Jimbo 2021: Meemaw's Got a Brand New Bag

[NoName 16369]

2 minutes ago, Pato del Muerto said:

But that’s not true either

at least it has a 0.01% chance of being the case depending on where the other DBs on their depth chart are at any given point in time...maybe they are on vacation elsewhere

 

[Mdhorn 5984]

24 minutes ago, Lobwedgephil said:

  Hide contents

Jason Howell

7:12a 

Staff

*A few weeks later and it still amazes me the Aggies landed McKinnley Jackson - I know you're saying but Jason we're onto 2021 now, and I'm saying shut it because I want to talk about landing McKinnley Jackson. Going into deep south Mississippi and fighting off Alabama and LSU for the top unsigned DT in the late signing period is as big as it gets in the recruiting world. The fact no one else saw it coming only makes it sweeter for the Aggies. It was yet another big, bold, Jimbo Fisher recruiting power play. He's made several since he arrived and the Aggies are recruiting at a national championship level. I'm not saying you have to agree with every move made, because I haven't, but Jimbo Fisher has shown there's reason to trust the great majority of his decision making on the recruiting trail. 

*Early official visits - someone asked for thoughts about prospects taking spring official visits earlier this week. To me it depends on the recruit. You have to know where you're at with the prospect and what commitment means to them. It certainly worked out well with Demarvin Leal and Erick Young in 2019, and in 2020 it proved effective for Muhsin Muhammad. Getting guys on campus is a must in the recruiting game, and if you can do that, make the big impression, and lock in a top prospect then you've accomplished the goal. So, I don't have a problem with it at all, and I think it can work out really well if done right.

*Some 2021 thoughts
-CB Deuce Harmon is my highest confidence pick to join the Aggies' class right now.
-I still like the Aggies' chances with guys like Reuben Fatheree, Bryce Foster, Shemar Turner, Landon Jackson, Marcus Burris, Jordon Thomas, and Ishmael Ibraheem. I'm not ready to put them all on commit watch, but these are all guys I believe the Aggies will get on campus again soon, and will be squarely in the mix for when it comes to decision making time.
-WR Ketron Jackson is another guy I feel like the Aggies have a great shot with after my interview. Coach Craig has done a great job there and the Super Bowl weekend has the Aggies very high on his list.
-One thing we've come to expect is a nice dose of out of state recruiting, and I don't expect that to change in 2021.
-Texas A&M will also have a strong in-state presence. 

 

Recap--if done right, aggy can pay both in state and out of state prospects during their early official or late visits and have a shot at landing them. 

Edited February 21, 2020 by Mdhorn

[Focht Up 631]

Wouldn't Sloneal's blazing speed be put to better use at CB instead of safety?

[Tex Pete 20430]

1 hour ago, golfclap said:

*ahem* 

 

Leon clearly doesn't understand that the best DBs are the ones people DON'T notice. Drawing attention to yourself (by chasing a receiver from 5 yards behind or tweeting stupid shit) isn't the way to go. There is only one Deion Sanders in the world.

[SHOOTER12 8819]

1 hour ago, gernblansten said:

He didn't say which country?  Maybe he's just out in the middle of nowhere?

He misspelled slowest.

[Fud 9552]

I like the idea of naming the award for slowest DB in the country the Jim Thrope Award 

[Fud 9552]

1 hour ago, Lobwedgephil said:

-WR Ketron Jackson is another guy I feel like the Aggies have a great shot with after my interview. Coach Craig has done a great job there and the Super Bowl weekend has the Aggies very high on his list.

This kid has some sort of red flags, although I don't know the details. Maybe grades? Either way, should fight right in there. 

[Bevo14 8364]

56 minutes ago, Tex Pete said:

Leon clearly doesn't understand that the best DBs are the ones people DON'T notice. Drawing attention to yourself (by chasing a receiver from 5 yards behind or tweeting stupid shit) isn't the way to go. There is only one Deion Sanders in the world.

They also tend to run sub 5 40s

[Elmer_Fudd 22313]

Aggy hired Tommie Robinson as the new RB coach.

[PHLaggie 110]

22 minutes ago, Elmer_Fudd said:

Aggy hired Tommie Robinson as the new RB coach.

finally!

who is he?

*runs over to google*

https://www.theadvocate.com/baton_rouge/sports/lsu/article_bff83fbe-576a-11ea-b7f5-5fd967314fab.html

maybe decent option?

 

Edited February 25, 2020 by PHLaggie

[victory88 5669]

So Texas and aggy both hired failed coaches from each other’s schools?

[Dijon Robinson 1511]

32 minutes ago, Elmer_Fudd said:

Aggy hired Tommie Robinson as the new RB coach.

Not a terrible hire imo, although Robinson was being forced out...

 

[Elmer_Fudd 22313]

1 minute ago, victory88 said:

So Texas and aggy both hired failed coaches from each other’s schools?

Looch has yet to put out a sunshine pumping tweet.

Tigerdroppings saying his contract wasn't renewed and that he interviewed for South Carolina RB coach position, but didn't get it.

[Burt Macklin 19038]

18 minutes ago, PHLaggie said:

finally!

who is he?

*runs over to google*

https://www.theadvocate.com/baton_rouge/sports/lsu/article_bff83fbe-576a-11ea-b7f5-5fd967314fab.html

maybe decent option?

 

He coached at Texas for a bit, but was pretty underwhelming and a much worse recruiter than his reputation suggested. IIRC, he had some good success recruiting to USC after Texas.  Based on everything I've read, Coach O was letting him go, so that's probably not a great sign. 

I'd give that hire a very solid meh for A&M. 

[Lobwedgephil 1139]

Spoiler

Liucci

7:03p 

Staff

AG

...by adding former LSU assistant Tommie Robinson as the Ags' new running backs coach. 

This completes the Ags' 2020 staff and I think it's safe to say Fisher has upgraded from top-to-bottom and that this is very likely his best staff - in terms of on the field and in the recruiting front - in three seasons at the helm in College Station. 

Robinson's work at LSU stands out (he helped take Derius Guice from lightly-regraded recruit for record-setting runner and turned Clyde Edwards-Helaire into one of the nations best this fall) but he was also named the Pac-12 recruiter of the year at USC. Very strong hire by Fisher and the Ags. More thoughts to follow.

 

 

[texifornia 57077]

3 minutes ago, Lobwedgephil said:

  Hide contents

Liucci

7:03p 

Staff

AG

...by adding former LSU assistant Tommie Robinson as the Ags' new running backs coach. 

This completes the Ags' 2020 staff and I think it's safe to say Fisher has upgraded from top-to-bottom and that this is very likely his best staff - in terms of on the field and in the recruiting front - in three seasons at the helm in College Station. 

Robinson's work at LSU stands out (he helped take Derius Guice from lightly-regraded recruit for record-setting runner and turned Clyde Edwards-Helaire into one of the nations best this fall) but he was also named the Pac-12 recruiter of the year at USC. Very strong hire by Fisher and the Ags. More thoughts to follow.

 

 

I swear to God he just has an AI auto-generating his articles at this point

[fattyflattie 4638]

Wonder if he’ll mention juggernaut South Carolina passing on him before they hired him?

[texifornia 57077]

Between Robinson and Hagan, we're just mirroring each other - hiring an old dud from their rival who rehabilitated (but not really) their career elsewhere.

[Getafix 28778]

 

LIUCCI

"Robinson's work at LSU stands out (he helped take Derius Guice from lightly-regraded recruit for record-setting runner"

******************************************************************************

Assuming Liucci meant "lightly-regarded to record-setting runner" ... 

Derrius Guice was the #45 overall recruit in the nation (and 4th highest in LSU's class).

 

 

 

[theaveragejon 988]

40 minutes ago, Lobwedgephil said:

  Hide contents

Liucci

7:03p 

Staff

AG

...by adding former LSU assistant Tommie Robinson as the Ags' new running backs coach. 

This completes the Ags' 2020 staff and I think it's safe to say Fisher has upgraded from top-to-bottom and that this is very likely his best staff - in terms of on the field and in the recruiting front - in three seasons at the helm in College Station. 

Robinson's work at LSU stands out (he helped take Derius Guice from lightly-regraded recruit for record-setting runner and turned Clyde Edwards-Helaire into one of the nations best this fall) but he was also named the Pac-12 recruiter of the year at USC. Very strong hire by Fisher and the Ags. More thoughts to follow.

 

 

Guice lightly regarded?! He was .97 on 247, was the number 5 back in the nation and had an offer from Bamma. Is he fuckin high?!

[GRHorn 105]

43 minutes ago, Getafix said:

 

LIUCCI

"Robinson's work at LSU stands out (he helped take Derius Guice from lightly-regraded recruit for record-setting runner"

******************************************************************************

Assuming Liucci meant "lightly-regarded to record-setting runner" ... 

Derrius Guice was the #45 overall recruit in the nation (and 4th highest in LSU's class).

 

 

 

The stupid fucking hurts, it’s so bad 

[Beau Vine 54381]

1 hour ago, texifornia said:

I swear to God he just has an AI auto-generating his articles at this point

You don't think an actual human could pull of that level of consistent stupidity, do you?

[Beau Vine 54381]

28 minutes ago, theaveragejon said:

Guice lightly regarded?! He was .97 on 247, was the number 5 back in the nation and had an offer from Bamma. Is he fuckin high?!

What's the significance of that fucking horseshit?  Guice was only #41 in the Liucci 44.  

[theaveragejon 988]

12 minutes ago, Beau Vine said:

You don't think an actual human could pull of that level of consistent stupidity, do you?

Aggy could 

[Chad 1728]

Chin pubes Looch consults with Taylor Hamm in the shit house to compile his recruiting rankings, which are the only rankings that matter if you ask any aggy. Rivals sucks a lot of dicks these days, but their work is vastly superior compared to Looch's biased rankings.

[SydneyCarton 48150]

8 hours ago, Elmer_Fudd said:

Aggy hired Tommie Robinson as the new RB coach.

Ha. Robinson has been good to great everywhere except Texas. He was good at USC, and fucking tremendous at LSU. The operating theory is he’s great when a school is paying kids. Let’s see how his second round in Texas goes. Because he was a fucking worthless dildo while he was here. 

[SydneyCarton 48150]

7 hours ago, Lobwedgephil said:

  Hide contents

Liucci

7:03p 

Staff

AG

...by adding former LSU assistant Tommie Robinson as the Ags' new running backs coach. 

This completes the Ags' 2020 staff and I think it's safe to say Fisher has upgraded from top-to-bottom and that this is very likely his best staff - in terms of on the field and in the recruiting front - in three seasons at the helm in College Station. 

Robinson's work at LSU stands out (he helped take Derius Guice from lightly-regraded recruit for record-setting runner and turned Clyde Edwards-Helaire into one of the nations best this fall) but he was also named the Pac-12 recruiter of the year at USC. Very strong hire by Fisher and the Ags. More thoughts to follow.

 

 

Did he just cal Darrius Guice, high 4 star and top 50 player in his class “lightly regarded?” 
 

theres only one regard referenced in that post and it’s the fucking author. 

[Burt Macklin 19038]

2 hours ago, SydneyCarton said:

Ha. Robinson has been good to great everywhere except Texas. He was good at USC, and fucking tremendous at LSU. The operating theory is he’s great when a school is paying kids. Let’s see how his second round in Texas goes. Because he was a fucking worthless dildo while he was here. 

You think he’s been great at LSU? They weren’t going to renew his contract... 

[SydneyCarton 48150]

14 minutes ago, Burt Macklin said:

You think he’s been great at LSU? They weren’t going to renew his contract... 

Because they like Faulk better. Tell me which part about RB recruiting or production you’d be critical of at LSU during his tenure? Is LSU plug and play? Maybe. Probably. But dude is the rb coach, and rb recruiting and production have been outstanding there. How exactly are you going to shit on him? 
 

Unless it’s a Mehringer situation there and he didn’t recruit any of their players for real, which we haven’t heard anything like that, wheres the beef? At worst he’s a Stan Drayton non volume recruiter maybe? 

Edited February 25, 2020 by SydneyCarton

[closetojumping 62785]

7 minutes ago, SydneyCarton said:

Because they like Faulk better. Tell me which part about RB recruiting or production you’d be critical of at LSU during his tenure? Is LSU plug and play? Maybe. Probably. But dude is the rb coach, and rb recruiting and production have been outstanding there. How exactly are you going to shit on him? 

You doubt the wisdom of a one Sir Edgart Reginald Orgeron, IV, at your own peril, sir. Burt Macklin is merely giving credit where credit is due. LSU just won a national title in large part because of Sir Orgy’s profound and repeatable personnel management genius. 

Perhaps it’s time for you to push away for a minute from worshipping at the altar of Saint Thomastard the Hermanticore and see who the dominant mental wizards in college football really are. 

Edited February 25, 2020 by closetojumping
meh persian mythological spelling

[Bevo14 8364]

10 hours ago, theaveragejon said:

Guice lightly regarded?! He was .97 on 247, was the number 5 back in the nation and had an offer from Bamma. Is he fuckin high?!

Unlike Guice, Looch is highly regarded.

Edited February 25, 2020 by Bevo14

[texifornia 57077]

Hah, they're trying to make their own Grove

 

[NoName 16369]

11 hours ago, texifornia said:

I swear to God he just has an AI auto-generating his articles at this point

Billy Liucci couldn't spell AI if you spotted him the A

[bizzle 1153]

4 hours ago, SydneyCarton said:

Ha. Robinson has been good to great everywhere except Texas. He was good at USC, and fucking tremendous at LSU. The operating theory is he’s great when a school is paying kids. 

based on how many checks this board says we're writing, he's going to be fucking awesome. 

[PHLaggie 110]

1 hour ago, texifornia said:

Hah, they're trying to make their own Grove

 

As a tree advocate and volunteer, anything that brings more tree canopy to College Station has my support. If they're lucky the trees will be large with enough canopy to cover up some of the atrocious architecture from at least some of the lines of sight/viewsheds.

 

[PHLaggie 110]

12 hours ago, texifornia said:

Between Robinson and Hagan, we're just mirroring each other - hiring an old dud from their rival who rehabilitated (but not really) their career elsewhere.

[texifornia 57077]

Just now, PHLaggie said:

As a tree advocate and volunteer, anything that brings more tree canopy to College Station has my support. If they're lucky the trees will be large with enough canopy to cover up some of the atrocious architecture from at least some of the lines of sight/viewsheds.

 

It's a good idea. The execution could be interesting in terms of how natural and lush it can look and getting real shade cover. Obviously growing a nice forest is easier in Mississippi.

[Burt Macklin 19038]

2 hours ago, SydneyCarton said:

Tell me which part about RB recruiting or production you’d be critical of at LSU during his tenure? Is LSU plug and play? Maybe. Probably. But dude is the rb coach, and rb recruiting and production have been outstanding there. How exactly are you going to shit on him? 

Lulz. I didn’t shit on him. I said he was a pretty meh hire. Not great, not terrible. You’re the one who said he’s been good to great everywhere he’s been except Texas. 

This cant really be your standard, can it? Show me bad RB production and recruiting at LSU at any point in the last 20 years. He gets gifted guys like Emery and Guice, who even Todd Orlando could’ve landed if he was the RB coach at LSU. As for production levels, that’s much more dependent on the OC and the overall offense. He had some good recruiting victories at USC, but Tee Martin was listed as the secondary recruiter on most of those recruitments, so it’s hard to know if Robinson landed those guys or if it was more of a Mehringer gets credit for Jake Smith kind of situation. He doesn’t appear to be much of a volume recruiter, and he’s not God’s gift to RBs as far as coaching goes. 

I’m not saying he’s horrible, but the points you bring up about LSU are not meaningful indicators as to how he’ll do elsewhere.

2 hours ago, SydneyCarton said:

At worst he’s a Stan Drayton non volume recruiter maybe? 

I’d say Drayton, a guy who many people would prefer to replace, is a decent comp but not at worst. Robinson’s had some good RBs and has a long history as a RB coach. When he’s at a school that recruits well and pays, he does pretty well, but he’s not otherwise great. 
 

2 hours ago, closetojumping said:

You doubt the wisdom of a one Sir Edgart Reginald Orgeron, IV, at your own peril, sir. Burt Macklin is merely giving credit where credit is due. LSU just won a national title in large part because of Sir Orgy’s profound and repeatable personnel management genius. 

Perhaps it’s time for you to push away for a minute from worshipping at the altar of Saint Thomastard the Hermanticore and see who the dominant mental wizards in college football really are. 

Idk what is going on with this bloviating attempt at humor, but do you actually think Tommie Robinson is a good hire by ole Jimbo?

[SHOOTER12 8819]

41 minutes ago, PHLaggie said:

As a tree advocate and volunteer, anything that brings more tree canopy to College Station has my support. If they're lucky the trees will be large with enough canopy to cover up some of the atrocious architecture from at least some of the lines of sight/viewsheds.

 

They will probably plant live oaks so they will have shade in a hundred years or so...

[Lobwedgephil 1139]

Spoiler

Liucci

11:11p, 2/24/20 

Staff

AG

Feel however you want about the hire but if you choose to believe everything coming out of Baton Rouge then that's your prerogative.  

I've maintained all along that Ed O isn't the easiest head coach to work for and stand by that. There's a reason Raymond - an LSU lifer - has reached out to A&M twice and it hasn't just been in an effort to get a raise. Same with Aranda jumping into the mix before Fisher closed out Elko at Notre Dame.

So you can believe that LSU was so fired up about promoting Kevin Faulk, an LSU legend but one who has never been on the recruiting trail or been a college position coach, that they 'pushed Robinson out' or you can believe that Tommie was looking around, which was why he at one point appeared South Carolina-bound and ultimately landed at A&M. Muschamp was hoping he could make the hire but the Gamecocks were unable to close. And rumor out of Baton Rouge is that Orgeron actually did try to counter-offer the Ags in the last couple of days but it wasn't enough to keep Robinson on the Bayou.  

Folks, this will be a he-said, she-said in which you'll have to choose to believe what you want. What I don't get is the folks who have seen what Jimbo Fisher and A&M are capable of in terms of hire yet still default to always 'believing the other side.' We have some on here who will voluntarily buy the Purple and Gold narrative from fans, message board fanatics and LSU insiders simply 'because.' Many of the same folks who were miserable and skeptical throughout the run towards the nation's No. 6-ranked class in the 2020 recruiting race.

All that really matters is whether or not Fisher and the Aggies landed a damn good position coach and recruiter and Robinson's resume screams as much. He could absolutely turn out to be an upgrade on the recruiting front and his development of Clyde Edwards-Helaire was very impressive, as was turning Nick Brossette into a 1,000-yard rusher in the SEC in 2018. Fisher considered no fewer than three current SEC assistants (including the eventual hire) and a prominent NFL assistant looking to get back to the college game before making his choice. All four would have likely taken the job and the options were impressive so quite a bit went into the decision.

As I said earlier today, what Fisher did in terms of upgrading his entire staff with the four new additions was really damn impressive. He was patient and went out and made hires from LSU, Florida State and Georgia (x2) and brought back a young linebackers coach hand-picked by his defensive coordinator and being groomed as a future Power 5 DC.  

Fisher knocked it out of the park this go-round and you're about to see the impact on the 2021 recruiting front prior to the upcoming season...with Tommie Robinson playing a key role, LSU stans be damned.

 

[Pato del Muerto 52571]

Lol so now aranda and Raymond wanted in, and aggy stole Robinson from LSU AND South Carolina.  

[NoName 16369]

8 minutes ago, Lobwedgephil said:

  Hide contents

Liucci

11:11p, 2/24/20 

Staff

AG

Feel however you want about the hire but if you choose to believe everything coming out of Baton Rouge then that's your prerogative.  

I've maintained all along that Ed O isn't the easiest head coach to work for and stand by that. There's a reason Raymond - an LSU lifer - has reached out to A&M twice and it hasn't just been in an effort to get a raise. Same with Aranda jumping into the mix before Fisher closed out Elko at Notre Dame.

So you can believe that LSU was so fired up about promoting Kevin Faulk, an LSU legend but one who has never been on the recruiting trail or been a college position coach, that they 'pushed Robinson out' or you can believe that Tommie was looking around, which was why he at one point appeared South Carolina-bound and ultimately landed at A&M. Muschamp was hoping he could make the hire but the Gamecocks were unable to close. And rumor out of Baton Rouge is that Orgeron actually did try to counter-offer the Ags in the last couple of days but it wasn't enough to keep Robinson on the Bayou.  

Folks, this will be a he-said, she-said in which you'll have to choose to believe what you want. What I don't get is the folks who have seen what Jimbo Fisher and A&M are capable of in terms of hire yet still default to always 'believing the other side.' We have some on here who will voluntarily buy the Purple and Gold narrative from fans, message board fanatics and LSU insiders simply 'because.' Many of the same folks who were miserable and skeptical throughout the run towards the nation's No. 6-ranked class in the 2020 recruiting race.

All that really matters is whether or not Fisher and the Aggies landed a damn good position coach and recruiter and Robinson's resume screams as much. He could absolutely turn out to be an upgrade on the recruiting front and his development of Clyde Edwards-Helaire was very impressive, as was turning Nick Brossette into a 1,000-yard rusher in the SEC in 2018. Fisher considered no fewer than three current SEC assistants (including the eventual hire) and a prominent NFL assistant looking to get back to the college game before making his choice. All four would have likely taken the job and the options were impressive so quite a bit went into the decision.

As I said earlier today, what Fisher did in terms of upgrading his entire staff with the four new additions was really damn impressive. He was patient and went out and made hires from LSU, Florida State and Georgia (x2) and brought back a young linebackers coach hand-picked by his defensive coordinator and being groomed as a future Power 5 DC.  

Fisher knocked it out of the park this go-round and you're about to see the impact on the 2021 recruiting front prior to the upcoming season...with Tommie Robinson playing a key role, LSU stans be damned.

 

Quote

All that really matters is whether or not Fisher and the Aggies landed a damn good position coach and recruiter and Robinson's resume screams as much. 

isn't he known as an excellent recruiter and a sub par position coach?

 

[NoName 16369]

5 minutes ago, Pato del Muerto said:

Lol so now aranda and Raymond wanted in, and aggy stole Robinson from LSU AND South Carolina.  

Raymond has reached out twice, not left either time and IIRC received a bump from LSU both times.

but sure he didn't want to just get a raise. it's why he is the DB coach at THE university of Texas A&M #LitStation

 

...right?

[Beau Vine 54381]

19 minutes ago, Lobwedgephil said:

Muschamp was hoping he could make the hire but the Gamecocks were unable to close. And rumor out of Baton Rouge is that Orgeron actually did try to counter-offer the Ags in the last couple of days but it wasn't enough to keep Robinson on the Bayou.  

Folks, this will be a he-said, she-said in which you'll have to choose to believe what you want.  What I don't get is the folks who have seen what Jimbo Fisher and A&M are capable of in terms of hire yet still default to always 'believing the other side.' We have some on here who will voluntarily buy the Purple and Gold narrative from fans, message board fanatics and LSU insiders simply 'because.' Many of the same folks who were miserable and skeptical throughout the run towards the nation's No. 6-ranked class in the 2020 recruiting race.

 

This one is an all-timer, even for someone as prolific as Looch.

Edited February 25, 2020 by Beau Vine

[Dbeasy 15084]

Looch reads this thread and has to immediately course correct everything he writes.

[SydneyCarton 48150]

55 minutes ago, Burt Macklin said:

Lulz. I didn’t shit on him. I said he was a pretty meh hire. Not great, not terrible. You’re the one who said he’s been good to great everywhere he’s been except Texas. 

This cant really be your standard, can it? Show me bad RB production and recruiting at LSU at any point in the last 20 years. He gets gifted guys like Emery and Guice, who even Todd Orlando could’ve landed if he was the RB coach at LSU. As for production levels, that’s much more dependent on the OC and the overall offense. He had some good recruiting victories at USC, but Tee Martin was listed as the secondary recruiter on most of those recruitments, so it’s hard to know if Robinson landed those guys or if it was more of a Mehringer gets credit for Jake Smith kind of situation. He doesn’t appear to be much of a volume recruiter, and he’s not God’s gift to RBs as far as coaching goes. 

I’m not saying he’s horrible, but the points you bring up about LSU are not meaningful indicators as to how he’ll do elsewhere.

I’d say Drayton, a guy who many people would prefer to replace, is a decent comp but not at worst. Robinson’s had some good RBs and has a long history as a RB coach. When he’s at a school that recruits well and pays, he does pretty well, but he’s not otherwise great. 
 

Idk what is going on with this bloviating attempt at humor, but do you actually think Tommie Robinson is a good hire by ole Jimbo?

Oh hey, thanks for basically rehashing all the things possibilities I addressed in my post as the reasons you're contending with my post:
-LSU not being an apples to apples comparison with any other recruiting area - Check
-Tee Martin gets credit for all of his recruits at USC, Mehringer situation - Check
-Potentially not a volume recruiter - Check
-Robinson does well at a school that pays - Check

I mean I literally covered all this shit before your response. So thanks for the trip down memory lane of my own posts this morning. 

Listen, you claim you're not shitting on it, but the direct post I quoted was literally "He didn't get retained by LSU." I'm pretty sure that's saying a coach was shit at this job. Or do you want to go down the list of guys Herman just "didn't retain" that did really, really good jobs at Texas and weren't shit? Please clarify what you were implying with that post, because to me, it doesn't translate to "Ok Hire."

Let me clarify the slant I was aiming for in my original set of posts: By what metric exactly would you measure a successful position coach? He's had success at multiple schools, has recruiting victories everywhere but Texas, and has put guys in the NFL consistently. Now, there area always outliers as we've seen at the fucktards who show up pointing at Mehringer's recruiter of the year bullshit, but I mean, it sounds like you're literally saying Tommie Robinson is Drew Mehringer, and we can't evaluate the guy at any level of his job because of special circumstances. Well, okay, if that's where your head at is on this, that's fine. But by any conceivable metric Robinson has been very successful everywhere but Texas. 

And for the record, I think he'll be just okay at aTm. But at least he'll be able to point to all the guys he's sent to the NFL recently. Mark Hagen is going to walk into a recruits living room, let out a huge fucking trombone style fart that lasts 15 seconds, and then he's going to look in either direction and nod his head towards one of the kid's parents when they ask about who he's coached in the NFL. 




 

[Hornsfan91 181]

I know for sure Robinson wasn’t well received by his own RB room. Edwards-Helaire even cussed him out during film sessions. Emery freshman season is due to Robinson and Emery himself. Emery would fall asleep during film hence why he wasn’t much active all year. But The development of those running backs came from Faulk, who I believe will be much better than Robinson. 

[golfclap 6903]

11 minutes ago, Lobwedgephil said:

There's a reason Raymond - an LSU lifer - has reached out to A&M twice and it hasn't just been in an effort to get a raise.

 

So Looch is saying that Raymond wanted the Aggy gig twice and Jimbo turned him down for Linguist and Rushing? That's what he's going with? Because that would be quite the indictment on Jimbo. Looch, you may want to walk this one back on your podcast or one of your next threads. Yes, we know you are reading surly. (Hi Hamm!!) 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[SydneyCarton 48150]

The word on Faulk is extremely high, thus far, and he did an extensive amount of coaching with the staff this past year, so it's pretty easy to see how Orgeron could have a good look at who he was placing his money on for the future and came up strongly in favor of Faulk. We heard his praises during the season even over here. He's young, he's had a decade plus career in the NFL with the fucking Patriots, he's born and bred in Louisiana, he starred at LSU. If he was a net positive in the RB room and doesn't suffer from Wareheim syndrome on the trail he's going to be an A++ hire for those guys. 

Edited February 25, 2020 by SydneyCarton

[Burt Macklin 19038]

13 minutes ago, SydneyCarton said:

Oh hey, thanks for basically rehashing all the things possibilities I addressed in my post as the reasons you're contending with my post:
-LSU not being an apples to apples comparison with any other recruiting area - Check
-Tee Martin gets credit for all of his recruits at USC, Mehringer situation - Check
-Potentially not a volume recruiter - Check
-Robinson does well at a school that pays - Check

I mean I literally covered all this shit before your response. So thanks for the trip down memory lane of my own posts this morning. 

Listen, you claim you're not shitting on it, but the direct post I quoted was literally "He didn't get retained by LSU." I'm pretty sure that's saying a coach was shit at this job. Or do you want to go down the list of guys Herman just "didn't retain" that did really, really good jobs at Texas and weren't shit? Please clarify what you were implying with that post, because to me, it doesn't translate to "Ok Hire."

Let me clarify the slant I was aiming for in my original set of posts: By what metric exactly would you measure a successful position coach? He's had success at multiple schools, has recruiting victories everywhere but Texas, and has put guys in the NFL consistently. Now, there area always outliers as we've seen at the fucktards who show up pointing at Mehringer's recruiter of the year bullshit, but I mean, it sounds like you're literally saying Tommie Robinson is Drew Mehringer, and we can't evaluate the guy at any level of his job because of special circumstances. Well, okay, if that's where your head at is on this, that's fine. But by any conceivable metric Robinson has been very successful everywhere but Texas. 

And for the record, I think he'll be just okay at aTm. But at least he'll be able to point to all the guys he's sent to the NFL recently. Mark Hagen is going to walk into a recruits living room, let out a huge fucking trombone style fart that lasts 15 seconds, and then he's going to look in either direction and nod his head towards one of the kid's parents when they ask about who he's coached in the NFL. 




 

Tl;dr. And I don’t really care about this topic enough. I think he’s fine. Not great, not terrible. Saying he was going to be retained, which is true, isn’t shitting on him. It’s merry stating a fact. 

I never said he was like Mehringer; that’s just a straw man you created to try to dig yourself out of the pit of word vomit you’re currently rolling around in.