on Caldwell's grades question.

[Rockethorn1978 6072]

2 hours ago, Mr. Drummond said:

And to be clear, im not saying the lines aren't better in the SEC, they clearly are.    But there is no reason to be a bitch about it.

Aggy best season in the sec was with a big 12 roster. We will be fine.

[Hookem2147 21194]

CJ Daniels is at Auburn today (obviously a Hugh Freeze connection coming from Liberty) and is supposed to be in Austin on Sunday.

[closetojumping 62557]

3 hours ago, tokamak said:

It seems early to me for 2023 OL to be transferring. Especially with a small '24 class behind them. They'll get their shot.

Some of the 2023 guys will leave and no one will be upset about it other than some recruitniks and football board idiots.

2 hours ago, someguy said:

don't underestimate the bolded - it was a real factor with Mitchell.

For sure you and I know this, but I think it gets short shrift here on Surly and with the other forums. If Texas is going to recruit from anywhere north of St. Louis, which I am all for, they should probably expect those guys to need 6 months to acclimate, at least. It didn't help that this past summer was one of the absolute all time scorchers throughout the state.

2 hours ago, 6th Street said:

Hope Kirkland, Goolsby, and Chatman stick around. Cojoe and Stroh might be further down the IOL depth chart 

A lot will need to change for Kirkland to stick. I think the others are well-liked, with some maturity issues for one of them, but if another school is willing to offer significant money to any of this group, it is highly unlikely that Texas can match. Folks really like Goosby and Chatman, I believe.

12 minutes ago, Hookem2147 said:

CJ Daniels is at Auburn today (obviously a Hugh Freeze connection coming from Liberty) and is supposed to be in Austin on Sunday.

I won't be surprised if Freeze does his thing and shuts this one down today. Hope that doesn't happen, of course.

[BurntOrange&White 39930]

Just now, closetojumping said:

Some of the 2023 guys will leave and no one will be upset about it other than some recruitniks and football board idiots.

For sure you and I know this, but I think it gets short shrift here on Surly and with the other forums. If Texas is going to recruit from anywhere north of St. Louis, which I am all for, they should probably expect those guys to need 6 months to acclimate, at least. It didn't help that this past summer was one of the absolute all time scorchers throughout the state.

A lot will need to change for Kirkland to stick. I think the others are well-liked, with some maturity issues for one of them, but if another school is willing to offer significant money to any of this group, it is highly unlikely that Texas can match. Folks really like Goosby and Chatman, I believe.

Kirkland allegedly had a pretty significant injury to his knee but they say he had fallen behind others in terms development even though he started off stronger.

[BornAndRaised 12281]

2 minutes ago, closetojumping said:

I won't be surprised if Freeze does his thing and shuts this one down today. Hope that doesn't happen, of course.

Didn't they fire their Offensive coordinator today? Shades of aggy signing #1 class with no defensive coordinator. 

[Vito Andolini 9124]

Quote

I won't be surprised if Freeze does his thing

Calls a porn line on the company dime?

[HenryJames 66038]

Who the fuck is Auburn’s quarterback next season?

[Mother mopar 3318]

I won't be surprised if Freeze does his thing

Calls a porn line on the company dime?

Or poops on company time, cause boss makes a dollar, I make a dime...

[Sgt Hulk 13713]

Who the fuck is Auburn.  They are dog shit. A step down from liberty

[crash_davis 23100]

6 minutes ago, HenryJames said:

Who the fuck is Auburn’s quarterback next season?

Casey Thompson may have another year of eligibility remaining.

[Vertigo 20276]

55 minutes ago, HtownHorn said:

Not really.

OFEI

2 LSU

3 Georgia

8 Oklahoma

9 Kansas

10 Kansas State

15 Ole Miss

17 Texas

18 Missouri

20 Alabama

21 TCU

22 Texas A&M

23 Tennessee

25 UCF

26 West Virginia

27 Iowa State

 

Looks pretty even.

Does it? Only 4 of the top 13 teams listed are B12 teams. 

Edited January 5 by Vertigo

[BigOrange1 6433]

43 minutes ago, Hookem2147 said:

Bobby also said he heard today that Mo Blackwell signed a lease for a new apartment and is staying 

 

39 minutes ago, BurntOrange&White said:

"Texas has continued to recruit him(Caldwell) so I think that hurdle has been cleared and not really that concerned about it any further" - Bobby on Caldwell's grades question.

Bobby is fucking griding since he ditched the dead weight at inside texas.

[Hiphopopotamos 20869]

CJ Daniels should be an interesting recruitment.  We've been told that one of Freeze's biggest selling points to the 2024 class was that this year is a rebuild and that he expects young players opportunity to win jobs for 2024.  He also doesn't have an established starter (worth a damn) at QB.

If it just comes down to money - and Freeze wants him - then ok we move on.

But...

If he's looking at opportunity and situation - Texas has the AD Mitchell role wide open for him to step in to and he'll have a Heisman favorite QB (given time by an established and experienced OL) to throw him a ridiculous amount of TDs.  

[Duane Moore 5237]

1 minute ago, Hiphopopotamos said:

He also doesn't have an established starter (worth a damn) at QB.

Is Kaidon Salter not heading to Auburn?