Gumbo

[After irth 1246]

17 minutes ago, irishtexan said:

Also, the recommendation on this thread to add Worcestershire sauce made a huge fucking difference. Noticeable umami. Threw it in when I added the shrimp 5 mins before playing. Awesome.

How much did you add to that pot?

[irishtexan 11712]

How much did you add to that pot?

Didn’t measure. Probably like 5-6 healthy dashes

[dcbc 14644]

21 minutes ago, irishtexan said:

Didn’t measure. Probably like 5-6 healthy dashes

I usually do a tablespoon along with a tablespoon of soy sauce. 

[UncleBuck 6455]

Threw down on some gumbo yesterday. Smoked/BBQd some chicken thighs over pecan and used Pollok's pork sausage. Turned out nice. 

Also, a +1 on shaking some W-sauce into it. Literally, this was the first time I tried doing gumbo without it, and toward the end my taste-test was kinda "ehhhhh ok?"  Shook some W-sauce in and it was $$$$$.

 

Edited July 25, 2022 by UncleBuck

[South Austin 53227]

Several years ago my Cajun friend in Breaux Bridge taught me to put Worcester and/or soy sauce in gumbo.  That, in addition to homemade stock, were game changers.

[dcbc 14644]

1 hour ago, South Austin said:

Several years ago my Cajun friend in Breaux Bridge taught me to put Worcester and/or soy sauce in gumbo.  That, in addition to homemade stock, were game changers.

I always credit some guy in South Austin, who I'm willing to bet doesn't live in south Austin.

Edited July 25, 2022 by dcbc

[South Austin 53227]

5 minutes ago, dcbc said:

I always credit some guy in South Austin, who I'm willing to bet doesn't live in south Austin.

I would’ve changed my username in the move from Shaggy to Surly, but then folks would’ve grieved over the loss of “South Austin’s Mom.”

[dcbc 14644]

2 minutes ago, South Austin said:

I would’ve changed my username in the move from Shaggy to Surly, but then folks would’ve grieved over the loss of “South Austin’s Mom.”

Yeah, my username doesn't really mean anything in the context of this board or shaggy, and my avatar is confusing when people meet me in person and I don't resemble Earl Campbell in any way, shape, or form.  But its weird when people change those things, so I stuck with it.

Edited July 25, 2022 by dcbc

[huge 3831]

I suspect this would also be a good add.

[UncleBuck 6455]

32 minutes ago, huge said:

I suspect this would also be a good add.

Jugo Maggi is in my michelada recipe

[Lhorn 5094]

Is this too dark?  It was my first time making roux in the microwave.  About 1.5 cups flour., just over a cup of oil.  Probably a total of 11 minutes cooking time (divided and stirred twice during cooking).  It was a bit lighter when I took it out but continued to darker a bit as it cooled on the counter.  

Its always hard for me to tell if there is a burnt taste vs smokey.  Not sure what to think.

Edited August 25, 2022 by Lhorn

[South Austin 53227]

Looks fine to me. My rule of thumb is that I add the trinity to my roux when it’s just about a shade lighter than I ultimately want it to be, because sautéing the vegetables for a while always seems to get the roux a notch or two darker. 

Also, the darker the roux, the better the flavor, but the darker it gets it loses its thickening ability. Saw that on Alton Brown when he went all science and shit on how to make roux. So if you go darker but want it thick, maybe add some okra and/or file at the end.

[HouTex 1942]

3 hours ago, South Austin said:

Looks fine to me. My rule of thumb is that I add the trinity to my roux when it’s just about a shade lighter than I ultimately want it to be, because sautéing the vegetables for a while always seems to get the roux a notch or two darker. 

Also, the darker the roux, the better the flavor, but the darker it gets it loses its thickening ability. Saw that on Alton Brown when he went all science and shit on how to make roux. So if you go darker but want it thick, maybe add some okra and/or file at the end.

This.  Prudomme talks about this in his original cookbook.  He strives for a black roux which is hard to do without burning it.  He also says that your color is perfectly fine for a good gumbo.  I find that sometimes if I get it too dark that I have a hard incorporating the roux into the stock.  Bottom line is that I get it to your color and then add the trinity as SA says.

[DalTxHornFan 3130]

2 hours ago, HouTex said:

This.  Prudomme talks about this in his original cookbook.  He strives for a black roux which is hard to do without burning it.  He also says that your color is perfectly fine for a good gumbo.  I find that sometimes if I get it too dark that I have a hard incorporating the roux into the stock.  Bottom line is that I get it to your color and then add the trinity as SA says.

And is there a more glorious smell in the world than the incorporation of the trinity into hot roux?  Looking forward to Fall! 

[Lhorn 5094]

I’m afraid that when I hear the roux and then cook the trinity, the roux will go too far  and burn.

Can I cook the trinity, add stock, bring to a boil then add the roux?  

[South Austin 53227]

3 hours ago, Lhorn said:

I’m afraid that when I hear the roux and then cook the trinity, the roux will go too far  and burn.

Can I cook the trinity, add stock, bring to a boil then add the roux?  

I've never done it that way.  You shouldn't worry about burning the roux after you add the trinity, because adding the vegetables will help bring down the temperature to keep the roux from burning (assuming you're cooking your roux at around medium heat and not much hotter).  If you want to be super careful, turn down the heat on pot or take it off the heat altogether, but I've never had to do that.

Edited August 25, 2022 by South Austin

[Texzilla58 4792]

I’m afraid that when I hear the roux and then cook the trinity, the roux will go too far  and burn.
Can I cook the trinity, add stock, bring to a boil then add the roux?  

I think sautéing the veg a bit is a great idea. I’m a milk chocolate roux guy because I end up burning it going much darker. Add the sautéed veg to the roux and cook a bit together then add the stock.

Big mistake most make: not having their meeze done before starting. Timing is everything here. So everything must be prepped and ready to go. Why do I know this? Too many burned dishes from winging it.

[South Austin 53227]

1 hour ago, Texzilla58 said:

Big mistake most make: not having their meeze done before starting. Timing is everything here. So everything must be prepped and ready to go. Why do I know this? Too many burned dishes from winging it.

Yep, pretty basic rule if you add the trinity to the roux.  Make sure you have all the veggies chopped and ready to go, because you won't have time to do so once the roux is cooking, as you'll need constant stirring (unless, of course, you have a copilot in the kitchen who can do that for you).

Edited August 25, 2022 by South Austin

[Brisketexan 106899]

8 hours ago, South Austin said:

Also, the darker the roux, the better the flavor, but the darker it gets it loses its thickening ability. Saw that on Alton Brown when he went all science and shit on how to make roux.

CSB: many years ago, my daughter did a "comparison of thickening quality" of various colors of roux for her science project.  Took first place in her class.  Did a basic white roux, a golden roux, a peanut butter roux, and a dark roux.  Mixed the same quantity of each with 1 cup of water, then timed how long it took to flow through a funnel.  Explained the thickening quality of gluten and how it was affected by heat (stealing liberally from Alton Brown's explanation).  I thought it was one of the kids' cooler school projects.  I really was amazed at the significant difference between even a peanut butter roux and a dark roux.

[dcbc 14644]

1 hour ago, Brisketexan said:

CSB: many years ago, my daughter did a "comparison of thickening quality" of various colors of roux for her science project.  Took first place in her class.  Did a basic white roux, a golden roux, a peanut butter roux, and a dark roux.  Mixed the same quantity of each with 1 cup of water, then timed how long it took to flow through a funnel.  Explained the thickening quality of gluten and how it was affected by heat (stealing liberally from Alton Brown's explanation).  I thought it was one of the kids' cooler school projects.  I really was amazed at the significant difference between even a peanut butter roux and a dark roux.

Eighth grader and I were brainstorming and watching old Mythbusters episodes trying to come up with good science project ideas.  You post is well timed.  Thanks!

[BearSchlong 8240]

This.  Prudomme talks about this in his original cookbook.  He strives for a black roux which is hard to do without burning it.  He also says that your color is perfectly fine for a good gumbo.  I find that sometimes if I get it too dark that I have a hard incorporating the roux into the stock.  Bottom line is that I get it to your color and then add the trinity as SA says.

Reminds me of how he made beef debris sauce. Reduced it to the consistency of motor oil. So so good.

[ROFL BOX 6655]

Seems like it is Gumbo weather again & I'm looking @ Saturday night / TCU watching for a good opportunity.

Sent from my SM-A326U1 using Tapatalk

[PantsTent 2005]

Tailgate gumbo. Got this far at home and taking it down for the rest of the process. 2.5 cup oil and 3.5 cup flour roux done in oven for 2.5 hrs while I relaxed and got other shit ready.

[Texzilla58 4792]

That is fuckin perfect. When convenient I’d like to see your recipe for the oven method of rouxage.

Would like a pic of finished product if you have one.

[South Austin 53227]

I just bought a 16-lb turkey for Thanksgiving. Why post that here? Because  turkey gumbo is coming.

[MalibuSheriff 1095]

A question for the Magnalite devotees - which model is your preferred gumbo pot?  13 quart, 17 quart or other?

[dcbc 14644]

5 hours ago, MalibuSheriff said:

13 quart, 17 quart

Seems like a lot of gumbo.  Are you planning to make a lot of gumbo?  What time?

[MalibuSheriff 1095]

3 hours ago, dcbc said:

Seems like a lot of gumbo.  Are you planning to make a lot of gumbo?  What time?

I’ve got an 8quart cast iron that’s my go-to gumbo pot for years (decades…olddds). I was thinking about adding a large pot for gatherings (Holidays, Mardi Gras).  Come on up…bring some crawfish…

 

[After irth 1246]

17 hours ago, MalibuSheriff said:

A question for the Magnalite devotees - which model is your preferred gumbo pot?  13 quart, 17 quart or other?

All-Clad 24 qt Stock Pot has never let me down.  Regardless of brand, however, go big...you'll be ready for anything.

Edited November 14, 2022 by After irth

[PantsTent 2005]

22 hours ago, Texzilla58 said:

That is fuckin perfect. When convenient I’d like to see your recipe for the oven method of rouxage.

Would like a pic of finished product if you have one.

There's an Alton Brown recipe somewhere for oven method, but it's just whisk on stove in dutch oven until all the initial bubbles die down, then into oven at 350F. Come back and stir it every 30-45 mins. It takes about 2.5 hrs for my oven, but then back to stove to put in veggies.

I didn't take any pictures at the tailgate but do have some leftovers in the fridge.

[jeevsie 3789]

Made a great batch yesterday.  Got a good and dark roux, but as noted, I didn't get the thickening power.  I guess next time just make more roux? I did a cup of flour and half cup each of butter and oil. It was a pretty big pot.

[Brisketexan 106899]

Made a great batch yesterday.  Got a good and dark roux, but as noted, I didn't get the thickening power.  I guess next time just make more roux? I did a cup of flour and half cup each of butter and oil. It was a pretty big pot.

The darker the roux, the less the thickening power. That’s why dark roux gumbo is often served with file.

[RMac5 1557]

I made another chx and sausage gumbo today. Colder than shit up here in Amarillo and a perfect day for gumbo. This one tasted much better than my last one, I think a key difference was my roux. I have always used the fat/flour ratio of 1:1, or very close to that. I recently read that the  1:1 ratio is supposed to be by weight not volume. Thought I would experiment on today’s roux. I used 1C of oil to 1 3/4C of flour, I think it made a big difference in both taste, and the ability to get the roux darker quicker. I also used a round le creuset Dutch oven in place of my coon ass magnalite pot. My magnalite is big and oval and harder to get in the corners while stirring. Anyway, todays was much better. Any of our gumbo pro staff have opinions on roux fat to oil ratios?

Edited November 15, 2022 by RMac5

[HouTex 1942]

I’ve always measured the oil and flour by volume and with a 1:1 ratio.  Never had a problem doing so.  

[After irth 1246]

I do 1:1, but I weigh the flour rather than scoop.  I also use Unsalted Butter instead of Oil.

[South Austin 53227]

12 hours ago, RMac5 said:

I made another chx and sausage gumbo today. Colder than shit up here in Amarillo and a perfect day for gumbo. This one tasted much better than my last one, I think a key difference was my roux. I have always used the fat/flour ratio of 1:1, or very close to that. I recently read that the  1:1 ratio is supposed to be by weight not volume. Thought I would experiment on today’s roux. I used 1C of oil to 1 3/4C of flour, I think it made a big difference in both taste, and the ability to get the roux darker quicker. I also used a round le creuset Dutch oven in place of my coon ass magnalite pot. My magnalite is big and oval and harder to get in the corners while stirring. Anyway, todays was much better. Any of our gumbo pro staff have opinions on roux fat to oil ratios?

I’ve done both for several years. My Le Creuset works great for a low and slow roux.

And for the flour/oil ratio, most Cajun recipes I see call for a 1:1 ratio in terms of cups, whether it’s 1 cup flour and 1 cup oil, or 3/4 cup oil and 3/4 cup flour, whatever. I’ve found that regardless of how much oil I use for any particular batch, I always add about 1/2 cup more flour. 

Here’s a real game changer – instead of oil, use rendered duck fat. 

[dcbc 14644]

2 hours ago, South Austin said:

I’ve done both for several years. My Le Creuset works great for a low and slow roux.

And for the flour/oil ratio, most Cajun recipes I see call for a 1:1 ratio in terms of cups, whether it’s 1 cup flour and 1 cup oil, or 3/4 cup oil and 3/4 cup flour, whatever. I’ve found that regardless of how much oil I use for any particular batch, I always add about 1/2 cup more flour. 

Here’s a real game changer – instead of oil, use rendered duck fat. 

Your new avatar is a game changer and is confusing.

[South Austin 53227]

1 minute ago, dcbc said:

Your new avatar is a game changer and is confusing.

It's a tribute to one of the few aggy's to experience a national championship in recent memory.  (It's only temporary.  Bruce will be back in a week or so.)

[dcbc 14644]

Just now, South Austin said:

It's a tribute to one of the few aggy's to experience a national championship in recent memory.  (It's only temporary.  Bruce will be back in a week or so.)

Lulz.  And thank goodness. 

[UncleBuck 6455]

Man, this weekend might be time for some smoked chicken thigh and sausage gumbo. Need to start doing my own roux again, been lazy lately. 

[RMac5 1557]

5 hours ago, South Austin said:

I’ve done both for several years. My Le Creuset works great for a low and slow roux.

And for the flour/oil ratio, most Cajun recipes I see call for a 1:1 ratio in terms of cups, whether it’s 1 cup flour and 1 cup oil, or 3/4 cup oil and 3/4 cup flour, whatever. I’ve found that regardless of how much oil I use for any particular batch, I always add about 1/2 cup more flour. 

Here’s a real game changer – instead of oil, use rendered duck fat. 

Will try the duck fat next. I have been adding the Worcestershire sauce and it seems to really improve the flavor too. So much going on in a gumbo it’s hard to tell when you make a few changes which ones contribute the most. My favorite is chicken and sausage but think the next one will be a seafood version. Might be a turkey one with Thanksgiving being right around the corner.

[Shoxthemonkey 1994]

On 11/14/2022 at 10:48 AM, Brisketexan said:

The darker the roux, the less the thickening power. That’s why dark roux gumbo is often served with file.

Thanks. I didn't know that. I finally got a batch really dark without burning it and was surprised at the soupiness of the finished gumbo. I thought that I might have done something wrong. The leftovers were nice and gravy like the next day, though.

ETA, I used schmaltz that I skimmed from the homemade chicken stock after it cooled. I wondered if that helped get it darker. Usually I get a little antsy and stop cooking the roux early.

Edited November 17, 2022 by Shoxthemonkey

[Brisketexan 106899]

3 minutes ago, Shoxthemonkey said:

Thanks. I didn't know that. I finally got a batch really dark without burning it and was surprised at the soupiness of the finished gumbo. I thought that I might have done something wrong. The leftovers were nice and gravy like the next day, though.

Well, it's a known thing -- gumbo is actually better the next day.  I really hadn't thought about a darker roux gumbo thickening up some overnight, but that wouldn't surprise me.

[dcbc 14644]

Fire up the stock pots Surly Gumbophiles. It is time.

[RMac5 1557]

What’s in your stock @dcbc? Looks like you have a bay leaf in there as well. I’m planning on a couple of onions, couple of carrots and a few stalks of celery. Thought about  adding some peppercorns but not sure since my turkey was fried and had a lot of seasoning to begin with. 

[dcbc 14644]

What’s in your stock [mention=548]dcbc[/mention]? Looks like you have a bay leaf in there as well. I’m planning on a couple of onions, couple of carrots and a few stalks of celery. Thought about  adding some peppercorns but not sure since my turkey was fried and had a lot of seasoning to begin with. 

It's the Emeril easy stick posted upthread.

Turkey carcass
4 qts water
2 onions quartered
3 stalks of celery cut into 4" pieces
4 bay leaves
1 T peppercorn
2 tsp salt

Bring to a boil and simmer for 2 hours. Run through a sieve and refrigerate for gumbo tomorrow (I'll skim the fat then)

[Murfdogg21 4563]

On 8/25/2022 at 5:11 AM, South Austin said:

So if you go darker but want it thick, maybe add some okra and/or file at the end.

He is his mother’s son. 

[South Austin 53227]

No pics, but I made my turkey stock last night using the Emeril recipe. Not sure I’ll make it back from the game in time to start the gumbo, so it may not be until Saturday morning.

[dcbc 14644]

Man, I thought this thread would be jumping. Keeping the tradition alive at our place and employing techniques from the Surly Braintrust, I browned the sausage, added the soy sauce and Woosty , made homemade stock, and even used some of the stock to cook the rice.

Edited November 3, 2023 by dcbc

[South Austin 53227]

17 minutes ago, dcbc said:

Man, I thought this thread would be jumping. Keeping the tradition alive at our place and employing techniques from the Surly Braintrust, I browned the sausage, added the soy sauce and Woosty , made homemade stock, and even used some of the stick to cook the rice.