The Mandalorian (Star Wars live action show)

[Dutch 4464]

How old is your kid? My best friend’s dad let all the neighborhood kids watch Predator,  Terminator, Commando, etc when I was around eight, and I turned out ok.*

*obligatory “for a Surly asshole.”

[Speedtrucker 2063]

He’s 8, and yeah I saw most of them around 7-10

[Murfdogg21 4412]

The lady who has voiced Ahsoka from the beginning made a statement yesterday that reads like she’s pissed at Filoni for not being considered for the live role. 

[mdmost 42747]

If he replaced her in a follow up cartoon that would be one thing. Live action is completely different. Rosario Dawson isn't a slouch. 

[Speedtrucker 2063]

The lady who has voiced Ahsoka from the beginning made a statement yesterday that reads like she’s pissed at Filoni for not being considered for the live role. 

I know they made an online thing about it before that she’d be perfect to play her if Ashoka ever went live action but she’s super white... That’d be like Dee Bradley baker playing Rex now days...

[FORTY NINE TO ZERO 2630]

she can’t play an orange Alien?  
 

[mdmost 42747]

Not as good as Rosario Dawson can. 

[Speedtrucker 2063]

she can’t play an orange Alien?  
 

Well my thought is she looks more tan bronze.

Guess I just picture Rosario pulling it off more naturally than a trump-style orange face.

[Nivek 16804]

2 hours ago, Speedtrucker said:

I know they made an online thing about it before that she’d be perfect to play her if Ashoka ever went live action but she’s super white... That’d be like Dee Bradley baker playing Rex now days...

2,1

[ernest_t_bass 1196]

9 hours ago, Nivek said:

2,1

Endorsed

[atomheartbevo 89350]

18 hours ago, Murfdogg21 said:

The lady who has voiced Ahsoka from the beginning made a statement yesterday that reads like she’s pissed at Filoni for not being considered for the live role. 

In her defense, she carried the Ahsoka torch for a long time, even when there was no active shows in production.   I’ve been to a convention where a shit-ton of people stood in line for her autographs, photos, whatever, and she had her fans.  

[Buzzrock 14867]

I’m not saying Ashley should automatically get the nod, but I’m not totally feeling RD as Ahsoka. Ahsoka is one of my favorite characters ever and I really want them to do her justice. She has such an interesting arc across Clone Wars and Rebels.

[billfromlaketravis 11351]

Ahoska is a pretty big character, and a fan favorite. They had to go with a name actress. Rosario Dawson is pretty connected, and definitely a Star Wars fan, but her resume is a little sparse. 
 

Her last good movie was Sin City (2005). Last good movie she starred in, 25th Hour (2002). A lot of voice work/TV since then. 

[Buzzrock 14867]

At least they didn’t go with the designated sci-fi queen, Zoe Saldana

[mdmost 42747]

She was a regular on four Marvel projects, Daredevil, Iron Fist, The Defenders and Luke Cage. Marvel properties are owned by Disney. 

Edited March 27, 2020 by mdmost

[Viper 12011]

1 hour ago, billfromlaketravis said:

Ahoska is a pretty big character, and a fan favorite. They had to go with a name actress. Rosario Dawson is pretty connected, and definitely a Star Wars fan, but her resume is a little sparse. 
 

Her last good movie was Sin City (2005). Last good movie she starred in, 25th Hour (2002). A lot of voice work/TV since then. 

what? did no one watch Trance? 

[billfromlaketravis 11351]

Just now, Viper said:

what? did no one watch Trance? 

As @mdmost pointed out, she’s earned her keep on Marvel TV. I guess they need somebody about Dawson’s age. Personally, I can see Dawson as Ahoska. 

But yeah, she hasn’t been a feature film star, or regular, for quite some time

[Pato del Muerto 52314]

20 minutes ago, billfromlaketravis said:

As @mdmost pointed out, she’s earned her keep on Marvel TV. I guess they need somebody about Dawson’s age. Personally, I can see Dawson as Ahoska. 

But yeah, she hasn’t been a feature film star, or regular, for quite some time

As opposed to Pablo whoever, Nick nolte , Gina carano, and Carl weathers?

[crash_davis 23078]

On 3/26/2020 at 2:59 AM, Murfdogg21 said:

The lady who has voiced Ahsoka from the beginning made a statement yesterday that reads like she’s pissed at Filoni for not being considered for the live role. 

I dig her. She has a legit gripe but she needs to be careful. I don't think they started development on the Rebels sequel with Ahsoka, Sabine and Ezra. Would suck if they had someone else voice Ahsoka for that series.

[Scary Stranger 1712]

1 hour ago, crash_davis said:

I dig her. She has a legit gripe but she needs to be careful. I don't think they started development on the Rebels sequel with Ahsoka, Sabine and Ezra. Would suck if they had someone else voice Ahsoka for that series.

Is that an actual thing or a theory?  I haven't heard anything about that.

[The Dog 43769]

2 minutes ago, Scary Stranger said:

Is that an actual thing or a theory?  I haven't heard anything about that.

She's not happy but is taking the high road. https://www.slashfilm.com/ashley-eckstein-responds-to-ahsoka-tano-casting-in-the-mandalorian-season-2/

 

[Buzzrock 14867]

She was a regular on four Marvel projects, Daredevil, Iron Fist, The Defenders and Luke Cage. Marvel properties are owned by Disney. 

Well, she was the same supporting character in all of those.

[mdmost 42747]

Okay. People were acting like she hasn't done much in a while. She also starts in a show on the USA Network. If they created Sabine, I wouldn't think they should cast the person who voiced her either. This is such a dumb manufactured controversy by people online. Not saying here but Reddit is acting all whiny about this. Star Wars fans are the worst. 

Edited March 27, 2020 by mdmost

[Viper 12011]

1 hour ago, mdmost said:

Okay. People were acting like she hasn't done much in a while. She also starts in a show on the USA Network. If they created Sabine, I wouldn't think they should cast the person who voiced her either. This is such a dumb manufactured controversy by people online. Not saying here but Reddit is acting all whiny about this. Star Wars fans are the worst. 

I mean it wouldn't be the worst casting, plus always great to get a UT alumn some work

[Buzzrock 14867]

Freddy Prinze Jr as Kanan?

[Speedtrucker 2063]

Dave filoni as Chopper?!?

Although it’s be interesting to see David Oyelowo as Kallus.

[mdmost 42747]

You ever seen the guy who voices Ezra? Give him a haircut and he's actually not that far off. And the MF who voices Thrawn would be a dead ringer. Paint his ass blue. He's also Mads Mikkelsen's brother (Galen Erso).

[Speedtrucker 2063]

You ever seen the guy who voices Ezra? Give him a haircut and he's actually not that far off. And the MF who voices Thrawn would be a dead ringer. Paint his ass blue. He's also Mads Mikkelsen's brother (Galen Erso).

Yeah Lars mikkelsen does kinda look like Thrawn.

When he was on the Witcher, I happened to be reading a text but as he started talking a snapped up saying “Thrawn?!?”

[oSuJeff97 3435]

Yeah that guy could totally play Thrawn.

So who would eventually play Ezra?  IIRC, I think Ezra was supposed to be *roughly* the same age as Luke and Leia right?  I know they were both supposed to be 19 at the time of ANH.... seems like Ezra would have been in that same ballpark, or perhaps even maybe a year or two younger.

So during the time of the Mandalorian, he should be..what... late 20s/early 30s, give or take a few years?

[Pato del Muerto 52314]

1 hour ago, oSuJeff97 said:

Yeah that guy could totally play Thrawn.

So who would eventually play Ezra?  IIRC, I think Ezra was supposed to be *roughly* the same age as Luke and Leia right?  I know they were both supposed to be 19 at the time of ANH.... seems like Ezra would have been in that same ballpark, or perhaps even maybe a year or two younger.

So during the time of the Mandalorian, he should be..what... late 20s/early 30s, give or take a few years?

I mentioned Wilmer valderama on another thread

[Drew 2331]

I’m not saying Ashley should automatically get the nod, but I’m not totally feeling RD as Ahsoka. Ahsoka is one of my favorite characters ever and I really want them to do her justice. She has such an interesting arc across Clone Wars and Rebels.

Same. I LOVE RD. And I’m sure she’ll pull it off.

But much like Gal Gadot, who’s been great at WW(I was super skeptical at first) I still don’t think she’s really WW to me. I have no complaints though with her. Just thought someone bigger, bustier?, should have played her.

Kind of like Ryan Reynolds IS Deadpool. And Margot Robbie took Harley Quinn to a point I can’t picture anyone else...I’m not sure Dawson can do that yet.

But I have am hopeful and have faith in Filoni.

[oSuJeff97 3435]

On 3/28/2020 at 1:01 PM, Pato del Muerto said:

I mentioned Wilmer valderama on another thread

I know actors can often play younger, but he's 40.  Ezra (I think) would be in his late 20s during the time of the Mandalorian.

[Speedtrucker 2063]

Yeah there are quite a few good Hispanic actors that could play an older Ezra... hell I kinda thought benicio del toro might have been Ezra in the last Jedi before they made him have a weird lisp for some reason.

Gael Garcia Bernal would also be a solid choice for an older Ezra.

Wilmer would be a decent choice as well.

All of them would have to work on losing the accent though.

Agent Kallus could be played by leiv schreiber, he had the same beard when he played sabertooth

[Pato del Muerto 52314]

Jake busey could be kallus. Or Scott caan if you want a different body type. 

[NorthLoop 14071]

Seeing articles on fb saying that Boba will be in season 2, played by the actor who played Jango in the prequels.

[Levi 2576]

Looks like he’ll play as Rex, too. 

[Drew 2331]

I actually don't hate that at all.

 

They better have a very fucking good explanation for how Boba Fett lived though.

[Patricio Swayze 17058]

I actually don't hate that at all.
 
They better have a very fucking good explanation for how Boba Fett lived though.

Ewoks nursed him back to health.

[Drew 2331]

Motherfucking space care bears....

 

@mulletpelini will be ecstatic though.

 

[Pato del Muerto 52314]

Why can’t another clone get the same gear and be a new boba fett?

[The Dog 43769]

2 hours ago, Drew said:

I actually don't hate that at all.

 

They better have a very fucking good explanation for how Boba Fett lived though.

there isn't one. I sure hope this isn't true because I think Boba Fett is stupidly overrated. and he died - and isn't a force user so there's no "using the force somehow" to cheat death. 

The sarlacc ate him. He's desert poop. The End.

Totally on board with Rex though. 

[Speedtrucker 2063]

Yeah not a fan of boba fett return but absolutely cool with old badass Rex still looking for a fight and knowing Jedi.

With Ashoka and Rex, baby Yoda will definitely get explained to the new crew how important his connection to the force is

[Nivek 16804]

I got the feeling from Rebels that Rex had not see a Jedi for a while.  

Boba reborn as a clone trooper in disguise is rather Cobra Commanderish, and I like it.  Maybe a Bad Batcher?

[billfromlaketravis 11351]

The Bad Batch in live action would be wild

[UT_OB1 2200]

On 3/30/2020 at 9:11 AM, oSuJeff97 said:

I know actors can often play younger, but he's 40.  Ezra (I think) would be in his late 20s during the time of the Mandalorian.

Ezra was born 19 years BBY, so he’s the same age as Luke. Luke is 23 in RotJ, so yes, Ezra would be late 20s (28)

[Buzzrock 14867]

I’m down with Boba coming back. He was armored up and I’ve heard he escaped in the comics. He had a jet pack and a grappling hook, I could see it.

Hell Darth Maul survived being chopped in half and that turned out awesome.

[Speedtrucker 2063]

I’m down with Boba coming back. He was armored up and I’ve heard he escaped in the comics. He had a jet pack and a grappling hook, I could see it.

Hell Darth Maul survived being chopped in half and that turned out awesome.

That’s the only argument I’m accepting and praying for

[Speedtrucker 2063]

I got the feeling from Rebels that Rex had not see a Jedi for a while

That was right, they went into hiding because they thought most the Jedi had been wiped and those that survived would definitely be hostile towards clones. As scenes when Kanen meets them.

But they still vividly remembered surviving under the Jedi in combat including Yoda.

[Buzzrock 14867]

There are four named actors for S2E1 on IMDB


https://www.imdb.com/title/tt11150494/

[atomheartbevo 89350]

On 5/10/2020 at 12:36 PM, Nivek said:

Boba reborn as a clone trooper in disguise is rather Cobra Commanderish, and I like it.  Maybe a Bad Batcher?

I got the G.I. Joe series/movies for my 7-year-old, and we've been slowly working through them, and as batshit as some of those are, some of the Star Wars stuff rivals them, particularly the last 3 movies.