Jump to content

2025 Texas Coaching/Support Staff Thread


RaysBoomBoomRoom

Recommended Posts

31 minutes ago, Newy25 said:

The third quarter malaise and the red zone issues suggest Sark is great at scheme and design but too busy or ineffective at in game tactics and play calling. Once his script runs out, we go dormant for two quarters. He should keep scheming and scripting our opening but delegate play calling to someone focusing solely on that task. 

I truly think it's the "busy" part. He didn't seem to have these issues as an OC when he could spend a lot of time in-game reviewing/thinking/planning/adjusting. Now he doesn't have that time because he's watching the defense. The problem is that he hasn't compensated. Either he needs more playcalling input from elsewhere, or he needs to step away from the sideline on occasion to strategize offense while the defense is on the field.

  • Hook 'Em 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think he’s too reactionary to each game. If team a shuts down our screen game doesn’t mean team b can shut it down. He’ll go away from certain play calls that are successful because another team has stopped it before.  Wish he would mix it up more instead of scrapping it. Swing passes to rb should have been a staple instead Georgia shut it down so all teams will. Each game is different and personnel should dictate playcalls per roster we’re facing. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/19/2025 at 11:47 PM, DixonHur said:

I hope Sark hires an actual OC to handle the play calling.  

Not questioning Sark's ability as a play caller, and 100% want him deeply involved in game planning the offense and initial script, but I'd just rather he focus on being a HC during the game.

Sark is NOT going to give up play calling. Just stop with that.

 

2 hours ago, closetohumping said:

No, Yes

Fify 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

55 minutes ago, TrashMaster G said:

Sark is NOT going to give up play calling. Just stop with that.

 

Fify 

 

15 minutes ago, Fondren & Main said:

Ryan Day gave up play calling this year.  Sark will have to get kicked in the nuts a few more times before he does so as well.

I'm not sure about the bitching about Joseph.  Guy seems fine to me.  We got faster at CB and S and then the entire secondary played better.  Crazy how that works.

I was a hard no on sark being willing to give up play calling.   But I think before this year he was still in prove it stage.  Maybe now that he’s entrenched and got a real bag he’ll let go?  
 

or he’s a control freak

Link to comment
Share on other sites

46 minutes ago, Fondren & Main said:

Ryan Day gave up play calling this year.  Sark will have to get kicked in the nuts a few more times before he does so as well.

He didn't choose give it up. It wasn't his idea. The concept that he thought of it and brought it up and wanted to make the change is categorically wrong. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, NoName said:

He didn't choose give it up. It wasn't his idea. The concept that he thought of it and brought it up and wanted to make the change is categorically wrong. 

I don’t think it matter if it was his or lot his but a change that was made and now they’re national champions. Steve Spurrier and Jimbo Fisher are the only two play calling head coaches to win titles going back 30 years. Numbers pretty much say it’s not going to happen. 

  • Hook 'Em 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, AlrightAlrightAlright said:

I don’t think it matter if it was his or lot his but a change that was made and now they’re national champions. Steve Spurrier and Jimbo Fisher are the only two play calling head coaches to win titles going back 30 years. Numbers pretty much say it’s not going to happen. 

Thanks for getting the point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The 'it hasn't happened in x years' argument would be a lot more convincing if more coaches did it. How many P5 coaches are good enough to be calling their own plays right now? 4? 5? So yes, by simple math, the odds are not in their favor.

No one has done it since Jimbo Fimbo is also a really fancy way of saying if your name isn't Smart, Saban or Dabo, you probably don't have a title in the last 10 years.

Again, I'm not totally against the idea but if the reasoning is doing it just because other people did it, that is a poor way to operate.

  • Hook 'Em 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, AlrightAlrightAlright said:

I don’t think it matter if it was his or lot his but a change that was made and now they’re national champions. Steve Spurrier and Jimbo Fisher are the only two play calling head coaches to win titles going back 30 years. Numbers pretty much say it’s not going to happen. 

It ABSOLUTELY matters when it's pitched as "Ryan Day made the decision to give up play calling and it worked out for him" - which is how it's been pitched probably ten times on Surl.

Also Pete Carroll called plays in 04 I'm pretty sure. The Athletic said he did a while back but can't verify via Google. Tom Osborne I believe called plays for Nebraska for all their national championships.

Are we acting like Saban didn't have an inordinate amount of impact on what defensive plays were called week in and week out? Or that Kirby doesn't now and didn't early on at UGA and even after that today?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Hookem2147 said:

No one has done it since Jimbo Fimbo is also a really fancy way of saying if your name isn't Smart, Saban or Dabo, you probably don't have a title in the last 10 years.

Again, I'm not totally against the idea but if the reasoning is doing it just because other people did it, that is a poor way to operate.

We're in a pretty heavily defensive led decade of CFB right now.

Texas was the #3 DFEI team this year at 0.82, behind Ohio State at 0.83 and ND at 0.84.

DFEI isn't perfect but easy to get to on mobile and it's good.

DFEI rankings of last handful of champs

24 Ohio State 2

23 Michigan 1

22 Georgia 1

21 Georgia 1

20 Alabama 17 (1 offense)

19 LSU 11 (1 offense)

18 Clemson 1

17 Alabama 2

16 Clemson 9 (2 offense)

15 Alabama 1

14 Ohio State 7 (4 offense)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Norm Chow was USC’s play caller and as for Tom Osbourne, he may have in the 90s but the last time they played for a title he was not. Either way you’re looking as far back as Spurrier/Osbourne in the 90s and only Jimbo at the turn of this century. 
 

Of course Saban and Kirby know their their DCs call and may give help but they generally let them call the game. But those two guys are in both huddles especially when things aren’t going well. How often has Sark been in the defensive huddle to motivate them?

It would be much better for the program if Sark self scouts himself and sees he needs the change rather than his boss and other people telling him to do so. Watching the red zone woes the past two years and short yardage situations is unacceptable. Our 3rd quarters the past two years have been unacceptable. 
 

people all agree Sark is a magnificent script writer and game planner but his in game calls and adjustments leave a lot to be desired and if we didn’t have those issues this year we are likely hoisting the title trophy. 
 

 

Edited by AlrightAlrightAlright
Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, Hookem2147 said:

The 'it hasn't happened in x years' argument would be a lot more convincing if more coaches did it. How many P5 coaches are good enough to be calling their own plays right now? 4? 5? So yes, by simple math, the odds are not in their favor.

No one has done it since Jimbo Fimbo is also a really fancy way of saying if your name isn't Smart, Saban or Dabo, you probably don't have a title in the last 10 years.

Again, I'm not totally against the idea but if the reasoning is doing it just because other people did it, that is a poor way to operate.

Right now there are zero at it that are good enough to be doing it. The only ones that do it and have success right now are all NFL coaches which include McVay, Shanahan, and Reid. 
 

No other college coach right now is good enough at it to win a title in my opinion 

Edited by AlrightAlrightAlright
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, AlrightAlrightAlright said:

Norm Chow was USC’s play caller and as for Tom Osbourne, he may have in the 90s but the last time they played for a title he was not. Either way you’re looking as far back as Spurrier/Osbourne in the 90s and only Jimbo at the turn of this century. 
 

Of course Saban and Kirby know their their DCs call and may give help but they generally let them call the game. But those two guys are in both huddles especially when things aren’t going well. How often has Sark been in the defensive huddle to motivate them?

It would be much better for the program if Sark self scouts himself and sees he needs the change rather than his boss and other people telling him to do so. Watching the red zone woes the past two years and short yardage situations is unacceptable. Our 3rd quarters the past two years have been unacceptable. 
 

people all agree Sark is a magnificent script writer and game planner but his in game calls and adjustments leave a lot to be desired and if we didn’t have those issues this year we are likely hoisting the title trophy. 
 

 

Carroll was the defensive play caller for his teams at USC. 

The fantasy talk of Sarkisian ending his own playcalling tenure is as boring as it is tedious. 

  • Hook 'Em 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ryan Day gave up playcalling two years ago and gave Brian Hartline a shot. They really struggled, that’s why he brought in Kelly. I chuckle when I think of what would’ve become of Ohio State if Bill Obrien never got offered the Boston College job. That’s a fun alt history.

The Sark playcalling conundrum is fascinating. Sark is a very emotional playcaller and that’s what makes him great. He uses not only his scheme stuff but he relies on his relationships with his players and his knowledge of what they are confident in(very baseball-like). He’s mentioned this being a big part of his philosophy and he said that it was the main reason why he made PK come down from the press box after his 1st season. All that being said, the 3rd quarter stuff has got to get fixed because it’s unacceptable to be as bad as we were. We never scored more than 7 points in the 3rd quarter against a P5 opponent, yet we tripled our opponents in 3rd quarter yards lmao. It makes no sense. 
 

As far as the redzone stuff is concerned, Sark has got to have a plus run game or he becomes a prisoner to his creativity. The Bama and SC offenses were historically elite in the redzone because they had backs who could do it on their own. We were great in years one and two with Bijan and we’ve fallen off since. I think simply that without an elite back, Sark just has some serious Redzone demons. His redzone struggles cost 2019 Bama vs LSU, Atlanta as OC in the playoffs on a 4th and 1, and at Texas he threw a quick screen on 4th and an inch to Xavier Worthy in Dallas and obviously the semifinal endings in back to back years. I don’t think it has to do with him being the HC I think it’s just who he is.

  • Hook 'Em 1
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...