Drafting NFL QBs

[Guest]

From Eli to Rivers, Baker to Johnny Hatecrime, from Wentz to Goff...

 Think the Bears would like a redux of the 2017 Draft?

Edited September 26, 2018 by slorch

[Zavala 1384]

It's always hard to tell from the outside.

Mahommes would've probably sucked with da Bears as well.

[Bateshorn 9927]

Yeah, Andy Reid is a warlock with developing QB's. 

[trza-hawk 269]

I have been scouting quarterbacks for the NFL for thirty years, and the one thing I always emphasize is their height. you just can't coach tall.

[Hiphopopotamos 20869]

15 minutes ago, Zavala said:

It's always hard to tell from the outside.

Mahommes would've probably sucked with da Bears as well.

 

As a Bears fan - I can almost guarantee that Mahomes would have had a shitty rookie year.  He would have been forced to play and would have had John Fox as his HC and Darrell Loggains as his OC.  The Bears had one of the most conservative and predictable offenses in the NFL last year.  Probably the most predictable and conservative offenses of the last decade.

Andy Reid is a wizard - and part of the reason Matt Nagy was hired as Head Coach in Chicago is because of his working for Reid, and the job he did with Alex Smith and Mahomes (though Mahomes only started one game last year).

I have no idea what Trubisky would be like this year if he had the opportunity to sit and learn for a season on an Andy Reid coached team - but I guarantee it would be a hell of a lot better for a QB's development than being forced to play in Chicago's 1950's offense that Trubisky had to play in last year.

Trubisky wasn't my first choice (I wanted Watson), and I'm certainly not convinced that he'll ever amount to anything, but it was always expected that it was going to take him longer than most because of his inexperience - he only started 13 games in college.  

Bears fans are definitely nervous seeing how much success young QB's like Watson and Mahomes are having - but we're used to it.

[Guest]

28 minutes ago, trza-hawk said:

I have been scouting quarterbacks for the NFL for thirty years, and the one thing I always emphasize is their height. you just can't coach tall.

Dan McGwire was dominant as fuck...LOlz.

[GopherRock 1765]

49 minutes ago, Zavala said:

It's always hard to tell from the outside.

Mahommes would've probably sucked with da Bears as well.

Chiefs will be the runaway 1 seed in the AFC and promptly soil themselves in the divisional round. Rinse, repeat. 

[Murfdogg21 4412]

3 hours ago, trza-hawk said:

I have been scouting quarterbacks for the NFL for thirty years, and the one thing I always emphasize is their height. you just can't coach tall.

Fucking Drew Brees, how does quarterbacking work???

[BabaYaga 15288]

8 minutes ago, Murfdogg21 said:

Fucking Drew Brees, how does quarterbacking work???

Always exceptions.  R. Wilson is another.  But generally the NFL game is still centered around a big, tall QB with a cannon for an arm.  Not much of a mystery.

[Slacks 6819]

3 hours ago, trza-hawk said:

I have been scouting quarterbacks for the NFL for thirty years, and the one thing I always emphasize is their height. you just can't coach tall.

you're tricking me, aren't you?

[MaybeACoordinator 8349]

There are diminishing returns as to height after you hit 6'5" or so. The list of supertalls is pretty undistinguished:

 

McGwire, Dan 6' 8"
Patrick, Frank 6' 7"
Gibbs, Sonny 6' 7"
Mitchell, Scott 6' 6"
Navarre, John 6' 6"
Anderson, Derek 6' 6"
Quinn, Jonathan 6' 6"
Blundin, Matt 6' 6"
McClure, Brian 6' 6"
Wilson, Marc 6' 6"
Hamdan, Gibran 6' 6"

Add Brock Osweiler (6'8") and Paxton Lynch (6'7") to the shit list, but also Joe Flacco and Nick Foles to the successes. (Both 6'6") Schaub is also 6'6" and he was both shit and decent.  

Edited September 26, 2018 by MaybeACoordinator