Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

This is Dan Neil's piece this morning from 247, why I continue to hold a sub on this site, I have no idea. I respect Dan as the former player that he is, but I can't stand him an editorial writer/TV analyst. More to follow after the spoilered write up.

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 I asked him a question in the comments and got the following response:

I'd like to hear if you think Herman gives preferential treatment to some players over others? We've seen players get pulled for both small and big on field mistakes, we've also seen them pulled for what seemingly happens off field or in practice. Why then don't players who continue to make mistakes get pulled. Ehlinger continues to make poor decisions, on top of not having progressed in his throwing mechanic, Hager still plays much too aggressively at times leading to big runs, Ominihue makes a boneheaded hit on the QB giving up a first down, yet these players are never punished on the field. I don't expect these players to be criticized publicly in a press conference, but they do need to be pulled aside and have their ass chewed out on the side line and sit for a few plays.

Tre Watson gave up an unfortunate fumble, a questionable one but it was ruled one regardless. Despite him being RB 1, and only making that 1 mistake, the staff answers by putting in Kyle Porter under the guise that he is the best blocker, and immediately he lines up out wide as a WR?

Shane Buchele reportedly has a great camp, has a winning record as a starter, has much better throwing mechanics, but he isn't a vocal leader, so we get the turnover machine instead.

Keontay Ingram, proves himself in the game, proved himself as a competitor at the highest level of pressure in the State Championship games, didn't make a mistake as far as I could see watching the game, displays great cutting ability and vision. He scores a touchdown, but doesn't hug a big ugly after scoring and we never see him again.

Herman is arrogant, that's okay. I like an arrogant head coach. What I don't like is someone pissing on my head and telling me that it's raining. He is not coming off as arrogant from being confidant, he is coming off as being arrogant because is in over his head and being defensive. He was a highly touted OC, he sparked the UH program with wins over much more talented teams and more experienced coaching staffs, yet how come we see none of that confidence, swagger, and innovation here?

There are different kind of mistakes. Mental and physical. Mental are inexcusable and need to be corrected. Physical mistakes happen to everyone and it would be hard to get mad at a player for being too aggressive. Fumbles are never OK. They do happen and no one will fault a team players who buys into the culture for the mistake. You also treat the senior leadership different then the freshman. Hopefully your seniors embody your culture and the freshman are still learning the culture.

I would admit that as long as the players are giving full effort and buying into the culture then the coach needs to play the best players. In the first week you are still figuring out who the best players are.

I'm all for discipline and rules, but feel as long as the player is the right character then we need to let them learn as we go and be hesitant to publicly punish someone for minor infractions. Pull the young man aside and use it as a teaching moment. Give the young man the benefit of the doubt that it was simply a mistake and will be corrected.

Being a dad of three kids makes you learn that mistakes happen and you need to determine the big ones from the minor ones.

Posted

This was my reply to which he never replied to:

So even if a player makes multiple mental mistakes, as long as they, are as you and some others have said "bought into the culture", then it is okay to continue to reward them with playing time and not give the opportunity to someone else?

Sounds to me like that is playing favorites, I get that you don't want to criticize your Westlake boys, just like I don't ever want to criticize players from my school either. I'm also not saying that coaches need to be on the sideline cussing a kid out and embarrassing them, but even when leaders make mistakes they need to be punished, whether that is sitting them for a set of downs or series and letting someone else get a shot, or opening up the competition for the job. The same thing happens in the real world based on my experience in the military, the corporate world, and in State Government.

I'm not laying all of this on the players, because I feel the biggest issue on Saturday was with the coaches, there is no reason that the players should have come out and let themselves be punched in the mouth again and again on both sides of the ball. The play-calling looked like something that a Pee Wee coach would do, totally uninspired and had no rhythm.

 

Also, you say fumbles are never okay, how about interceptions? How about busted assignments? How about not having your effing knee pads on and having to be subbed out on the first play, causing a delay of game?

The great coaches in all sports remove empathy from their decisions. I don't care if a player is a fan favorite, a legacy player, came from rough home life, overcame adversity to make it to college. I care about results, recruits care about results, alumni care about results, the NFL cares about results. We are not getting results, instead what we get is an arrogant jackass who is clearly in over his head, who does nothing but preach about "culture" and "accountability". He says he can feel the culture with this years team and that the locker room feels completely different than this time last year.

If this is the case then I don't want anything to do with this so called culture, because if your culture is one that looks like what Saturday was and what his pathetic press conferences were, then that is a losing culture.

  • Like 1
Posted

I've never been much of a poster, as I mostly would just say the same things that everyone else says on boards, but at this point I am getting fed up with how much these guys defend the coaches and players. 

Posted

I just try to imagine Herman playing Tua in the second half against Georgia last year, and I just don't see it.  As for Texas, I'd even rather take a chance and maybe even lose an extra game or two now if it means playing the best players overall for the long-term.  You can watch Ingram for all of a few plays to see he should be playing more this season and I can't understand why anyone would play Porter for any reason.  Even in literally only two plays with a first time freshman playing his first ever game, you could see right away Ingram is light years ahead of multiple seasons of watching Porter for his vision and ability to both cut back on his blockers and make people miss.  I just don't understand how they are deciding personnel decisions on offense sometimes...

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 5:09 PM, DigglerontheHoof said:

Wait, Ingram was pulled b/c he didn't hug a lineman after his score?  Is my  sarcasm meter broken?  

If true, fire his mensa ass now....JFC

Expand  

 

  On 9/4/2018 at 5:13 PM, PilotsError said:

it's not true

Expand  

I was about to get triggered if he had been pulled for that....who am I kidding, I'm still triggered from Saturdays' tomfoolery.

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 5:07 PM, kopp0e said:

Good post, it appears the response is in effect, if the kid is a favorite, they get "perks" as in not getting pulled...

Expand  

That is exactly what happens, same thing with Foreman last year. He was the best player on the field during games, reportedly didn't practice well and his Dad is an idiot so Armanti was punished for it.

Posted

Maybe I'm not getting OP's point, but Dan's response to your post made sense to me whether or not you agree with him.   Your follow up was a little all over the place.  I certainly don't think you bench Hager or Omenihu for their mistakes, primarily because they are both the best and most experienced.  None of us know what was said to them on the sidelines.   Sam's shitty decision was on the last play so guess you could bench him for this week but I certainly understand why they aren't.   I don't agree with Porter being in the game after the Watson fumble but I at least see the reasoning. I have more of an issue with how he was used (as Scipio said, if he's the best blocker on the team and they are dropping 8, then use his ass as a lead blocker for a QB run instead of splitting him out).

  • Like 2
Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 5:37 PM, Bevoball said:

That is exactly what happens, same thing with Foreman last year. He was the best player on the field during games, reportedly didn't practice well and his Dad is an idiot so Armanti was punished for it.

Expand  

Um, Armanti Foreman was not the best player on the field during games last year.

  • Like 2
Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 5:08 PM, UTDD said:

I just try to imagine Herman playing Tua in the second half against Georgia last year, and I just don't see it.  

Expand  

If the Sam shitty decision/int happened at the end of the first half I think a chance they would have set him a couple of series.  Lord knows we will probably get the chance to see how they will handle it.

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 5:42 PM, Skipper said:

Maybe I'm not getting OP's point, but Dan's response to your post made sense to me whether or not you agree with him.   Your follow up was a little all over the place.  I certainly don't think you bench Hager or Omenihu for their mistakes, primarily because they are both the best and most experienced.  None of us know what was said to them on the sidelines.   Sam's shitty decision was on the last play so guess you could bench him for this week but I certainly understand why they aren't.   I don't agree with Porter being in the game after the Watson fumble but I at least see the reasoning. I have more of an issue with how he was used (as Scipio said, if he's the best blocker on the team and they are dropping 8, then use his ass as a lead blocker for a QB run instead of splitting him out).

Expand  

The issue with Sam is that it isn't just that second interception, it is as a whole he does not look like a quarterback, this throws are shaky, under-powered, and dreadfully inaccurate. I'm not saying you bench Hager or Ominihu, but we constantly hear Herman preach accountability, yet we see players make egregiously stupid mistakes, such as a late hit on a QB in the 4th quarter, or having to be subbed out on the very first play of the game because they didn't put on their fucking knee pads, and there is no consequence. 

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 5:53 PM, Bevoball said:

Sorry I meant Wide Receiver, though it was probably a toss up between him and LJH.

Expand  

That I can see. 

Any talk of WR makes me sad because Collin Johnson has all of the physical gifts and continues to be the biggest disappointment on this football team. It kills me that he is so mediocre.

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 5:57 PM, Bevoball said:

The issue with Sam is that it isn't just that second interception, it is as a whole he does not look like a quarterback, this throws are shaky, under-powered, and dreadfully inaccurate.  

Expand  

Agree, the issue with Sam is that he is just not good enough of a passer to make defenses care. We have no balance on offense because defenses don't have to account for the passing game other than a few hail mary passes that are more than offset by the number of poorly thrown interceptions they will get.

Posted

I would rather use Shane, yes I know he isn't that much better than Sam. But I feel like you can more reliably scheme around his deficiencies by using the inside zone (though I would prefer a power run scheme over the zone scheme that Herman insists on), mixing in some play action, and a more open route tree. Honestly I can only identify three routes that the WR run, the curl, vertical, and bubble routes, and a lot of that has to do with it seeming like they are getting jammed up by the DB, or just running down the sideline.

Posted (edited)
  On 9/4/2018 at 5:57 PM, Bevoball said:

The issue with Sam is that it isn't just that second interception, it is as a whole he does not look like a quarterback, this throws are shaky, under-powered, and dreadfully inaccurate. I'm not saying you bench Hager or Ominihu, but we constantly hear Herman preach accountability, yet we see players make egregiously stupid mistakes, such as a late hit on a QB in the 4th quarter, or having to be subbed out on the very first play of the game because they didn't put on their fucking knee pads, and there is no consequence. 

Expand  

I mean the Sam issue is an entirely different can of worms and the subject of many threads.   At the end of the day they chose him as the starter.  It isn't like Shane's limitations aren't obvious and the other option are true freshman, so yeah, for 8th year in a row we don't have a clear cut QB.  That will clearly play out over the year with the new RS providing additional intrigue as FR may get a shot they wouldn't otherwise, but I think it would have been a 'panic' move to name Sam your starter and bench him game 2.    On your other points, you think we should have benched Collin for the entire game for a rules violation?  There may very well have been a consequence for CJ, we don't know, but I can only fathom the backlash (and rightfully so) if we would have benched our most talented WR because of that.

Edited by Skipper
Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 5:08 PM, UTDD said:
I just try to imagine Herman playing Tua in the second half against Georgia last year, and I just don't see it.


This is why Saban will retire with $100,000,000.

A - for having him on the roster in the first place, and B for knowing how to use him.
Posted (edited)
  On 9/4/2018 at 6:22 PM, Skipper said:

I mean the Sam issue is an entirely different can of worms and the subject of many threads.   At the end of the day they chose him as the starter.  It isn't like Shane's limitations aren't obvious and the other option are true freshman, so yeah, for 8th year in a row we don't have a clear cut QB.  That will clearly play out over the year with the new RS providing additional intrigue as FR may get a shot they wouldn't otherwise, but I think it would have been a 'panic' move to name Sam your starter and bench him game 2.    On your other points, you think we should have benched Collin for the entire game for a rules violation?  There may very well have been a consequence for CJ, we don't know, but I can only fathom the backlash (and rightfully so) if we would have benched our most talented WR because of that.

Expand  

Alot of this just has to do with being frustrated. I get tired of the rhetoric that we hear from this staff about so and so player has progressed so much, and so and so has become such a great leader.

This staff and team is so inept, that they can't follow the uniform rules, they can't think of any other play to run on 3rd and other than a WR screen that hasn't worked all day, and they can't even come out and play like a team that wants to be there?

For fucks sake they are lucky to not have been blown out by a team that has two QBs who are coming off of major knee surgery, had a player get killed in a team workout, whose program has been in headlines all summer, had their head coach suspended and will likely be fired, with an interim head coach who got fired at LSU because the offense was worse than usual, not to mention that this team fucking embarrassed you last year at home!

Am I over reacting? Yes, and I know I am, but at least I act like I give a damn about the program, instead of Coach Mensa, who wants to tell me that the team was trying too hard and that's why they lost. 

Edited by Bevoball
formatting
  • Like 1
Posted

Let me preface this post by saying that I was just as pissed as anybody, and I have zero faith that this team will turn it around and win more than they lose this year.  But I also went on record with an 8-4 season and I won't  believe that this team is trending in the right direction until right after the scoreboard clicks zero on their 9th regular season win of the year.  Doesn't look like that will be this year.

But I like Dan's answer and, as a fan, I like and respect Dan.  After listening to Herman yesterday, I somewhat understand what he is dealing with, and that it isn't an easy fix.  This team has no idea how to win.  Had they been matched up against a team like Northwestern State, they could have made all of the same errors they made against Maryland and still won easily.  Maryland has enough talent to make them pay for mistakes, so they tried to eliminate all of the mistakes, which made them play tight.

I'm about to lose all of the non-golfers here, but to take it away from football and to something that I understand, think about how trying to play perfect on a golf course affects your game.  It is never good.  Pressing leads to bad shots, which leads to poor decisions, which leads to more bad shots and more bad decisions.  It is a vicious cycle and leads to a score card that gets thrown in the trash.  The best golf is played when you truly learn to focus on the one shot you can take at a time.  The last shot is over, and you don't know what the next shot will be until this one has landed.  Most of the time when I ignore the score card and enjoy the game, I end up with a score I am proud of at the end of the day.

This is longer than I usually post, and may be just as useless to you as Dan's analogy.  But I look at the Maryland game as one that the players (just like the fans) know that they should win, and every mistake gets them further from that goal and makes them press harder, leading to more mistakes like my shot analogy above.

I think this thing will take time to fix and switching players / coaches / philosophies creates more variables rather than building a solid baseline.  Somehow we have to get to a solid baseline of winning more than we lose.

  • Like 5
Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 6:44 PM, jinx said:

Let me preface this post by saying that I was just as pissed as anybody, and I have zero faith that this team will turn it around and win more than they lose this year.  But I also went on record with an 8-4 season and I won't  believe that this team is trending in the right direction until right after the scoreboard clicks zero on their 9th regular season win of the year.  Doesn't look like that will be this year.

But I like Dan's answer and, as a fan, I like and respect Dan.  After listening to Herman yesterday, I somewhat understand what he is dealing with, and that it isn't an easy fix.  This team has no idea how to win.  Had they been matched up against a team like Northwestern State, they could have made all of the same errors they made against Maryland and still won easily.  Maryland has enough talent to make them pay for mistakes, so they tried to eliminate all of the mistakes, which made them play tight.

I'm about to lose all of the non-golfers here, but to take it away from football and to something that I understand, think about how trying to play perfect on a golf course affects your game.  It is never good.  Pressing leads to bad shots, which leads to poor decisions, which leads to more bad shots and more bad decisions.  It is a vicious cycle and leads to a score card that gets thrown in the trash.  The best golf is played when you truly learn to focus on the one shot you can take at a time.  The last shot is over, and you don't know what the next shot will be until this one has landed.  Most of the time when I ignore the score card and enjoy the game, I end up with a score I am proud of at the end of the day.

This is longer than I usually post, and may be just as useless to you as Dan's analogy.  But I look at the Maryland game as one that the players (just like the fans) know that they should win, and every mistake gets them further from that goal and makes them press harder, leading to more mistakes like my shot analogy above.

I think this thing will take time to fix and switching players / coaches / philosophies creates more variables rather than building a solid baseline.  Somehow we have to get to a solid baseline of winning more than we lose.

Expand  

I definitely see what you are saying there. A lot of what I am feeling is that Herman is a victim of playing favorites, and saying one thing but doing another, I feel like these are most evident with Sam and Porter, hell even with Andrew Beck not that he's been particularly bad but more so just meh. If what you are preaching is that you are bring a winning or championship culture, then he needs to cut out the sentimentality and favoritism. I get it, Sam has a likable story to him with him being a local kid and with his dad passing, but what has he done to prove that he is the leader of this team? I'm okay with him as the starter, if the game-plan is to run the ball alot allowing receivers to get open opening up the passing game, but based on saturday that isn't what this team is doing. Even if you look at the offense before they fell behind midway in the second, there was not a concerted effort to run the ball. 

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 5:42 PM, Skipper said:

 Sam's shitty decision was on the last play so guess you could bench him for this week but I certainly understand why they aren't.   I don't agree with Porter being in the game after the Watson fumble but I at least see the reasoning. I have more of an issue with how he was used (as Scipio said, if he's the best blocker on the team and they are dropping 8, then use his ass as a lead blocker for a QB run instead of splitting him out).

Expand  

Sam played shitty the whole game. If you were referring simply to bone headed mistakes, he also threw the ball away on a two point conversion. He had a few options like run for it or throw it to where only his teammate could catch it.

As for playing Porter, that was a mistake. Play Watson or the next guy on the depth chart who knows the playbook. Can Johnson not catch the ball? Does Ingram not know the plays or does he make too many mistakes? Personally, I would have stuck with Watson. He did fumble but that call was BS. He was called down on the field so I thought the rule was that there had to be incontrovertible evidence to overturn it. I don't see that that was the case. Anyway, the error to play Porter was on either Beck, Drayton or Herman depending on who makes the personnel choices on offense. 

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 6:56 PM, Bevo said:

Sam played shitty the whole game. If you were referring simply to bone headed mistakes, he also threw the ball away on a two point conversion. He had a few options like run for it or throw it to where only his teammate could catch it.

As for playing Porter, that was a mistake. Play Watson or the next guy on the depth chart who knows the playbook. Can Johnson not catch the ball? Does Ingram not know the plays or does he make too many mistakes? Personally, I would have stuck with Watson. He did fumble but that call was BS. He was called down on the field so I thought the rule was that there had to be incontrovertible evidence to overturn it. I don't see that that was the case. Anyway, the error to play Porter was on either Beck, Drayton or Herman depending on who makes the personnel choices on offense. 

Expand  

The TD pass to Duvernay was pretty choice, though. But otherwise, I agree with you.

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 6:22 PM, Skipper said:

I mean the Sam issue is an entirely different can of worms and the subject of many threads.   At the end of the day they chose him as the starter.  It isn't like Shane's limitations aren't obvious and the other option are true freshman, so yeah, for 8th year in a row we don't have a clear cut QB.  That will clearly play out over the year with the new RS providing additional intrigue as FR may get a shot they wouldn't otherwise, but I think it would have been a 'panic' move to name Sam your starter and bench him game 2.    On your other points, you think we should have benched Collin for the entire game for a rules violation?  There may very well have been a consequence for CJ, we don't know, but I can only fathom the backlash (and rightfully so) if we would have benched our most talented WR because of that.

Expand  

Is Lil'Jordan a WR? Because if so he is our most talented WR by a mile. Collin is our most physically gifted, and uses his height pretty well, but he is not more talented than LJ.

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 7:12 PM, BurdineBandit said:

Is Lil'Jordan a WR? Because if so he is our most talented WR by a mile. Collin is our most physically gifted, and uses his height pretty well, but he is not more talented than LJ.

Expand  

Probably meant the same thing.  I agree LJH is a better WR.   CJ is a better NFL prospect (that for whatever reason isn't sniffing his potential at this point).

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 7:05 PM, C-Man said:

The TD pass to Duvernay was pretty choice, though. But otherwise, I agree with you.

Expand  

Thanks to a borderline Herculean effort to catch up to it, grab it and maintain possession all the way through the play. Easily the best catch he's ever made. Had he not managed to corral it, we'd have been talking about how Sam missed him, too. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't think that Sam has a very high football IQ, but he can be an above average QB in time.  I have no idea why they didn't run the ball more from the QB position.

Not trusting Ingram because he is a freshman and having Brett Robin Kyle Porter on the field at any point in the game blows my mind.  Both are very Mack like.

Collin Johnson not having his knee pads in is something that I hope he did half a mile of bear crawls for, but he has never been truly bought into the culture from what I have read.  So you are damned either way on that one, and you have to have him on the field.

Time is a flat circle and momentum is (apparently) an illusion, but we sure could use some illusions right now.

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 6:56 PM, Bevo said:

Personally, I would have stuck with Watson. He did fumble but that call was BS. He was called down on the field so I thought the rule was that there had to be incontrovertible evidence to overturn it. I don't see that that was the case.

Expand  

You are correct. It is supposed to require indisputable evidence to overturn a call, and there absolutely was not indisputable evidence. I'd love to hear that explanation. 

  • Like 1
  • Fuck You 1
Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 7:13 PM, JBJ said:

The fumble had nothing to do with it.  Porter was in for both 2-minute offenses.

Expand  

Why is our #4 RB on the depth chart in for 2-minute offenses?  Why are the coaches incapable of coaching up the first three players on the depth chart to run the 2-minute offense?  

Posted

The worst part about a big Texas loss, beyond the loss itself, is having to wade through all the morning after articles from 9.95 internet "pundits" who feel the need to craft brainless think-pieces that say absolutely nothing of value.

  • Like 1
Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 9:21 PM, deech said:

Why is our #4 RB on the depth chart in for 2-minute offenses?  Why are the coaches incapable of coaching up the first three players on the depth chart to run the 2-minute offense?  

Expand  

Good questions? Ask our big money donors? Maybe their asses should have to answer questions at press conferences.

Posted
  On 9/4/2018 at 4:55 PM, Bevoball said:

tl;dr

Expand  

Tom Herman has been head coach for 647 days. The idea that he can change the culture in the next 81 while having to game plan each week and get ready for a game is comical. He had a year to start building things and then an offseason to re-enforce it and we saw the same poor preparation, poor in game coaching and mental mistakes we saw last year and under Charlie. If Tom Herman hasn't figured things out yet he likely isn't going to. He'll be here through next year so fretting about it won't matter. If he goes 6-6 again this year or worse the big money donors will blame it all on Charlie Strong. You can mark my words on that.

Posted (edited)
  On 9/4/2018 at 9:21 PM, deech said:

Why is our #4 RB on the depth chart in for 2-minute offenses?  Why are the coaches incapable of coaching up the first three players on the depth chart to run the 2-minute offense?  

Expand  

fwiw,  Scipio stated Porter was in on the 2 minute offense for his blocking ability/recognize blitz to protect Sam.  (Scipio interview yesterday,  104.9, Chad and Kevin).

Should be noted that Maryland only rushed 3 with a spy linebacker.

Edited by torre
Posted (edited)
  On 9/4/2018 at 6:44 PM, jinx said:

But I like Dan's answer and, as a fan, I like and respect Dan.  After listening to Herman yesterday, I somewhat understand what he is dealing with, and that it isn't an easy fix.  This team has no idea how to win.  Had they been matched up against a team like Northwestern State, they could have made all of the same errors they made against Maryland and still won easily.  Maryland has enough talent to make them pay for mistakes, so they tried to eliminate all of the mistakes, which made them play tight.

Expand  

Thats the fucking reason he gets paid $5 million a year. You think the kids at UCF knew how to win when Scott Frost showed up after an 0-12 season? Two years later they were 12-0. Check out  Urban Meyer's stints at BGU and Utah. That's what good coaches do. Shitty coaches bitch about their players trying to hard in season 2. 

Did Herman expect to walk into a top paying job, with top resources, more talent than 90% of FBS schools, with a team of trained assassins already laser focused on winning. Why the fuck did he think the job was open in the first place? The more I think about that press conference and his pussy ass excuses, the more it pisses me off. Fuck that clown.

Edited by Blotto
  • Like 4

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...