Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

So, I know the call was overturned by review, but I'm mystified by the original call.  Unless I misunderstood something or am an idiot (both possible) it sounded like there is a rule that a QB fumble in the backfield can't be advanced if recovered by an offensive teammate.  Is this a new rule?  If not, how the hell have I missed it through decades of watching college football?

Posted (edited)

~Always been the case that a fumble can’t be advanced by a dif off player on 4th down. There was a play in the 70s? that led to the rule… or maybe the Holy Roller wasn’t the reasoning and it’s always been around. 

Edited by bluto
  • Hook 'Em 3
Posted
1 minute ago, nunna yo bizness said:

So, I know the call was overturned by review, but I'm mystified by the original call.  Unless I misunderstood something or am an idiot (both possible) it sounded like there is a rule that a QB fumble in the backfield can't be advanced if recovered by an offensive teammate.  Is this a new rule?  If not, how the hell have I missed it through decades of watching college football?

It’s a 4th down thing to prevent intentional fumbles and it’s not specific to QBs.

  • Hook 'Em 5
Posted
2 minutes ago, 6th Street said:

Fumblerooski is a legal play since QB never had possession

Incorrect. On the fumblerooski the QB receives the snap and intentionally places the ball on the ground for a pulling OL to pick up.

Posted
So, I know the call was overturned by review, but I'm mystified by the original call.  Unless I misunderstood something or am an idiot (both possible) it sounded like there is a rule that a QB fumble in the backfield can't be advanced if recovered by an offensive teammate.  Is this a new rule?  If not, how the hell have I missed it through decades of watching college football?

The rule for that play wasn’t a fumble, but a “muff”, as the QB never had possession. Earlier poster is correct on advancing a “fumble” on 4th.

Anyone can advance a “muff” to include an OL, as long as it was behind the LOS, as this play was. It’s basically like a backwards pass.

Hook’em!!!
Posted

So, is it accurate that an offense can never advance its own fumble?  I guess this rarely comes up because a fumbling offense just wants to get the ball and smother the fucker and isn't looking to advance it usually.

I had forgotten that there was a set of rules evolving over fourth down plays because of fumblerooski type plays.

Posted
1 minute ago, TwiceHorn said:

So, is it accurate that an offense can never advance its own fumble?  I guess this rarely comes up because a fumbling offense just wants to get the ball and smother the fucker and isn't looking to advance it usually.

I had forgotten that there was a set of rules evolving over fourth down plays because of fumblerooski type plays.

It's legal for a teammate to advance a fumble on any other down. 

  • Hook 'Em 2
  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
33 minutes ago, nunna yo bizness said:

So, I know the call was overturned by review, but I'm mystified by the original call.  Unless I misunderstood something or am an idiot (both possible) it sounded like there is a rule that a QB fumble in the backfield can't be advanced if recovered by an offensive teammate.  Is this a new rule?  If not, how the hell have I missed it through decades of watching college football?

It was the Holy Roller and the rules were changed in the off season to prevent such a play. 

To the OP’s original question - on 4th down if there is a fumble by an offensive player, only that offensive player can recover and advance it*. It is to prevent a player from fumbling on n purpose when they are going to fail to gain a first down with basically nothing to lose. 
 

* any player can recover the fumble, but the ball goes back to the point of the fumble. 

Edited by Captain Ron
  • Hook 'Em 1
Posted
1 minute ago, TwiceHorn said:

So, is it accurate that an offense can never advance its own fumble?  I guess this rarely comes up because a fumbling offense just wants to get the ball and smother the fucker and isn't looking to advance it usually.

I had forgotten that there was a set of rules evolving over fourth down plays because of fumblerooski type plays.

Offense can advance its own fumble.  The only real stipulation is that if it's 4th down only the fumbler can advance it. 

Thanks alot Stabler 

  • Hook 'Em 1
Posted
4 minutes ago, TwiceHorn said:

So, is it accurate that an offense can never advance its own fumble?  I guess this rarely comes up because a fumbling offense just wants to get the ball and smother the fucker and isn't looking to advance it usually.

I had forgotten that there was a set of rules evolving over fourth down plays because of fumblerooski type plays.

Anyone can advance a fumble if it’s not 4th down. On 4th down, only the guy that fumbled it can advance it. 

Posted
It's legal for a teammate to advance a fumble on any other down. 

Yes, except for 4th down, as also any play past the LOS. Once ball is possessed on 4th, the play is dead at the spot.

Hook’em!!!
Posted
19 minutes ago, Huckleberry said:

Incorrect. On the fumblerooski the QB receives the snap and intentionally places the ball on the ground for a pulling OL to pick up.

Hence why Nebraska ran it on 3rd down in the 1984 Orange Bowl. 

Posted

This discussion is related to the late hit after 4th down penalty in the Duke/Clemson game. 4th down has its own rules in a lot of ways, both during the play because it's the offense's last chance and immediately upon the end of the play because possession officially changes instantly if they don't reach the line to gain. 

  • Hook 'Em 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...