Game Replay/Review/Recording Surly Style

[immamac 42838]

Would there be interest in getting game recordings and replaying the thread comments with usernames like Instagram live or one of those other things (comments float up and fade out in real time as they were made with the game timestamps?) 

Is there interest in additional commentary outside of the current youtube people that are doing it (texasnash?)

[Josef Pwag 1738]

I don't know what any of this means. 

[thunderlounge 7815]

You sure you want said comments on a bigger stage than they already are?

Are you sure?

[Soliver465 404]

I think that it would be great.  I usually follow the game thread pretty close but drop out when either the comments get ridiculous or I need another drink.

[TheAuditor 1035]

37 minutes ago, Soliver465 said:

I think that it would be great.  I usually follow the game thread pretty close but drop out when either the comments get ridiculous or I need another drink.

So you're never really on the thread.  

[GringoSalado 1651]

53 minutes ago, Soliver465 said:

I think that it would be great.  I usually follow the game thread pretty close but drop out when either the comments get ridiculous or I need another drink.

First play?

 

[Wulaw Horn 19068]

1 hour ago, immamac said:

Would there be interest in getting game recordings and replaying the thread comments with usernames like Instagram live or one of those other things (comments float up and fade out in real time as they were made with the game timestamps?) 

Is there interest in additional commentary outside of the current youtube people that are doing it (texasnash?)

I have no idea if I would watch it or not but it sounds like a super interesting idea to see at least once. 

[pyrohornIII 4814]

Lot of guys have different opinions after the game than before.  Maybe doing what you speak of would be better without all the kneejerk emotional comments and seeing actual analysis commentary.   

The game threads are a beating with the same guys commenting over and over how Ewers, Sark or Worthy suck.  Like their waiting for the game to go south so they can say "told you so."

You guys did several years back with that one really good analyst.   Maybe have a team, some for different analysis and some surly humor tossed in?  Do a poll on who surly thinks would be best?