NFL Mount Rushmore

[BurntOrange&White 41866]

Who is on your NFL players Mount Rushmore?

 

 

Tom Brady

Jerry Rice

 

For sure

 

 

Possibilities to fill out remaining

 

Emmitt Smith

Jim Brown

Joe Montana

 

Having trouble thinking of defensive guys. Would you split yours 2 offensive, 2 defensive?

[Guest]

Tom Brady

A bunch of other guys way the fuck below him, and I’m a Cowboys fan.

maybe start with

Jim Brown

Jerry Rice

Lawrence Taylor

[alincoln 2391]

Brady, Brown and Rice are no doubters.

Montana used to be but Rice and Brady move him off imo.  4 is debatable  but I would go with Manning.  

[Surly Bevo 25748]

Jim Brown

Johnny Unitas

Dick Butkus

Tom Brady

 

If we are really doing a true Mt Rushmore you need some early generation guys  (Washington and Jefferson) a bridge (Lincoln) and the recent guy to it being built (Teddy)

Edited January 21, 2019 by Surly Bevo

[Wally Pryor 5410]

7 minutes ago, slorch said:

Tom Brady

A bunch of other guys way the fuck below him, and I’m a Cowboys fan.

maybe start with

Jim Brown

Jerry Rice

Lawrence Taylor

From Michael Smith / Pro Football Talk:

Brady has had 17 (healthy) seasons as a starter and been to the Super Bowl 9 times. The last 6 QBs inducted into the Hall of Fame (Warner, Favre, Stabler, Moon, Marino, Young) were starters for a combined 76 seasons and went to a total of 8 Super Bowls.

 

 

 

[USMCHorn 1369]

1. Jerry Rice

2. Lawrence Taylor

3. Tom Brady 

4. Barry Sanders

That's it.

[futureman 22702]

brady is the only player that’s not open to debate.  figuring out the the other three will just become a useless shit flinging waste of time.  

just carve brady’s face into the side of a mountain and be done with it. 

[futureman 22702]

Just now, USMCHorn said:

1. Jerry Rice

2. Lawrence Taylor

3. Tom Brady 

4. Barry Sanders

That's it.

heh.  

[Guest]

Nm

Edited January 21, 2019 by slorch

[Guest]

5 minutes ago, Wally Pryor said:

From Michael Smith / Pro Football Talk:

Brady has had 17 (healthy) seasons as a starter and been to the Super Bowl 9 times. The last 6 QBs inducted into the Hall of Fame (Warner, Favre, Stabler, Moon, Marino, Young) were starters for a combined 76 seasons and went to a total of 8 Super Bowls.

 

 

 

SB is a factor, with regard to ‘clutchicity’. 

 

Brady’s whole body of work is a little bit supportive of him being the GOAT as well.  It’s not like he’s Larry Brown or Timmy Smith.

[Guest]

13 minutes ago, USMCHorn said:

1. Jerry Rice

2. Lawrence Taylor

3. Tom Brady 

4. Barry Sanders

That's it.

#4 arguably wasn’t even the best RB of his era and you’re suggesting greatest ever?

Lolz.

Even Jim Brown says it was him, Earl and then however you want to list the rest.

Edited January 21, 2019 by slorch

[Cheeseweasel 26439]

Brady, Rice, LT, Ronnie Lott.

[Underdog 29191]

Brown,  Brady, Rice & Unitas

[TreatyOak 17380]

BIG Mt Rushmore

Edited January 21, 2019 by TreatyOak

[Vertigo 20497]

You would probably have an easier time doing a Mount Rushmore of QB's. How could you argue Lawrence Taylor versus Barry Sanders? Madness I tell you. 

 

For QB's I would go

Brady, Montana, Manning, and Brees just edging out Marino

[futureman 22702]

brady, aikman, michael irvin, emmitt smith. 

that’s it. 

[Jebus 1341]

Just now, futureman said:

brady, aikman, michael irvin, emmitt smith. 

that’s it. 

heh.

[Radical Larry 28822]

If Jeff Heath isn't on your list, you're doing it wrong. 

[futureman 22702]

Just now, Radical Larry said:

If Jeff Heath isn't on your list, you're doing it wrong. 

goddammit.  but you’re right. 

[Surly Bevo 25748]

3 minutes ago, Radical Larry said:

If Jeff Heath isn't on your list, you're doing it wrong. 

Yea he's a hell of a kicker

[kopp0e 1135]

1 hour ago, slorch said:

Tom Brady

A bunch of other guys way the fuck below him, and I’m a Cowboys fan.

maybe start with

Jim Brown

Jerry Rice

Lawrence Taylor

The sad thing is that many of the greats, we have never seen play in real life, as in Terry Bradshaw or Joe Namath...

[futureman 22702]

2 minutes ago, kopp0e said:

The sad thing is that many of the greats, we have never seen play in real life, as in Terry Bradshaw or Joe Namath...

[Guest]

20 minutes ago, TreatyOak said:

BIG Mt Rushmore

Coarch Art Briles didn’t make it?

[Surly Bevo 25748]

1 minute ago, slorch said:

Coarch Art Briles didn’t make it?

He's a fucking I-tay now.  You can't put a fucking I-tay on  Mt Rushmore

[TexArcher 39072]

This is impossible unless we do it by position.

[Vertigo 20497]

21 minutes ago, kopp0e said:

The sad thing is that many of the greats, we have never seen play in real life, as in Terry Bradshaw or Joe Namath...

Much like Eli Manning, those guys were really only great during playoff runs. Pretty pedestrian the rest of the time. 

[former alkie 72]

18 minutes ago, TexArcher said:

This is impossible unless we do it by position.

This is correct.....but to start, the no-brainers are:

RB:  Earl

QB:  Tom Brady

Corner:  Deion Sanders 

[Captain Ron 13133]

Brady, Belichick, Kraft, Brady again

[CooterBrown 18288]

No Montana. He was a system QB before anyone knew what that was. 

[South Austin 53227]

Tom Brady

Jerry Rice

Lawremce Taylor

Vai Sikahema

[futureman 22702]

[Saint Tacky 1647]

43 minutes ago, TexArcher said:

This is impossible unless we do it by position.

Fodder for discussion.  

QB
Brees
Montana
PManning
Brady

RB
Sanders
ESmith
Brown
Payton

OL
Munoz
Upshaw
Webster
Hannah

TE
Gonzalez
Newsome
Casper
Witten
 

Offense Mt. Rushmore
Brady
Brown
Munoz
Gonzalez

[futureman 22702]

4 minutes ago, Saint Tacky said:

Fodder for discussion.  

QB
Brees
Montana
PManning
Brady

RB
Sanders
ESmith
Brown
Payton

OL
Munoz
Upshaw
Webster
Hannah

TE
Gonzalez
Newsome
Casper
Witten
 

Offense Mt. Rushmore
Brady
Brown
Munoz
Gonzalez

OL sans larry allen just solidifies your place in history as biggest fuckwit in the history of the world.  congratulations!

[Saint Tacky 1647]

3 minutes ago, futureman said:

OL sans larry allen just solidifies your place in history as biggest fuckwit in the history of the world.  congratulations!

Well Homer, there's not any one of those four that Allen could replace without an argument. Good luck with that Asperger's though.

[futureman 22702]

1 minute ago, Saint Tacky said:

Well Homer, there's not any one of those four that Allen could replace without an argument. Good luck with that Asperger's though.

larry allen would flat out destroy all four of them in an oklahoma drill.  that is without argument. 

[Paco 1960]

You have to include Phil "The Claw" Pozderac just for his holding prowess.

[Neonmoon 38130]

Brady, Brown, Rice, Taylor 

 

[Sgt Hulk 14449]

We still doing the sanders over smith shit.  Nice.  

[Saint Tacky 1647]

19 minutes ago, futureman said:

larry allen would flat out destroy all four of them in an oklahoma drill.  that is without argument. 

Perhaps, but I'm the douchebag that left the WR position out entirely.

[elfenix 34752]

montana is still on there.  yeah, brady has more rings, but 1) brady has never thrown a touchdown in the first quarter of a super bowl; 2) brady has never blown anyone out in a superbowl, let alone a hall of famer. 

[Machinator 32103]

Not sure if I would put Brees on the QB Rushmore, either. No love for Johnny U?

[futureman 22702]

2 minutes ago, elfenix said:

but 1) brady has never thrown a touchdown in the first quarter of a super bowl; 

[TornACL 7792]

My Mt Rushmore would be

Koy Detmer

Marion Butts

Steve Pelluer

Jeff Feagles

[elfenix 34752]

5 minutes ago, futureman said:

https://ftw.usatoday.com/2015/02/new-england-patriots-havent-scored-super-bowl-first-quarter

 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Bowl_LI

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Bowl_LII

 

edit: the 3 put on the board in the first quarter of LII was the first time they scored points at all in the first quarter of a superbowl under brady. 

Edited January 21, 2019 by elfenix

[futureman 22702]

3 minutes ago, elfenix said:

https://ftw.usatoday.com/2015/02/new-england-patriots-havent-scored-super-bowl-first-quarter

 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Bowl_LI

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Bowl_LII

I’m not questioning its veracity.  just its relevance.  

for example, I’d say the fact that he has won the game five times is a touch more relevant than his 1st quarter stats.  but that’s just me. 

Edited January 21, 2019 by futureman

[BurntOrangeCrush 1028]

Otto Graham

Jim Brown

Lawrence Taylor

Jerry Rice

[elfenix 34752]

Just now, futureman said:

I’m not questioning it’s veracity.  just it’s relevance.  

for example, I’d say the fact that he has won the game five times is a touch more relevant than his 1st quarter stats.  but that’s just me. 

it's relevant as to why you keep montana up there with 4 rings and having destroyed people in the SB. 

[futureman 22702]

Just now, elfenix said:

it's relevant as to why you keep montana up there with 4 rings and having destroyed people in the SB. 

5 > 4

can someone check my math?

[elfenix 34752]

Just now, futureman said:

5 > 4

can someone check my math?

brady is obviously on there too.

[kingkoopa6 8707]

Tom Brady, Barry Sanders, Jerry Rice, Deion Sanders