The Mandalorian (Star Wars live action show)

[Deej 77965]

That wasn't a mystery clone, that was Boba Fett.

I'm sure Dave Filoni has a plan. 

[Neonmoon 38130]

Am I the only child that liked adventure filler?

[Patricio Swayze 17058]

Am I the only child that liked adventure filler?

Nope. I enjoyed it. And I don’t like spiders.

[mdmost 44254]

I hate spiders and I liked the episode. Was it a bit of a filler, sure. But I don't mind them as they usually set up something later. And we have yet another deep cut courtesy of Filoni. The droid "Treadwell" that Amy Sedaris talks to is the droid Luke has with him when he observers the opening battle in A New Hope. It was a deleted scene that never made the final film and was only in the rough edit Lucas showed his friends. The Krykna were also in Rebels though they were a desert version of the spiders and impervious to blaster fire. 

[NotActuallyALonghorn 5006]

Nobody really thought the space whales episode in Rebels was important at the time either. In Filoni we trust.

[NTVTXN 1439]

1 hour ago, NotActuallyALonghorn said:

Nobody really thought the space whales episode in Rebels was important at the time either. In Filoni we trust.

IMO that’s one characteristic of a great franchise. A Director who’s dialed in can tie back almost anything from the series and people will “get it”.  If Filoni “geeks” on something, you can damn sure about a million other fans will have a similar reaction. 

[Radical Larry 28830]

3 hours ago, Neonmoon said:

Am I the only child that liked adventure filler?

Nope.

[Surly Bevo 25896]

I liked it, did it advance the plot much...no.  Was it entertaining....absolutely.  And on the tie back, shit that episode tied back to another side adventure episode from last season with the whole prison break/double cross etc episode.  It sets up the idea that things done previously even if seemingly insignificant continue to matter in the story arc, and frankly that's life, that's adventure...little shit that you didn't notice can come back big time later.  

[Pato del Muerto 53638]

Why did this episode drop on the fourth Tuesday of this week?

[Js1 87366]

Frog Lady during the ship crash had me dying. Need some gifs

[hornian 5299]

When frog lady didn’t start eating the spiders I was disappoint. 

[mdmost 44254]

The episode was directed by Peyton Reed from Ant Man. The giant ant was a nice nod to that. 

[Apep 646]

It doesn't advance the plot?

1. Mando is a wanted criminal to both the Imperial remnants and to the New Republic, even if his actions are understandable to the Republic.

2. Sublight travel exists and is used for purposes other than the hyperdrive being down. Probably a Rebels tie-in.

3. The New Republic isn't the Federation. They stopped to help, but left fixing the ship to Mando.

And filler? This is an hour of the Child and fangirl squeeing. Shit, we saw that upthread: "Eat that egg, you little green bastard. Yeah. Yeah." Sploosh.

[Neonmoon 38130]

And yes I was cackling the entire episode at the Baby Yoda egg eating bit. 

[DeepEastTexas 647]

2 hours ago, Apep said:

It doesn't advance the plot?

1. Mando is a wanted criminal to both the Imperial remnants and to the New Republic, even if his actions are understandable to the Republic.

2. Sublight travel exists and is used for purposes other than the hyperdrive being down. Probably a Rebels tie-in.

3. The New Republic isn't the Federation. They stopped to help, but left fixing the ship to Mando.

And filler? This is an hour of the Child and fangirl squeeing. Shit, we saw that upthread: "Eat that egg, you little green bastard. Yeah. Yeah." Sploosh.

No, it doesn't advance the plot in any meaningful way.  True, Filoni might re-visit elements of this episode just as he did in the whale episode of Rebels, as mentioned above by someone.  But, until that happens, this episode was more filler than anything else. 

1. We knew Mando was a wanted criminal by the Imperial Remnant after Moff Gideon's episode last season.  We also knew the Republic wanted him, and if we didn't know that for sure, we had a pretty good idea after he was a party to the murder of New Republic soldiers while helping with a prison ship breakout last season.  That was when Bill Burr guest starred.  Guess who else guest starred in that episode...Dave Filoni as an X-Wing pilot.  Guess who guest starred as an X-Wing pilot this episode...Dave Filoni.

2. We already knew sub-light travel existed.  Remember, in The Empire Strikes Back the Millennium Falcon's hyper drive was damaged and they had to limp to Bespin from the Noad system after dodging the Imperial Fleet.  Guess who followed them at sub-light speed....Slave I and Boba Fett.

3. I don't know that the New Republic pilots not helping fix the ship was all that important, outside of tying up this episode with a nice bow.

Speaking of Boba Fett, wouldn't it have been amazing to see him step out from behind the rocks after Mando was thrown from his speeder? I thought for sure after those three slapdicks dismounted him and were killed by Mando, that the Fett Man would walk out from behind a rock.  Too bad we didn't get that.  

Still fun to watch the show, this was just a sub-standard episode.  Especially after last week's outstanding season premiere. 

[Deej 77965]

Maybe "Grey's Anatomy" is more your speed?

[atomheartbevo 90730]

16 hours ago, Surly Bevo said:

...little shit that you didn't notice 

Cobb Vance literally bent over to shoot the rock, which hit the dragon in the eye.

The original Boba Fett action figure could only bend over, and originally had a spring-loaded rocket, that was recalled because...it was hitting kids in the eye.

Love this stuff.

[MC Fresh Breath 4075]

So the aliens/spiders bit scared my son into a panic attack. Other than that, I enjoyed it.


Tapasuck

[DeepEastTexas 647]

4 hours ago, Deej said:

Maybe "Grey's Anatomy" is more your speed?

I hear Friends is on Netflix.  Maybe you can go watch the 10 seasons and 220+ episodes of that show and revel in the plot development.  Sounds like your speed.

[atomheartbevo 90730]

37 minutes ago, DeepEastTexas said:

I hear Friends is on Netflix.  Maybe you can go watch the 10 seasons and 220+ episodes of that show and revel in the plot development.  Sounds like your speed.

Community is far superior to Friends.

[Murfdogg21 4583]

I’m on both sides of the fence. It was entertaining, but we only get 8 episodes and it may be 2022 before we see more. I’d prefer not burning one of the 8 episodes with frog lady taxi service and running from giant space spiders. 

[cam4mav 772]

11 hours ago, DeepEastTexas said:

No, it doesn't advance the plot in any meaningful way.  True, Filoni might re-visit elements of this episode just as he did in the whale episode of Rebels, as mentioned above by someone.  But, until that happens, this episode was more filler than anything else. 

1. We knew Mando was a wanted criminal by the Imperial Remnant after Moff Gideon's episode last season.  We also knew the Republic wanted him, and if we didn't know that for sure, we had a pretty good idea after he was a party to the murder of New Republic soldiers while helping with a prison ship breakout last season.  That was when Bill Burr guest starred.  Guess who else guest starred in that episode...Dave Filoni as an X-Wing pilot.  Guess who guest starred as an X-Wing pilot this episode...Dave Filoni.

2. We already knew sub-light travel existed.  Remember, in The Empire Strikes Back the Millennium Falcon's hyper drive was damaged and they had to limp to Bespin from the Noad system after dodging the Imperial Fleet.  Guess who followed them at sub-light speed....Slave I and Boba Fett.

3. I don't know that the New Republic pilots not helping fix the ship was all that important, outside of tying up this episode with a nice bow.

Speaking of Boba Fett, wouldn't it have been amazing to see him step out from behind the rocks after Mando was thrown from his speeder? I thought for sure after those three slapdicks dismounted him and were killed by Mando, that the Fett Man would walk out from behind a rock.  Too bad we didn't get that.  

Still fun to watch the show, this was just a sub-standard episode.  Especially after last week's outstanding season premiere. 

So what you're saying is next episode Boba Fett will be trailing Mando and step in to help/confront/something on his sublight flight / destination after trailing him from Tatooine to the ice planet onto his next destination all while undetected on Slave One ......?

 

I think that might advance in a meaningful way.... for a filler episode.

[DeepEastTexas 647]

That would be amazing. Especially with only 6 episodes left.

[Halohal 557]

It like playing KOTOR doing side jobs. Getting old and played out although CGI is awesome and new to keep my interest. Just don't forget to tie in within season... because rushing at the end sucks.

[Herpa Derpa 6361]

3 hours ago, DeepEastTexas said:

That would be amazing. Especially with only 6 episodes left.

Do you really think BY is getting home this season? Some of you don’t appear to understand the difference between an open ended television show and a movie. If you’re only watching for the destination, you’re really gonna miss the journey. 

[DeepEastTexas 647]

1 hour ago, Herpa Derpa said:

Do you really think BY is getting home this season? Some of you don’t appear to understand the difference between an open ended television show and a movie. If you’re only watching for the destination, you’re really gonna miss the journey. 

No, I don’t think he’s getting home anytime soon. 

[Apep 646]

Slower-than-light travel points to travel to the Unknown Regions. It was a plot point in Rebels. Sabine + Ahsoka + the child also point to the Unknown Regions.

[Deej 77965]

I'd rather have this slow burn for multiple seasons than whatever that shit was with the last three sequels 

Olyphant should have been cast as the Mandalorian. 

Edited November 8, 2020 by Deej

[atomheartbevo 90730]

54 minutes ago, Deej said:

I'd rather have this slow burn for multiple seasons than whatever that shit was with the last three sequels 

Agreed.  Thankfully, it sounds like Filoni/Favreau and the TV side are untouchable by Kennedy.

54 minutes ago, Deej said:

Olyphant should have been cast as the Mandalorian. 

I think Pascal's voice is much more suited to it, and part of Olyphant's appeal is his facial expressions.

I would have liked Olyphant to keep the armor and, owing to the main threats to his little town being wiped out, perhaps join Mandalorian's little band of misfits.

[Deej 77965]

He sounds a lot like Olyphant. Tone. 

[BayouBill 835]

That episode was tits

[mdleast 8554]

Spider tits

[aggie08 21865]

On 11/6/2020 at 9:57 PM, longhornmatt said:

Half of the episodes last season didn’t really advance the plot, either.   It’s basically a serialized 80s show like The A-Team or Magnum PI set in the Star Wars universe.  And it’s great.

That was my "complaint" last season: that it's an extremely formulaic procedural. Mando takes mission from suspect person and/or with suspect stipulations, it inevitably goes wrong, his ship gets fucked up (seriously, I think he's had to repair his ship 6 times in 10 episodes), and the bad guys/aliens kick the greatest warrior in the universe's ass until he's saved by his magical armor or other McGuffin.

But it's such a fun universe that it's easy to look past all that and just enjoy it for what it is. Not everything has to be an epic tale.

[Viper 12235]

Plus another Filoni cameo. He's really put on some weight in that cockpit.

[FORTY NINE TO ZERO 2652]

Loved seeing the OT insect alien while at the same time getting an entirely new frog species 

[Viper 12235]

On 11/7/2020 at 9:46 AM, mdmost said:

The episode was directed by Peyton Reed from Ant Man. The giant ant was a nice nod to that. 

 

34 minutes ago, Xian said:

Loved seeing the OT insect alien while at the same time getting an entirely new frog species 

Also, Dr. Mandible? classic

[oSuJeff97 3439]

Sheesh.... the whole "advance the plot/didn't advance the plot" argument takes me back to post-Sopranos episode arguments if the previous episode didn't focus enough on Mob machinations.

Anyone who watched Rebels, Clone Wars or, hell, Mandalorian season 1 shouldn't be surprised about episode 2.  That's exactly in-line with how Filoni tells stories.  You're not going to get touchstones of the primary overarching plot every week... they are going to be sprinkled in throughout the season, you're going to have a lot of "side adventures" that seemingly have nothing to do with the overall story, and there WILL be a great payoff in the end.

In Filoni we (should) trust.

[Kyle 208]

Anyone else leave with "Baby Yoda is kind of a dick?"

[Viper 12235]

43 minutes ago, Kyle said:

Anyone else leave with "Baby Yoda is kind of a dick?"

I thought it looked like he learned his lesson at the end

[kevwun 16460]

Right after he ate another egg?  He gives no fucks when it comes to food.

Edited November 9, 2020 by kevwun

[Kyle 208]

2 minutes ago, kevwun said:

Right after he ate another egg?  He gives no fucks when it comes to food.

Glad no one told Palpatine all he needed to do was keep a bowl of frog eggs in his senate chamber-pod.

 

[Viper 12235]

5 minutes ago, kevwun said:

Right after he ate another egg?  He gives no fucks when it comes to food.

Well it's not like he can just put it back. It was sort of like having one last cigarette before you quit

[McCroskey 1512]

Mando really wanted some naps in this ep.

Enjoyed it.

[Sbbruin 22150]

On 11/6/2020 at 10:36 AM, DeepEastTexas said:

I thought this episode was incredibly weak. It did nothing to advance the story. Just a filler episode that wasn’t very entertaining. 

I agree and disagree.  It did nothing to advance the story (which was weird, why wouldn't you move it forward a little); but it was entertaining.  Haven't watched the next ep, so I will eject from the thread.

[Red Five 41814]

How do you know it didn’t advance the story? Maybe Mando falls in love with frog lady. Maybe baby Yoda is allergic to those eggs and they have to find a Yoda hospital ASAP.

[Guadaloopy 11144]

I enjoyed Baby Yoda doing his Cool Hand Luke 50 eggs trick. 
 

“Baby Yoda and the Forbidden Boba”

[oSuJeff97 3439]

On 11/9/2020 at 7:11 AM, Viper said:

Plus another Filoni cameo. He's really put on some weight in that cockpit.

Maybe he's playing Porkins' younger brother.

Edited November 11, 2020 by oSuJeff97

[oSuJeff97 3439]

16 hours ago, Red Five said:

How do you know it didn’t advance the story? Maybe Mando falls in love with frog lady. Maybe baby Yoda is allergic to those eggs and they have to find a Yoda hospital ASAP.

Joking aside, it's definitely true that we don't know yet how it will advance the story.

Someone posted above about slower-than-light travel/unknown regions.... that was a HUGE thing in Rebels and given that Thrawn/Ezra are currently hanging out in unknown regions and Ashoka/Sabine are looking for them... this episode could end up being a key piece to linking the series together and introducing those characters.

Be patient and trust in Filoni.

[RamjetFDO 10656]

[Kermit 3167]

17 hours ago, Sbbruin said:

I agree and disagree.  It did nothing to advance the story (which was weird, why wouldn't you move it forward a little); but it was entertaining.  Haven't watched the next ep, so I will eject from the thread.

It’s an episodic slow burn. They’re not going to advance the plot in some episodes. They’re going to light speed the plot in others, kind of like the other shows Filoni has developed. Everything so far has been the most enjoyable, live action Star Wars vehicle since Empire. Good story telling to me isn’t constantly jamming the plot forward, it’s pacing. Dave has a plan, and it’s worked so far. Once the Clone Wars/Rebels characters surface, it’ll be all systems go.