Top 3 cookie rankings

[Pancho 46054]

Clearly...

1.) sugar

2.) white chocolate macadamienasne nut

3.) chocolate chip pecan

hon. mention: oreos

[TwiceHorn 31987]

If you like buttery sugar cookies, you should try the Simply Made by Keebler.  Granted more like "shortbread," but simple and good.

[RMac5 1552]

Store bought would have to be

oreo 

nutter butter

pecan sandies

[futureman 22664]

the original oreo is clearly at the top.

then 

the tie for #3 is wide ranging

[utee94 16068]

Homemade:

1) Chocolate Chip

2) White chocolate chip with macadamia nuts

3) Peanut butter with the criss-cross marks on top

Commercial:

1) Caramel Delights aka Samoas

2) Oreos

3) Little Debbie Fudge Rounds

[Brew 3049]

Snickerdoodles, Snickerdoodles, and then probably Snickerdoodles.

[T’Boo Ted Marshall 2779]

Little Debbie Fudge Rounds

Non-qualifier.

[utee94 16068]

5 minutes ago, T’Boo Ted Marshall said:

Non-qualifier.

 

False

[T’Boo Ted Marshall 2779]

Patently false. They don’t even put them with the rest of the cookies. They get shunned over with lemon bars.

[utee94 16068]

2 minutes ago, T’Boo Ted Marshall said:

Patently false. They don’t even put them with the rest of the cookies. They get shunned over with lemon bars.

Until you name your top 3, you're nothing more than an ant at a picnic.  Man up, son.

[hopkinsnhorns 533]

Chocolate crinkle cookies

Chewy molasses cookies

Black and white cookies

Non-qualifying top contender - Whoopie pie


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[T’Boo Ted Marshall 2779]

Until you name your top 3, you're nothing more than an ant at a picnic.  Man up, son.

Not going the homemade route.
DS Oreo
OG Chips Ahoy
Tagalongs

[Surly Bevo 25658]

 

[hopkinsnhorns 533]

Honorable mention to the peanut better cookies w/ the Hershey’s Kisses.  Fucking love those cookies.

[Brew 3049]

36 minutes ago, hopkinsnhorns said:

Honorable mention to the peanut better cookies w/ the Hershey’s Kisses.  Fucking love those cookies.

Chocolate chip cooked in a muffin tin with a miniature Reese’s peanut butter cup puts those to shame.

[RPM 26562]

2 hours ago, hopkinsnhorns said:

Honorable mention to the peanut better cookies w/ the Hershey’s Kisses.  Fucking love those cookies.

Very this.

1 hour ago, Brew said:

Chocolate chip cooked in a muffin tin with a miniature Reese’s peanut butter cup puts those to shame.

Never heard of this. It's like finding my first Hustler. Everything has changed.

[pops 7121]

Jacques Torres Choc Chip

Granny B's Sugar Cookie

Sour cream sugar cookie

 

 

[elfenix 34658]

4 hours ago, Brew said:

Snickerdoodles, Snickerdoodles, and then probably Snickerdoodles.

you and i seem to have the exact same taste in junk food. how do you feel about buffalo pretzel pieces?

Edited February 20, 2019 by elfenix

[utee94 16068]

I don't like snickerdoodles.  There, I said it.

I recognize that there are many snickerdoodle devotees, and I'm not saying they suck or anything-- I just don't like them. 

 

[SurlyORama 165]

1. Oreos (original, not any of the abominations)

2. Keebler fudge stripes (how tiny a donut can you create by eating around the hole without breaking it?)

3. Lorna Doone

[TornACL 7792]

I feel bad for y'all who hear cookie rankings and immediately think of cookie brands.

Didn't anybody ever love you and make you homemade cookies? 

Chocolate chip (properly made) is the goat. And it's a big gulf between one and two. 

[Js1 86943]

10 hours ago, hopkinsnhorns said:

Honorable mention to the peanut better cookies w/ the Hershey’s Kisses.  Fucking love those cookies.

Hi, Nana!

1 hour ago, SurlyORama said:

1. Oreos (original, not any of the abominations)

2. Keebler fudge stripes (how tiny a donut can you create by eating around the hole without breaking it?)

3. Lorna Doone

Did we stop doing phrasing when we migrated from the scat site? 

[Don Johnson 4802]

>>>>

 

Edited February 20, 2019 by Don Johnson

[Kennythetiger 9584]

10 hours ago, Brew said:

Chocolate chip cooked in a muffin tin with a miniature Reese’s peanut butter cup puts those to shame.

Go on....

[Kennythetiger 9584]

11 hours ago, hopkinsnhorns said:

Honorable mention to the peanut better cookies w/ the Hershey’s Kisses.  Fucking love those cookies.

Someone gave me some the other day that had the Hershey's Kiss with an almond inside.  Delicious.  

[Kennythetiger 9584]

1.  Chocolate chip

2.  Peanut butter

3.  Sugar, with some really good frosting

Non-qualifier:  chocolate-dipped peanut butter balls

[utee05 9]

1) peanut butter
2) sugar
3) chocolate chip

[phdhorn 6224]

My favorite cookie right now, and I shit you not, is HCF"s soft chocolate chip cookies at HEB:

I don't know why nor how, but these things are gotdamn nectar of the gods with milk.

[smuggs 9394]

1 hour ago, TornACL said:

I feel bad for y'all who hear cookie rankings and immediately think of cookie brands.

Didn't anybody ever love you and make you homemade cookies? 

Chocolate chip (properly made) is the goat. And it's a big gulf between one and two. 

 

Everyone knows that homemade is the best. But how can I prove that my Grandma's chocolate chip is vastly superior to your mom's piece of shit Oatmeal Raisin?

Store bought is the only route to a universally accepted, certifiable belt. And this is The Champion:

 

 

[Hank_Hill 19772]

1 hour ago, Don Johnson said:

>>>>

 

What the fuck

[HouTex 1912]

Chocolate chip/chunk with extra chocolate and pecans

Chocolate chip/chunk with pecans

Chocolate chip/chunk

[Dutch 4533]

Home made:

1. Chocolate chip, with both morsels and chunks.

2. Peanut butter (extra credit for adding a few chocolate chunks).

3. Oatmeal raisin.

Store-bought:

1. Trader Joe's Cookie Butter Cookies.

2a. Double-stuf Oreo

2b. Oreo Duo (one chocolate cookie, one vanilla cookie)

3.  Walker's Shortbread

[C-Man 27685]

1. Any cookie from Tiff's Treats

2. Oatmeal chocolate chip from Potbelly

3. Everything else

[idigTexas 2321]

2 hours ago, HouTex said:

Chocolate chip/chunk with extra chocolate and pecans

Chocolate chip/chunk with pecans

Chocolate chip/chunk

This pretty much sums it up for me, though if I could add a fourth cookie, it would be the Oatmeal Cranberry Orange cookies from Central Market.

For mass produced national brands, I enjoy the following:

Original Chips Ahoy - frozen

Girl Scout Thin Mints - frozen

Pepperidge Farms Milano

[Onboard 2.0 9083]

Girl Scout thin mints....  for the win, frozen of course, served with ice cold whole milk.

[Brew 3049]

2 hours ago, C-Man said:

2. Oatmeal chocolate chip from Potbelly

This is the best chain restaraunt cookie. I’m not sure there is another one that is close.

On the homemade front, chocolate oatmeal cookies are a solid choice as well.

[DallasHorn26 587]

1. Peanut Butter w/chocolate chips.

2. Kitchen Sink Cookies

3. Oatmeal Raisin

[DallasHorn26 587]

3 hours ago, smuggs said:

 

Everyone knows that homemade is the best. But how can I prove that my Grandma's chocolate chip is vastly superior to your mom's piece of shit Oatmeal Raisin?

Store bought is the only route to a universally accepted, certifiable belt. And this is The Champion:

 

 

That's not double stuffed.

[Steamboat1874 4284]

>>>>>>>>> All other Oreo cookies combined.

[spystud13 2371]

Anyone seen these in the wild? Seems like an interesting twist. 

 

My current favorite is the Chewy Chips Ahoy. 

[SHOOTER12 8883]

7 hours ago, utee94 said:

I don't like snickerdoodles.  There, I said it.

I recognize that there are many snickerdoodle devotees, and I'm not saying they suck or anything-- I just don't like them. 

 

You sir are demented.

Snickerdoodles

Nestles Turtle cookies.

[Kennythetiger 9584]

3 hours ago, Brew said:

This is the best chain restaraunt cookie. I’m not sure there is another one that is close.

On the homemade front, chocolate oatmeal cookies are a solid choice as well.

Arbys, of all places, has a delicious salted caramel cookie.  I think of Chad Briscoe every time I'm in there. 

[The Dude 1257]

Oatmeal raisin

snickersoodle 

peanut butter

[utee94 16068]

The Doubletree chocolate chip was a tasty commercial option.  But I haven't stayed at a Doubletree in years, do they still do that?

[RMac5 1552]

I heard on the radio that Oreo has a buttered popcorn cookie, never have seen them in the store though. 

[WBT 20884]

I like a good ginger snap

[Onboard 2.0 9083]

16 minutes ago, WBT said:

I like a good ginger snap

Yeah like you can even find one....

[T’Boo Ted Marshall 2779]

I like a good ginger snap

You must be older than Armybrat

[TornACL 7792]

4 hours ago, spystud13 said:

Anyone seen these in the wild? Seems like an interesting twist. 

 

My current favorite is the Chewy Chips Ahoy. 

Isn't this basically an E.L. Fudge in Oreo form? 

[threesheets 1685]

I celebrate every cookie mentioned on here so I'm not going to bother naming a favorite.  I just came to say y'all need to try these hoes: