THE College Football Playoff Rankings Thread [MICH,WASH,TEX,ALA]

[WBT 20415]

1 minute ago, bullet said:

We'll pass them with a win.  They are not an issue.  Oregon is.

I know that.  It's still stupid.

[bullet 1596]

13 minutes ago, dcar00 said:

Bo Nix and they think the Pac 12 is some juggernaut.  need to look at the committee makeup

There has traditionally been a lot of people with Pac and Big 10 ties.  And UW and OR are future Big 10 schools.

[Js1 85095]

1 minute ago, Hagbard Celine said:

they backed in last year without a conference title

dimwit.... hmmmm.....  let me consider an aspersion to cast reflexively....

They backed in bc a P5 champ had 2 losses. The committee ranks a 1 loss non champ over a 2 loss champ every year. But they won’t beat out a 1 loss champ 

[Sgt Hulk 13644]

The best bet is the top4 all lose 

[dcar00 14030]

ohio state is out after next week no need to discuss them, really because if we win they can't make it.

[Hagbard Celine 10751]

6 minutes ago, Horn80 said:

Right….”we look at everything” But Texas wins on all metrics ahead of Oregon?

exactly this - the rest of you just saw the committee raw and uncensored - zero logic or fucks given - and all of you are so damn certain we jump jort with a noles loss

okay then

[The_Great_Hornsby 3319]

1 minute ago, WBT said:

I know that.  It's still stupid.

Yes, I agree, Texas and Bama should both be ahead of OSU and Oregon tbh. 

[USNALonghorn 5024]

4 minutes ago, dcar00 said:

say it with me SOS doesn't matter.  schedule cupcakes and beat everyone's ass as bad as possible.

Fucking this. This is a beauty pageant, not a logical ranking system.

[mdmost 42843]

1 minute ago, Hagbard Celine said:

they backed in last year without a conference title

dimwit.... hmmmm.....  let me consider an aspersion to cast reflexively....

Because they were competing against Bama who had 2 losses. USC was 4th and lost to Utah in the Pac 12 championship, therefore letting them in since no one else was close. Bama was 6 in the poll before championship weekend. Ohio State was 5th. 7 was Tennessee. Ohio State was 2nd most o the year until they lost to Michigan. The two are not comparable. 

[Pimphand 5594]

15 minutes ago, BurntOrange&White said:

FSU loses and maybe an upset of Michigan or Georgia and we get in.

Michigan and Pac winner are pretty much locks.  Rooting for Alabama & Louisville is without a doubt the best path

[Vic Mackey 46932]

Just now, The_Great_Hornsby said:

Im not sure I would want Texas to get in if we were gonna get Cleveland Steamered by 50. 

Yep I meant to add that at the end. Even their own fans know they have zero chance with that backup QB. He is terrible right now. They struggled to beat a terrible Florida team who also started their backup QB. Louisville needs to do the country a favor and end their playoff hopes. As of right now, that seems to be our only hope. FSU losing. Michigan losing, too. Don't see us jumping Oregon at this point. Committee is fascinated with them. If it's between us and Oregon for that lost spot, we will be left out.

[dcar00 14030]

Just now, USNALonghorn said:

Fucking this. This is a beauty pageant, not a logical ranking system.

with russian and german judges from Pac12 and Big10

[Chuckie Finster 22598]

A lot of people here are clamoring for chaos. We do NOT want chaos. We want this very neat and tidy. Undefeated Georgia, undefeated Michigan, undefeated Washington. We want Oregon and Bama to have two losses and FSU and Ohio State to be one loss non-conference champs.

Anything else put this in the hands of the committee and they have made it very clear, for whatever reason, they do not respect our resume.

[UTEE97 3429]

5 minutes ago, mdmost said:

Again, no. If Michigan loses, it only makes Ohio State look worse. If Michigan loses that only helps us if we win. 

I know many of you are coming up with the rationales for what should happen but the committee is not going by your rationales. They didn't have to keep tOSU ahead of us and Bama if they didn't believe they were better. Same goes for Oregon. 

[mdmost 42843]

This is why none of this will matter next year. Good OOCs are still possible when you have it not possibly screw you in late November. 

 

[Hagbard Celine 10751]

7 minutes ago, The_Great_Hornsby said:

You are a retard and should stop posting. 

fuck all of you - i'll shut up now

[BurntOrange&White 39617]

[Vic Mackey 46932]

3 minutes ago, Js1 said:

That was pretty much the consensus of TCU against Michigan 

You play the game. 

That was the consensus of TCU/Georgia. Plenty of people said TCU could hang with Michigan or win. TCU had a healthy squad, too. FSU doesn't. They are Cincy without Kenyon Martin in 2000 or whatever that year that was. Zero shot to do anything.

[The Dog 43792]

Just now, Chuckie Finster said:

they have made it very clear, for whatever reason, they do not respect our resume.

Yup. 

Unfortunately we aren’t going to the playoffs in any scenario.

[DanTheHorn 4897]

3 minutes ago, bullet said:

Bad vibes  Committee loves Oregon.  Or they have just decided to put the Pac 12 in during their final year.  UW-OR winner is in the playoffs.  So that game doesn't matter to us, no matter how big a win we get on Saturday.  We need Iowa or Louisville to win.  We should stay ahead of Alabama if they win, but that's not certain.

Well what if with 3 seconds left Washington down by 1 has their walk on kicker shank a 20 yard field goal. 

[bullet 1596]

7 minutes ago, DanTheHorn said:

I guess resume does not matter Rece addressed all the numbers in which Texas is better and the response was we look at everything. What of everything when it comes to numbers is Oregon better?

Icandoanything.gif

Oregon played a lot of weak teams and beat them by big margins.

[Hondo 661]

"Vibes"

"I feel like"

Name-calling

 

I think I may have accidentally walked into the Ladies' Room. 

[The_Great_Hornsby 3319]

1 minute ago, mdmost said:

This is why none of this will matter next year. Good OOCs are still possible when you have it not possibly screw you in late November. 

 

I love our bracket, we would play 3 straight big 10 teams on the way to the title game against Georgia. 

[Biff Tannen 45491]

1 minute ago, Hondo said:

"Vibes"

"I feel like"

Name-calling

 

I think I may have accidentally walked into the Ladies' Room. 

The plaque for the alternates is around here somewhere.

[The_Great_Hornsby 3319]

1 minute ago, bullet said:

Oregon played a lot of weak teams and beat them by big margins.

They beat PRIME by 50!!! They should be crowned National Champions just for that. 

[Radical Larry 28528]

9 minutes ago, Candi Fisther said:

Oregon’s AD is chairman of CFP committee. See y’all at the sugar bowl.

Corrigan is the AD at NC State. 

[Horn80 6075]

4 minutes ago, Hagbard Celine said:

exactly this - the rest of you just saw the committee raw and uncensored - zero logic or fucks given - and all of you are so damn certain we jump jort with a noles loss

okay then

To claim the committee looks at “everything” then makes decision that clearly ignores all the facts.  Sham

[utexas8 1433]

I want Washington to win so bad because fuck Oregon.

But Washington has been flirting with a loss all season.

[The_Great_Hornsby 3319]

Just now, Vic Mackey said:

Yep I meant to add that at the end. Even their own fans know they have zero chance with that backup QB. He is terrible right now. They struggled to beat a terrible Florida team who also started their backup QB. Louisville needs to do the country a favor and end their playoff hopes. As of right now, that seems to be our only hope. FSU losing. Michigan losing, too. Don't see us jumping Oregon at this point. Committee is fascinated with them. If it's between us and Oregon for that lost spot, we will be left out.

As dumb as this sounds, I am glad the committee put FSU at 4, because psychologically, it shifts the pressure to them. Now they feel the pressure of "win and in", a playoff spot is definitively on the line. If they had dropped them to 5, they would play more stress free and with a huge chip on their shoulder. 

Just now, utexas8 said:

I want Washington to win so bad because fuck Oregon.

But Washington has been flirting with a loss all season.

Just channel your big Penix energy

[bullet 1596]

8 minutes ago, dcar00 said:

ohio state is out after next week no need to discuss them, really because if we win they can't make it.

Even Herbstreit said the only way they get in is if FSU and Texas both lose.

[Atticus 3920]

Oregon’s position and our position don’t matter. If Oregon beat undefeated UW, they would pass us. 
Oregon takes UWs spot, we just need another spot to open up ala Florida St, mich, UGa losing

[Hondo 661]

2 minutes ago, Biff Tannen said:

The plaque for the alternates is around here somewhere.

No, no, no.  There's two Os in "Goose", boys.

[chainsaw 9837]

1 minute ago, utexas8 said:

I want Washington to win so bad because fuck Oregon.

But Washington has been flirting with a loss all season.

Penix is the kind of player who wills his team to unlikely wins. The only way to beat UW is to crush them and not let them back into the game.

I don't believe Oregon is good enough to do it.

[Chuckie Finster 22598]

Yup. 
Unfortunately we aren’t going to the playoffs in any scenario.

This is incorrect. We are a slam dunk in the scenario I described. But I wouldn’t feel particularly confident in any of the other ones.

[Dahobbs 17437]

12 minutes ago, Chuckie Finster said:

A lot of people here are clamoring for chaos. We do NOT want chaos. We want this very neat and tidy. Undefeated Georgia, undefeated Michigan, undefeated Washington. We want Oregon and Bama to have two losses and FSU and Ohio State to be one loss non-conference champs.

Anything else put this in the hands of the committee and they have made it very clear, for whatever reason, they do not respect our resume.

This is wrong. A conference champ has never been left out in favor of a non-conference champ of similar record. Never happened. The more one loss teams, the better for us. 

Any ranking before the final is merely to generate interest. They mean nothing. 

Edited November 29, 2023 by Dahobbs

[Billy Pilgrim 1912]

It doesn’t matter if Oregon or Washington wins. The winner is in and the loser is out (for the same reason OSU is out- they aren’t conference champs).

Whats ridiculous is that the rationale for voting OSU over are as right now (better strength of schedule, better wins) doesn’t apply to Texas vs Oregon. That’s what sucks about only opinions factoring and no computer polls.

[CashMcCoy 3199]

7 minutes ago, Radical Larry said:

Corrigan is the AD at NC State. 

Yeah, Mullens hasn’t been the chair for years. Also the Sugar Bowl is a CFP game. This thread is insane, but I will miss this shit during the offseason.

[texhorn 351]

what a fucking tool 

[bigcigar 1161]

Just now, Dahobbs said:

This is wrong. A conference champ has never been left out in favor of a non-conference champ of similar record. Never happened. The more one loss teams, the better for us. 

His scenario is by far the cleanest path for Texas to make the playoff. How is he wrong? 

[FloridaHorn 4735]

Texas wins and FSU loses and we are in. None of the other shit matters.

[The Dog 43792]

4 minutes ago, Chuckie Finster said:

This is incorrect. We are a slam dunk in the scenario I described. But I wouldn’t feel particularly confident in any of the other ones.

I think they put Ohio St in over us. 

[Texasborn91 897]

Let the dust settle Saturday then we can cry like bitches. If Louisville looks terrible on Saturday we may jump them. They’d be sending a lamb to slaughter for no reason. Every person in the world knows they aren’t winning shit in the playoffs. Undefeated…but thems the breaks sometimes. 

[Fug 540]

1 minute ago, The Dog said:

I think they put Ohio St in over us. 

Conference championships are one of the called out criteria 

[Js1 85095]

2 minutes ago, The Dog said:

I think they put Ohio St in over us. 

No. They. Won’t. 

Good God, y’all are delusional in trying to pretzel yourself into ensuring Texas is out. Teams that don’t play this weekend are getting passed up. As it happens EVERY YEAR. Unless a P5 champ has 2 losses, a 1-loss champ is in ahead of a 1 loss non champ. Every year. 

Edited November 29, 2023 by Js1

[blutow 222]

The only new thing we learned tonight is that there is no situation where we jump Oregon.  The rest of it is business as usual.  FSU loss and we're in.  Bama win and we have a good shot.  

[mdmost 42843]

1 minute ago, The Dog said:

I think they put Ohio St in over us. 

Not if we have a conference championship. That does make a difference. It didn't last year because no one else with a conference championship was high enough to be there in place of Ohio State. Utah, KSU. 

[The Dog 43792]

Just now, blutow said:

The only new thing we learned tonight is that there is no situation where we jump Oregon.  The rest of it is business as usual.  FSU loss and we're in.  Bama win and we have a good shot.  

We need Bama to lose because if they win in this case then we are out.

they couldn’t have telegraphed this more - Georgia is in no mattter what. 

[Texasborn91 897]

4 minutes ago, texhorn said:

what a fucking tool 

That man has no idea what the fuck he’s doing. That’s awesome for Nix, but their best win is an unranked Utah. 

[Red Five 40632]

1 minute ago, blutow said:

The only new thing we learned tonight is that there is no situation where we jump Oregon.  The rest of it is business as usual.  FSU loss and we're in.  Bama win and we have a good shot.  

We've all discussed this to death, but the best shot of that happening IMO is if Oregon, Texas, and Bama are all sitting at 12-1. And the committee says screw it and takes Texas and Bama. Texas and Oregon leaves out the SEC winner. Bama and Oregon and you're leaving out the team that gave Bama their one loss. 

[Js1 85095]

3 minutes ago, blutow said:

The only new thing we learned tonight is that there is no situation where we jump Oregon.  The rest of it is business as usual.  FSU loss and we're in.  Bama win and we have a good shot.  

All I care about is a Texas win and an FSU loss. Then we are in.